One Ohio general store has sold diamonds, dynamite, and candy over the years. It even had a barbershop in its basement at one point. That is my kind of shopping list.
Two different Ohio stores trace their start to 1840, and both lay claim to the oldest title. I love that small-town bragging rights are still up for grabs after more than 180 years.
The stops on this list sell real groceries, not just souvenirs. Bulk bins, deli counters, penny candy, homemade fudge, and fresh-baked Amish treats are part of the fun. A few sit on quiet country roads in Amish country.
A few more fill grand city market halls with clock towers and iron frames.
I can’t imagine a better way to spend a Saturday than wandering aisles like these. There’s something about browsing old wooden shelves, discovering unusual treats, and picking up a few things I never planned to buy that makes this kind of shopping so much more enjoyable.
1. End of the Commons General Store

Few shops can say they started selling goods in 1840, yet this Mesopotamia store still opens its doors. It’s widely called the oldest operating general store in Ohio.
The building sits on the National Register of Historic Places. The Schaden family owns and runs it, which keeps the family-store spirit right where it belongs.
Hungry for choices? More than 1,000 bulk food products fill the shelves, so bring a list or prepare to wander.
The soda selection is its own adventure. You can pick from more than 150 varieties of old-fashioned soda, plus penny candy made for grandkids and grandparents alike.
Sweet tooth still talking? Homemade fudge and hand-dipped ice cream are both available, which makes a quick stop very hard to keep quick.
Amish-made goods show up here too, including the store’s famous Amish Fry Pies. Grab one for the road and maybe another for later.
Need a real meal? The Commons Cafe inside serves lunch and dinner, so you can shop, eat, and shop again.
Kitchen fans should check the houseware aisles. The store carries hard-to-find gadgets that you probably won’t spot at a big-box chain.
History buffs get a bonus too. Antiques and memorabilia from the store’s long past are on display, giving you something to study while you snack.
Beyond the nostalgia, this is still a working store. You can grab pantry basics and special treats in a single trip, the way folks did long ago.
The location helps the mood, since the store sits in the heart of Amish country. Plan to visit Monday through Saturday, because the shelves rest on Sundays.
One tip: Saturday hours end earlier, at 6 p.m. Weekdays run until 8:30 p.m., which leaves plenty of room for an after-work fudge run.
Address: 8719 State Route 534, Mesopotamia, OH 44439
2. Olivesburg General Store

Diamonds, dynamite, coffee, and appliances have crossed the counter here at some point. That’s quite a range for one store on a country highway.
The Olivesburg General Store dates to 1840 and claims to be tied for the oldest operating general store in Ohio. Friendly rivalry, anyone?
The building itself goes back to before the Civil War. It once held a barbershop in the basement, which is a fun thought while you shop for snacks.
Today, Tia Sponsler runs the show, and she has owned the store since 2017. The store reopened after a short remodel in early 2024.
Sandwich lovers, pay attention. The made-to-order cold deli lineup includes the Body Slammer, stacked with multiple meats and cheeses.
Want something hot? Subs, quesadillas, chicken tenders, wings, and pizzas fill the lunch menu, including thin crust and the Ashland Pepperoni Deluxe.
Homemade soups, ice cream, and coffee round things out. A wide cheese selection gives you something to take home for later.
Shoppers can also pick up groceries, household items, and honey and jams from local farmers and artisans. Local artists sell collectibles here on consignment, too.
Curious minds should hunt down the mini museum. Nostalgic candy, local craft sodas, and antiques add even more reasons to linger.
Free Wi-Fi and indoor and outdoor seating make it easy to stay a while. Keep an eye out for occasional live music and community events.
The store sits in Weller Township, right where Richland and Ashland counties meet. It’s open seven days a week, with shorter hours on Sunday.
Not many stores can mix a grocery run with a history lesson this easily. You may leave with lunch, a jar of jam, and a fun story to tell.
Address: 4778 State Route 545, Ashland, OH 44805
3. Roscoe General Store

