11 New Jersey Candy Shops With Imported Treats From Around the World

A bag of sour watermelon skulls in Princeton, a salty Dutch licorice roll in Sussex, and a British chocolate bar…

11 New Jersey Candy Shops With Imported Treats From Around the World

A bag of sour watermelon skulls in Princeton, a salty Dutch licorice roll in Sussex, and a British chocolate bar in Montclair can all be found without crossing the Hudson, never mind the Atlantic. New Jersey’s international candy scene is scattered in the best possible way.

Some shops specialize almost entirely in sweets from one country, while others hide impressive imported candy sections between homemade chocolates, baked goods, groceries, and enough nostalgic American sugar to keep everyone happy. That variety makes browsing half the fun.

You might walk in looking for gummies and leave with Turkish halva, Polish marshmallow candy, Japanese Kit Kats, or the kind of licorice that makes even devoted licorice fans reconsider their limits. These 11 New Jersey shops are worth knowing when the usual supermarket candy aisle feels a little too predictable and you want your next sugar run to come with a few surprises.

1. Tiger Treats, Princeton: A Small-Treat Adventure

Tiger Treats, Princeton: A Small-Treat Adventure
© Tiger Treats

Princeton has a little corner of Sweden hiding just off Nassau Street, and the setup is wonderfully simple: grab a bag, pick up the tongs, and start making difficult decisions. Tiger Treats specializes in Swedish-style pick-and-mix candy, with bins filled with colorful gummies, foamy sweets, sour pieces, licorice, and shapes that look considerably more entertaining than the standard bagged candy lineup.

Many of the candies come directly from Sweden, and labels identifying origins and whether a piece leans sweet or sour make experimenting easy. The fun here is building a bag piece by piece rather than committing to an entire package of something unfamiliar.

Try a few fruit gummies, add something aggressively sour, then throw in one of the Scandinavian licorice varieties just to see where you stand on the subject. Watermelon skulls, fizzy fruit candies, larger Swedish-style fish, and chewy foam pieces are the sort of finds that give the shop its personality.

The space itself is tiny, so this is more candy stop than leisurely shopping expedition, especially when Princeton is busy. That actually suits the concept.

You can be in and out with a highly customized haul before lunch, although anyone who enjoys comparing textures and flavors may spend longer staring into the bins than expected.

2. Lolli & Pops, Bridgewater: Make the Wrapper Part of the Fun

Lolli & Pops, Bridgewater: Make the Wrapper Part of the Fun
© Lolli & Pops

Walk into the Bridgewater Commons location with a strict plan and there is a good chance that plan will collapse somewhere between the gummy wall and the international sweets. Lolli & Pops takes a polished, gift-shop approach to candy, pairing jars, tins, truffles, and bulk selections with treats sourced from well beyond the United States.

Its international lineup has included country-focused collections from Japan, Sweden, Korea, and Greece, along with dedicated selections of European and Asian sweets. Japanese Kit Kats in flavors rarely spotted in ordinary supermarkets are especially fun targets, while Swedish-style gummies offer a completely different texture from the familiar American versions.

The shop also carries plenty of chocolates, licorice, sour candy, and elaborate packaged sweets that make it useful when you need a gift but would rather avoid the predictable box of assorted chocolates. Prices tend to reflect the presentation and specialty sourcing, so this is not necessarily the place for filling a pillowcase on a budget.

Instead, pick a few things you have never tried or build a mixed assortment. Because the store sits inside Bridgewater Commons, it is also an easy addition to an ordinary shopping trip rather than a special excursion.

That accessibility makes it one of the easiest places in central New Jersey to start exploring international candy without having to know exactly what you are looking for.

3. Black River Candy Shoppe, Chester: Follow Your Sweet Tooth

Black River Candy Shoppe, Chester: Follow Your Sweet Tooth
© Black River Candy Shoppe

The old oak whiskey barrels are the first clue that this is not going to feel like a fluorescent mall candy store. Hidden behind the storefronts at 44 Main Street in Chester, Black River Candy Shoppe occupies a red barn-like building packed with more than 1,000 varieties of candy, mixing imported finds with bulk sweets, retro favorites, chocolates, and the sort of oddball treats you may remember from childhood.

