Fill up the tank, then fill up your plate. Hickory Pit BBQ sits inside a gas station on Elida Avenue in Delphos, Ohio, and locals have been stopping by for years.
Smoky meats, homemade cookies, and even pizza wait behind the counter. Here is what makes this unlikely lunch stop worth a visit.
1. A Gas Station With a Smoky Secret

Pull up to the pumps at 1150 Elida Ave and you might not guess what is cooking inside. Past the snacks and drinks, a real barbecue counter is hard at work.
One visitor said they were skeptical at first, then blown away by the food.
That surprise is the whole charm. Reviewers keep saying the same thing: do not let the gas station setting fool you.
Tables are set up for dining in, so you can sit down and eat instead of balancing a tray in your car.
Another traveler joked that running low on gas was the luckiest thing that ever happened on an Ohio road trip. With a 4 star rating from about 180 reviews, plenty of people agree.
Stop in, look around, and let your nose lead the way.
2. Brisket That Wins Hearts

Brisket is the star for many diners. It gets mentioned in reviews more than almost anything else.
One couple ordered brisket sandwiches and were pleasantly surprised by how much meat was piled onto the hoagie buns.
You can get it in plenty of ways. Try it stacked in a sub with vinegar slaw, tossed over fries, or served with mac and cheese and a slice of cornbread.
Each version lets the smoky flavor shine.
Quick tip: ask for your sauce of choice. The sauce earns lots of praise, with one fan saying it is to die for.
Some people say the spicy kind is mild, so pour on extra if you like heat. Come hungry, because a brisket plate is a hearty meal.
3. Ribs Worth the Detour

“Best ribs we ever ate.” That is how one traveler summed up a stop here, and ribs show up in reviews again and again. For a spot tucked beside the fuel pumps, that is a big compliment.
Smoke is the secret. A past visitor noted the meat is actually smoked and you can taste it, which is not something you expect from a roadside stop.
The flavor sits deep in the meat instead of only on the surface.
If you plan to dine in, try ribs with a side of cheesy hash browns or mac and cheese. Taking some home is smart too.
Cold ribs the next day make a fine snack, and leftovers are a happy bonus after a big meal.
4. Pulled Pork Platters and Bowls

Picture a pile of tender, shredded pork next to a scoop of creamy mac and cheese. That is the pulled pork dinner platter, and guests have called it delicious.
It is a classic comfort meal.
Not everyone loves every cut, though. One reviewer found the pulled pork sandwich a bit too fatty.
If that sounds like you, try the pulled pork mac and cheese bowl, which a diner enjoyed with brisket fries on the side.
Here is a handy trick. Taste the pork plain first, then add sauce a little at a time.
That way you can find your favorite flavor without drowning the smoke. Bowls are easy to share, so grab a friend and trade bites.
5. Sides and Cornbread Corner

Great barbecue needs great sidekicks. Here the cornbread gets lots of love, with six mentions in reviews.
Even one unhappy diner gave it credit for being good and fresh.
Then there are the cheesy hash browns and the mac and cheese, both called awesome by happy guests. Vinegar slaw adds a tangy crunch that cuts through rich, smoky meat nicely.
Fried pickles are on the menu too, though one customer felt the portion was small for the price. Sides can add up, so pick your favorites wisely.
A smart plan is to choose two sides you love and skip the rest. Save a little room, because something sweet waits near the register.
6. Bonnie’s Fresh Cookies

Sweet tooth alert! Customers rave about the cookies baked fresh almost every day.
One reviewer called them heaven, and another urged everyone to try some of Bonnie’s cookies, calling her a great lady.
Homemade treats at a gas station feel like a little gift. They are easy to grab with a drink and make a nice dessert after a plate of ribs or brisket.
Cookies came up four times in reviews, so you know they are a crowd pleaser. Buy a few extra for the road.
They are great for car rides, school lunches, or sharing with family back home. If you want the best pick, go earlier in the day while the selection is fullest.
7. Pizza and Breakfast Surprises

Barbecue is not the only trick up the sleeve. The menu includes pizza, and fans are loyal.
One reviewer said it is the best pizza in town since Marco’s left.
Mornings are special too. A parent shared that their sons love the breakfast pizza and that the price cannot be beaten.
The shop opens as early as 5 AM most days, so early birds can fuel up before work or school.
Pizza size can be a talking point. One customer measured a 16 inch pie at about 14.5 inches, and math fans noticed.
Still, the brisket pizza earned big cheers. If you like variety, order a pizza and a sub and share them.
8. Subs With Soft, Fresh Buns

A good sub starts with the bread. Regulars say the buns here are soft and fresh, and one family says they have never had a bad sub.
That kind of record is hard to beat.
The fillings bring the flavor. Smoked meat, sauce, and crunchy slaw come together in a handheld meal that travels well.
Customers also call the value and price great.
Prefer to skip the drive? Some guests mention delivery, and a reviewer reported that a stacked brisket sub arrived and was above par.
Call 419-695-1227 to ask about options. Subs are perfect for lunch breaks, picnics, and ballgame snacks when you want something filling without a fuss.
9. Catering for Big Days

Planning a party? Barbecue works well for crowds.
One family ordered meat and sides for their daughter’s graduation, and the timing was perfect, with food freshly packed when they arrived.
Guests complimented every dish, and the family proudly told them where it came from. The suggested amounts were right on the money, with some leftovers for the next day.
If you want to try it, call ahead and talk through how many people are coming. Give yourself plenty of notice for larger orders.
Having a plan saves stress, and nobody wants to run short of ribs. Leftover brisket makes excellent sandwiches, so extra food is never wasted.
10. Tips Before You Visit

Hours are friendly. The doors are open until 10 PM every day, and most mornings start at 5 AM, with Sunday at 6 AM.
That makes it handy for road trippers and night owls.
Reviews are mixed, so set your expectations. Many praise friendly staff and big flavor.
Others mention slow service, small portions, or higher prices. One diner waited half an hour for a sandwich during a quiet time.
To get the best experience, go in with patience and ask what is freshest. Try the brisket, ribs, or a sub, and grab a cookie.
Dine-in tables are available, and the address is 1150 Elida Ave in Delphos. Bring an appetite and an open mind.
Share this story