Canal boats once made this village busy, and you can still ride one nearby today. Roscoe Village grew into a thriving canal town after the Ohio and Erie Canal arrived in 1830.
The village was laid out in 1816. Today, Historic Roscoe Village welcomes visitors year-round, seven days a week.
Right in the middle of it stands the Roscoe General Store. John Barkhurst built the building in 1870, and it first served as a drugstore and general store.
The building got a refresh in the 1970s during the Roscoe Village restoration. That project gave the 1870 structure a new life as part of the village.
So what’s inside? Old-fashioned candy, toys, cookbooks, and home necessities share space with figurines, gifts, and home decor.
Fudge fans, this one is for you. Fresh homemade fudge is made daily, so you can count on a fresh batch.
Collectors can browse antiques and collectibles too. It’s the kind of shop where a quick look turns into a slow lap around the room.
The best part might be the setting. You can pair your shopping with a living history tour and a canal boat ride in the same village.
That makes this stop great for families who like a little learning with their candy. Kids get toys and treats, and grown-ups get a dose of Ohio history.
Timing matters here. The store is open daily from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m., so plan an afternoon rather than an early morning visit.
A cookbook from the shelf could make a fun souvenir. It’s a way to bring a little of the village back to your own kitchen.
Shopping here feels like stepping back in time, minus the bumpy wagon ride. Comfortable shoes are a smart idea, since the village invites plenty of strolling.
Address: 348 North Whitewoman Street, Coshocton, OH 43812
4. Findlay Market

Back when Cincinnati had several public markets, this one opened its doors in 1855. Now it’s the last one left from that 19th-century group.
Although it was established in 1852, Findlay Market officially opened to the public in 1855 and remains Ohio’s oldest continuously operated public market. The building earned a spot on the National Register of Historic Places in 1972.
Take a look at the frame overhead. The market was built with an iron framework, a building method that was uncommon for its time.
A center masonry tower joined the structure in 1902. It gives the Over-the-Rhine landmark a look that’s easy to spot.
More than 50 full-time merchants work inside. You can shop for meat, fish, poultry, produce, flowers, cheese, deli items, and foods from many cultures.
That mix makes it a true grocery trip, not just a snack stroll. Bring a sturdy bag, because your list will likely grow.
Weekends kick things up a notch. The Farmers Market runs Saturdays from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. and Sundays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. in the Farm Shed.
You’ll also find an outdoor market with local merchants on weekends. Street performers and special events add extra fun to the visit.
The market also acts as an incubator for small businesses. Many of its vendors have been around for decades, which speaks to the staying power here.
Plan carefully, since the market is closed on Mondays. Tuesday through Sunday works, with Saturday opening earliest at 8 a.m.
Families, food fans, and history lovers can each find a reason to come. It’s one of the best places in the state to shop the old-school way.
Looking for a game plan? Start with a slow lap to see what’s fresh, then circle back for your favorites.
Address: 1801 Race Street, Cincinnati, OH 45202
5. West Side Market

A 137-foot tower with a Seth Thomas clock keeps watch over this Cleveland favorite. It’s hard to be late for groceries with a clock that big nearby.
The West Side Market opened in 1912, and it still operates in its original building. It’s Cleveland’s oldest continuously operated, municipally owned market.
Look up once you’re inside. The hall has a 44-foot vaulted ceiling and neoclassical and Beaux Arts style that makes shopping feel grand.
Want the full picture? A viewing area high above the main floor gives you a panoramic view of the market.
Around 60 small businesses fill the market with an impressive variety of foods. The lineup stretches from Hungarian sausages and stuffed cabbage to pierogi, ravioli, and pita bread.
Sticky rice is on the list too. So is liquid nitrogen ice cream, which proves this old market knows a few new tricks.
That variety shows how many food traditions meet under one roof. You could build a week of dinners from a single visit.
The market sits at the northeast corner of Lorain Avenue and West 25th Street. That puts it in the historic Ohio City neighborhood.
The building joined the National Register of Historic Places in 1973. More than a century after opening, it still serves its first purpose: selling food.
Check the schedule before you go. The market is open Monday, Wednesday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, but closed Tuesdays and Thursdays.
Sunday hours run from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. The other open days start at 8 a.m. and wrap up at 5 p.m.
A smart move is to arrive with a loose plan and an open mind. With this many stands, surprises are part of the fun.
Hungry shoppers will want to pace themselves. Sample a little here, buy a little there, and save room for that ice cream.
Address: 1979 West 25th Street, Cleveland, OH 44113
6. North Market