Its strength is sheer range. One bin might send you back several decades, while another turns up something from overseas that is considerably harder to find in a regular grocery store.

British Curly Wurly bars, with their braided caramel covered in chocolate, are one imported treat that has appeared in the shop’s rotating inventory and perfectly captures why candy hunters like browsing here. You never quite know which forgotten or unfamiliar wrapper will jump out next.

The old-fashioned setting adds to the treasure-hunt effect, with candy crowded into a space decorated with antiques and memorabilia rather than arranged like a modern supermarket aisle. Give yourself time to look instead of arriving with one specific item in mind, because stock changes and discovery is the real draw.

Chester’s walkable downtown also makes this an easy stop to pair with lunch, antique browsing, or a weekend afternoon around Main Street. Just remember that the store sits toward the back of the parking area rather than directly along the street.

4. Sweet Expressions by Geri, Denville: Give Candy a Personal Touch

Sweet Expressions by Geri, Denville: Give Candy a Personal Touch
© Sweet Expressions By Geri

There is something fitting about finding a candy shop inside Denville’s historic movie theater building. Sweet Expressions by Geri has been feeding local sugar cravings for more than three decades, and the selection goes far beyond a row of wrapped chocolate bars.

Handmade chocolates and truffles share space with gummies, licorice, retro candy, macarons, brownies, cookies, chocolate-dipped fruit, and gift-ready sweets, so it works particularly well for a group in which everyone defines “candy” differently. The international side is more of a rotating treasure hunt than a rigid specialty department, which is exactly why it is worth checking the shelves rather than shopping from a mental list.

Scandinavian-style gummies, licorice, European-inspired confections, and novelty imports can turn up alongside classic American favorites, while the shop’s own chocolate creations keep the selection anchored in Denville. Anyone interested specifically in imported treats should browse the gummy and licorice sections first and ask what has recently arrived, since specialty candy inventory can shift quickly.

The setting helps too. Sweet Expressions sits right in downtown Denville, where grabbing a bag of candy can easily become part of an afternoon wandering Broadway instead of a drive-in, drive-out errand.

If you are shopping for someone else, this is also one of the stronger stops on the list because almost everything seems capable of becoming a gift with very little effort.

5. Planet Candy, Seaside Heights: A Boardwalk Flavor Quest

Planet Candy, Seaside Heights: A Boardwalk Flavor Quest
© Planet Candy Frozen Yogurt & Ice Cream

Saltwater taffy would be the obvious move on the Seaside Heights boardwalk, but Planet Candy gives you plenty of reasons to wander beyond the Shore classics. Family-owned since 1997, the shop has grown into a sprawling sweets stop where more than 30 kinds of candy apples sit alongside fudge, chocolates, gummies, taffy, ice cream, and a notable selection of Swedish candy.

That last category is the reason curious candy shoppers should slow down instead of treating the place as another boardwalk sugar stop. Swedish sweets tend to play with texture as much as flavor, moving between chewy fruit gummies, foamy pieces, sour coatings, and licorice, so putting together a mixed bag is more interesting than grabbing one familiar package.

Planet Candy works especially well when you are shopping with people who cannot agree on dessert. Someone can go for imported gummies, another can order fudge or a candy apple, and another can skip candy completely for soft serve or Italian ice.

It is located directly on the Seaside Heights boardwalk at 615 Boardwalk, making it an easy stop between rides, beach time, and the inevitable search for something sweet after dinner. Summer crowds can make the boardwalk hectic, but the huge range is part of the fun.

Come hungry enough to experiment, because buying only the one thing you originally planned on is considerably harder here than it sounds.

6. IT’SUGAR, East Rutherford: Think Big, Taste Small

IT’SUGAR, East Rutherford: Think Big, Taste Small
© IT’SUGAR American Dream

Subtlety does not survive long inside the American Dream location of IT’SUGAR. This is a three-level candy department store measuring roughly 22,000 square feet, complete with enormous displays and a Statue of Liberty covered with more than a million jelly beans.