Columbus has been shopping at this market since 1876. That’s a long time to keep a city fed.
North Market sits just north of downtown on Spruce Street. It has served as a centerpiece of the city’s food scene for well over a century.
A nonprofit group, the North Market Development Authority, formed to preserve it. Thanks to that effort, the market keeps its old role alive.
Inside, dozens of vendors sell an impressive range of goods. You can find Ohio meats, seafood, flowers, and baked goods in one stop.
Prepared foods represent many different cuisines. That makes it easy to grab lunch while you finish your shopping list.
The market has also helped a variety of small businesses get their start. Buying here means supporting local makers in a very direct way.
Got errands after work? The market stays open until 7 p.m. Tuesday through Saturday, opening at 9 a.m.
Sundays and Mondays run shorter, from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. Individual merchants may keep their own hours, so check ahead for a favorite stand.
Fresh food sellers, bakeries, and specialty shops can vary in timing. A quick look before you leave home can save a wasted trip.
Fans of the downtown spot might like to know about a second location. North Market Bridge Park operates in Dublin.
Still, the Spruce Street original carries the history. It links shoppers today with Columbus families who bought groceries here in the 1800s.
Flowers for the table and meat for dinner in one trip is a pretty good deal. Add a pastry, and your afternoon just got better.
It’s a great pick for anyone in central Ohio who misses talking to the people behind the counter. Small vendors mean a more personal way to shop.
Address: 59 Spruce St, Columbus, OH 43215
7. Nauvoo Family Market

Old-fashioned stores don’t need a 19th-century birth certificate. This Middlefield market opened in 2011 and proves newer shops can keep old habits going.
Nauvoo Family Market is family-run and Amish. It serves Middlefield and nearby communities with what it calls hometown service.
The bakery case is a great place to start. Fresh baked goods sit alongside deli favorites, giving you breakfast, lunch, and dessert in one stop.
Bulk foods are part of the lineup too. Buying from bulk bins lets you grab just the amount you need, which is handy for baking projects.
Here’s a twist many grocery stores skip. You can pick up hardware along with your groceries.
That combo is classic general store thinking. One trip can cover both flour and a fresh pack of screws.
Everyday essentials fill the rest of the shelves. It’s a practical place, built around what families actually use.
Middlefield sits in Geauga County, home to a large Amish community. Shopping here gives you a glimpse of daily life in this part of Ohio.
Drive with care on the roads nearby. Horse-drawn buggies are common in this area, so patience is part of the trip.
The market’s smaller scale is part of its charm. You won’t need a map or a golf cart to find the deli.
Consider it a modern store with old-fashioned manners. Friendly service and simple, useful goods never really went out of style.
Planning a day in Amish country? Add this stop for baked treats and pantry supplies before heading home.
Fresh-baked goods make an easy gift, too. Bring something home and you’ll be the favorite guest at the next family dinner.
Address: 15979 Nauvoo Rd, Middlefield, OH 44062
8. Fowler General Store

Original wide-plank pine floors and a pressed tin ceiling set the stage at this 1864 store. That’s over 160 years of footsteps on the same boards.
The Fowler General Store began a new chapter under new ownership in 2026. The mission focuses on preserving its history and supporting local makers and farmers.
Hungry at any hour? Breakfast, lunch, and daily dinner specials come out of an authentic Amish kitchen and bakery.
Made-to-order deli subs and soups make easy lunch picks. Homestyle comfort favorites and homemade baked goods fill in the rest.
Thirsty? Try a Fowler Fizz, the store’s old-fashioned soda, or browse the glass-bottled sodas.
Dessert comes courtesy of Cockeye Creamery ice cream. Nostalgic candy sits nearby for anyone who wants a sweet souvenir.
Grocery essentials and fresh local Amish produce keep the store useful for real shopping. Antiques, toys, and unique gifts make it fun to browse.
The calendar stays busy too. Community events, seasonal celebrations, car cruises, craft workshops, and family activities take place here.
Car cruise nights pair nicely with a scoop of ice cream. Who says history can’t have a little chrome?
Hours are generous, with weekday doors opening at 7 a.m. Sunday hours start later, at 11 a.m., so plan brunch accordingly.
Occasional closures for maintenance or special events can pop up. A quick look at the store’s social pages before you drive is a good habit.
New owners and old floors make a fun mix. You get fresh energy without losing the charm of a building that has seen a lot.
Bring a little extra time for the antiques. One-of-a-kind treasures don’t announce themselves, so browsing slowly pays off.
The store sits on Youngstown Kingsville Road with a Cortland mailing address. It’s an easy detour for anyone exploring northeast Ohio.
Address: 3457 Youngstown Kingsville Rd, Cortland, OH 44410
9. JR’s General Store

Porch swings and storage sheds at a grocery store? That’s the kind of surprise you get in Bainbridge.
JR’s General Store has sold fresh foods and home furnishings since 1996. It’s open year-round, so you can stop by any month.
Groceries come first here. The store carries a wide variety of grocery items and bulk foods for stocking your pantry.
The deli slices meats and cheeses fresh. Ask for exactly how much you need, just like shoppers did generations ago.
Bulk candy is ready for scooping. Kids will make a beeline, and honestly, so might you.
Locally grown produce adds a farm-fresh touch. Buying it helps neighbors who grow food nearby.
Then things get bigger. Indoor and outdoor furniture fills part of the store, including those porch swings.
Storage sheds are on the list too. Few grocery trips end with a new shed, but here it’s a real possibility.
Home decor items add more browsing. Seasonal gift items make holiday shopping a little easier.
Gift shoppers get a head start too. You can cross a few names off your list while picking up lunch supplies.
Bainbridge sits in Ross County in southern Ohio. State Route 41 makes the store easy to reach for a quick stop.
Planning a weekend drive through the southern hills? A stop here can stock your cooler with deli meats, cheese, and candy for the road.
JR’s proves the general store idea still works today. One building can handle dinner, snacks, and a porch upgrade.
That’s how small-town stores used to work. People came for staples and left with whatever else the house needed.
Bring a measuring tape if furniture is on your mind. Bring an appetite if the deli case is your goal.
Address: 4715 State Route 41, Bainbridge, OH 45612
10. DeVitis Fine Italian Foods

Frank DeVitis, an Italian immigrant, opened this Akron shop in the mid-1920s. Nearly a century later, the family still runs it.
DeVitis Fine Italian Foods carries on his focus on quality food and customer service. It’s a family-owned business with deep roots in Akron.
The shelves feature high-quality imported Italian foods. It’s a great place to shop for an Italian dinner at home.
Sandwiches are made to order. Options include hot pastrami, the Italiano, and a turkey and bacon pick.
Save room for something sweet. The cannoli are freshly piped, which is exactly how a cannoli should be.
Other baked goods are available too. A box of treats could easily become the star of your next family gathering.
Want to eat right away? Indoor and outdoor seating gives you a spot to enjoy that sandwich while it’s fresh.
Free parking makes the stop simple. You can run in for lunch without circling the block.
Planning a party? DeVitis offers catering, so you can bring the Italian market flavor to a bigger crowd.
Timing is easy here. The market is open Monday through Saturday from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m., giving you plenty of time to shop for Italian groceries or pick up lunch.
Sunday hours are shorter, from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. Check for holiday schedule changes before making a special trip.
Grab a sandwich for now and imported goods for later. That combo turns one lunch break into a week of better meals.
Shops like this used to fill neighborhoods across Ohio. Finding one still run by the founder’s family is a real treat.
Consider it the corner Italian grocery your great-grandparents might have known. The difference is that you get to enjoy it today, cannoli included.
Address: 560 E Tallmadge Ave, Akron, OH 44310
Share this story