Once the visual overload settles down, though, there is a genuinely useful reason for international-candy hunters to explore deeper. IT’SUGAR’s large-format stores mix the giant American brands everyone recognizes with sections devoted to international candy, trending imports, bulk sweets, and products that become social-media obsessions long before they reach ordinary supermarkets.

That makes the East Rutherford flagship especially handy when you want variety rather than a deep dive into one country. You might start with European gummies or imported chocolate, get distracted by novelty candy from somewhere else entirely, and end up passing giant displays dedicated to brands like Swedish Fish, Nerds, Oreo, Sour Patch Kids, and Reese’s.

The experience is intentionally oversized, so this is less charming neighborhood sweet shop and more candy theme park. Embrace that.

The American Dream setting means you can also combine the stop with shopping, attractions, or dinner without making candy the sole purpose of the trip. If you want the best chance of stumbling across whatever international confection is currently having its moment, few stores in New Jersey have enough shelf space to compete.

7. The Pie Store, Montclair: Take the British Sweets Route

The Pie Store, Montclair: Take the British Sweets Route
© The Pie Store

A Galaxy bar beside a meat pie is a combination that makes perfect sense at this Montclair favorite. The Pie Store began with British baked goods, but its shelves have become equally useful for anyone hunting snacks and sweets normally associated with a trip across the Atlantic.

Alongside savory pies, sausage rolls, Cornish pasties, scones, and fruit pies, you will find British chocolates, sweeties, biscuits, crisps, and grocery imports that are surprisingly difficult to locate in mainstream American stores. This is the place for shoppers who want the British version of the candy aisle rather than an American brand wearing a Union Jack for marketing.

Galaxy chocolate is one recognizable target, but the pleasure comes from browsing whatever has arrived, particularly around holidays when seasonal British chocolates and sweets can expand the selection. The shop sits at 100 Watchung Avenue in Montclair’s Watchung Plaza, an area compact enough that stopping for candy can easily turn into coffee, lunch, or a neighborhood wander.

Do not ignore the baked goods while focusing on the imports, either. A proper savory pie followed by a British chocolate bar makes a convincing argument for doing both.

The store is relatively small, so expect a curated assortment rather than supermarket quantities. For Anglophiles, British expats, or anyone whose knowledge of U.K. sweets stops at Cadbury, that smaller selection is still dangerously easy to browse.

8. Wilbur’s Country Store, Frelinghuysen: Enjoy the Slower Search

Wilbur’s Country Store, Frelinghuysen: Enjoy the Slower Search
© Wilbur’s Country Store Gifts

A barn complex on Route 94 between Newton and Blairstown is not where most people would expect to find a stash of British candy, which is exactly what makes Wilbur’s Country Store such a satisfying discovery.

The shelves lean heavily into foods from the United Kingdom, with English crisps, McVitie’s biscuits, teas, marmalade, pantry staples, chocolate bars, and assorted sweets sharing space with country gifts, preserves, soaps, and other old-fashioned general-store finds.

Candy is only part of the operation, but British products are a genuine specialty rather than a token shelf near the register. That makes Wilbur’s particularly useful for shoppers who want to build a full U.K.-themed snack haul: grab chocolate and sweets, add a packet of crisps and some biscuits, then pick up proper tea to justify eating everything later.

The rural setting is part of the appeal. This does not feel like hunting for imported candy in a mall; it feels like discovering a local country store that happens to have an unusually strong connection to the British pantry.

The shop is at 735 Route 94 in Frelinghuysen, so it makes the most sense as a stop during a drive through northwestern New Jersey rather than a quick pedestrian detour. Inventory naturally changes, but that unpredictability works in its favor.

Arrive curious instead of fixated on one specific bar, and the shelves usually provide something worth taking home.

9. Euro Shoppe, Northfield: Let the Labels Lead

Euro Shoppe, Northfield: Let the Labels Lead
© Euro Shoppe Northfield,NJ

Ptasie Mleczko is a very different candy experience from a peanut butter cup. The Polish confection, often translated as “bird’s milk,” pairs a soft, marshmallow-like center with chocolate, and it is exactly the kind of treat that makes Euro Shoppe in Northfield worth exploring.

This South Jersey grocery specializes in foods from Poland, Lithuania, Moldova, Ukraine, Romania, Bulgaria, Italy, Turkey, and other parts of Europe, with imported candies and snacks woven into a much larger selection of deli goods and pantry staples.

Sweet-toothed shoppers can branch into halva, zefir, pryaniki gingerbread, cookies, chocolates, and other Eastern European treats that do not regularly appear in standard American candy aisles.

The smartest strategy is to treat the place like a tasting opportunity rather than search only for brands you already recognize. Pick one chocolate, one chewy or marshmallow-style sweet, and something involving nuts, sesame, or fruit; you will end up with a much more interesting bag.

Euro Shoppe is located at 900 Tilton Road in Northfield, putting it within easy reach of Atlantic City and much of the surrounding Shore area. Because this is a working European grocery rather than a novelty candy store, it is also a good spot for shoppers who grew up with these products and want the real thing.

Candy may get you through the door, but the deli and freezer cases can easily complicate your shopping list.

10. Holland American Bakery, Wantage: Explore a Dutch Sweet Side

Holland American Bakery, Wantage: Explore a Dutch Sweet Side
© Holland American Bakery

Dutch licorice does not ease newcomers into the experience. Some versions are sweet, some are salty, and the stronger varieties can make an ordinary black jelly bean seem almost timid.

Holland American Bakery in Sussex is one of New Jersey’s best places to find out which camp you belong to. The bakery’s Dutch roots show up not only in its pastries and breads but also in a retail selection packed with treats from the Netherlands.

Current offerings include multiple kinds of drop, the Dutch word for licorice, ranging from mixed varieties to double-salt versions, along with Wilhelmina peppermints, chocolate sprinkles, chocolate clogs, stroopwafels, and other imported pantry favorites. If licorice scares you, start with the peppermints or stroopwafels and work your way toward the darker stuff.

Better yet, pair the imported candy with something from the bakery counter. Dutch almond pastries, cookies, and other baked goods provide a softer introduction to the shop’s heritage and make it almost impossible to leave carrying only candy.

You will find the bakery along Route 23 in Sussex, and the combination of fresh baked goods and imported groceries makes it more interesting than a single-purpose confectionery. For shoppers who enjoy trying sweets with a clear cultural identity rather than chasing the newest viral gummy, this is one of the most distinctive stops in the state.

11. World Market, Paramus: Build a Snack-Sized World Tour

World Market, Paramus: Build a Snack-Sized World Tour
© World Market

The furniture can wait. At the Paramus World Market, the more interesting browsing often happens among the shelves of imported cookies, chocolates, gummies, and snacks tucked into the food section.

This is admittedly the oddball entry on a candy-shop list, but its international selection earns the exception.

World Market sources foods from across Europe, Asia, the British Isles, Scandinavia, and elsewhere, which means a single visit can produce German Ritter Sport chocolate, British Cadbury and McVitie’s treats, Swedish sour gummies, Japanese fruit candy, matcha Kit Kats, and whatever limited-edition import has appeared most recently.

Japanese candy is particularly fun here because flavors can change quickly, with fruit gummies, chewy candies, unusual Kit Kat varieties, and other small packages making experimentation relatively inexpensive. Scandinavian shoppers can head toward the licorice and gummy options, while anyone after British sweets has enough chocolate and biscuits to fill a separate basket.

The Paramus store is inside Bergen Town Center, so parking and combining the stop with other errands are straightforward. Inventory moves constantly, especially around holidays, when imported advent calendars, seasonal chocolates, and European cakes can take over whole displays.

That turnover is the point. World Market is best approached without a rigid shopping list: check the country sections, grab something you cannot find at the supermarket, and accept that you may leave with candy from four countries plus a lamp you absolutely did not intend to buy.

Share this story

Leave a response

Your email address stays private. Required fields are marked with an asterisk.