Some Staten Islanders move to New Jersey, Virginia, or farther, and they still come home for one table on the North Shore. They pay the toll, plan the trip around dinner, and order the same thin crust pie they grew up on.
That kind of loyalty does not happen by accident. This family-owned parlor has been turning out thin crust pizza for generations, with paper plates, a busy bar up front, and servers who reportedly have been around for ages.
Nothing about it chases trends, and that is exactly the point. Keep reading to learn where it sits, what keeps the crowds lined up on a Friday night, which pies and appetizers people talk about most, and the practical details that will help you plan your own visit to a true Staten Island landmark.
1. A Port Richmond Address Worth the Toll
Plenty of pizza places claim history, but few have a whole borough vouching for them.
Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern sits at 524 Port Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302, on the North Shore of the borough. It is described as a landmark parlor for thin crust pies, and it is family-owned.
The restaurant keeps things simple. The menu covers thin crust pizza, fried calamari, subs, and plenty more, all served in no-frills digs.
Port Richmond Avenue is a working neighborhood street, not a tourist strip. That fits the place perfectly, since it has always been about locals first.
People drive in from across the island and well beyond it. Some former residents who moved away decades ago still make the trip every few months, and they reportedly treat it as a required stop on every visit home.
The headline says 1937, and the long history shows in how comfortable the place feels in its own skin. It does not need a renovation or a rebrand to keep tables full.
So the address matters. It is the spot where generations of Staten Island families have marked birthdays, celebrations, and ordinary Tuesday dinners, and the next section explains why they keep returning.
2. Generations at the Same Tables
Family ownership is the backbone of this story.
Denino’s has been feeding Staten Island for generations, and the families who eat there have kept pace. Grandparents who once came as kids now bring their own grandchildren.
Longtime fans speak about the place with real affection. Some say they have been going for generations and have never had a bad meal, while others admit they think about it far more often than they probably should.
Staff continuity helps too. Many of the servers have reportedly been there for ages, which gives the dining room a familiar rhythm that newer spots cannot fake.
That steadiness is rare in a city that changes storefronts every season. Here, the pies and the faces stay largely the same.
Former islanders living in New Jersey still pay the toll to come back regularly. One expat in Virginia reportedly makes the trip home every three to six months and always stops in.
This is the kind of proof New Yorkers love. A place does not have to modernize every corner to stay relevant, as long as it keeps doing the important things right, and the pizza is the most important thing of all.
3. The Thin Crust That Built a Reputation
Thin, crisp, and consistent: that is the formula, and it has not needed much tinkering.
The regular cheese pie is the benchmark. It arrives with a slight crisp underneath, char on the bubbles, fresh mozzarella, balanced sauce, and just the right amount of basil.
Regulars who grew up on it say the cheese pizza is always crispy, crunchy, and thin. That consistency over many years is a big part of the loyalty.
Plenty of locals put it above other well-known Staten Island pizzerias. Some flatly call it the best pizza on the island, a bold claim in a borough that takes its pies seriously.
The crust holds up slice after slice. Even with heavier toppings, it keeps its structure instead of going limp.
Simplicity is the secret. Nothing here tries to be trendy, and the pies feel confident rather than fussy.
A Margherita pie is on the menu as well, and it gets solid praise. Still, for a first visit, the plain cheese pie is the clearest way to understand why this kitchen has lasted so long.
4. Garbage Pies, Clam Pies and Other Local Legends
Beyond the cheese pie, the menu gets adventurous.
The garbage pie is a crowd favorite. It comes loaded with meat on top of that same thin crust, and fans praise its combination of toppings.
Clam pie is another frequently mentioned order. It has a loyal following among regulars who know exactly what they want before sitting down.
The vodka pie earns big praise. Its sauce is creamy and full of flavor without feeling heavy, and the crust still holds firm under it.
White pies with prosciutto show up on many tables as well. The Salute pie, topped with prosciutto, is described as savory without being too salty.
There is also the MOR pie, which first-timers have called excellent. Specialty names like these are part of the fun of ordering here.
Groups often split several pies to sample the range. That approach makes sense, because the menu rewards curiosity.
The beauty is that every one of these pies starts from the same base that made the place famous. The toppings change, but the foundation does not.
5. Calamari Gets Top Billing Too
Pizza may be the headliner, but the fried calamari might be the most talked-about item in the building.
It is mentioned more than almost anything else on the menu. Some fans call it the best calamari on Staten Island.
The breading is light and the calamari is tender. The accompanying sauce gets plenty of love as well, though a few people wish for an extra cup of marinara on the side.
Other appetizers hold their own. Baked clams, mozzarella sticks, buffalo wings, red mussels, fried shrimp, and fried zucchini all have their supporters.
Portions are generous. Many tables order several starters before the pies arrive, which turns dinner into a full spread.
The kitchen moves quickly. Wings can still be on the table when the pizza shows up, which makes for a smooth, efficient meal.
Opinions are not unanimous on everything, and some side dishes draw mixed feelings. Still, the calamari is the one appetizer locals insist nobody should skip.
6. Bar Up Front, Booths Out Back
Paper plates are part of the charm, not a flaw.
The layout is classic tavern style. A bar greets guests at the entrance, and the restaurant seating is in the back.
Tables sit fairly close together, so diners may end up back to back with the next party. It is cozy, lively, and very much a neighborhood room.
The decor is no-frills by design. Meals come on paper plates, and the focus stays on the food rather than the furnishings.
Kids get a bonus. There is a Pac-Man arcade game and a driving arcade game to keep younger guests busy.
The bathrooms are kept clean, a detail families appreciate. The bar area usually draws a good crowd of its own.
Some outdoor dining is available as well, though it gets far less attention than the main room.
Everything about the setting says old school. For many New Yorkers, that is the whole appeal, a room that never tried to become something it is not.
7. Who Fills the Room on a Friday Night
Families, couples, old friends, and big birthday groups all find a seat here, eventually.
The crowd is broad. Sunday lunch can bring large groups and kids’ parties, while weeknight dinners draw families looking for a late meal.
The staff gets strong marks. Servers are described as fast, professional, and kind, and plates get cleared almost before diners notice.
Some tables have even had staff shake everyone’s hand at the end of the meal. That personal touch fits the family-run spirit.
Service is not flawless every single time, and a few people note slower moments. Even then, regulars say it would never stop them from coming back.
There is also a party room. It is spacious and has hosted events like engagement parties, with appetizers, pizzas, pasta, meatballs, and chicken francese on the menu.
Hosts can play music and use the TV for a slideshow, and the team handles cleanup afterward. The setup is described as affordable, a welcome word for anyone planning a family celebration.
8. Hours, Waits and Parking Know-How
Planning ahead pays off here.
Denino’s is open every day of the week from 11 AM to 11 PM. That makes it easy to swing by for lunch or a late dinner.
Friday evenings can mean a long wait, even for small parties. Some first-timers have been surprised by how long it took to get seated.
Saturday nights can be smoother than expected. Some diners have walked in on a Saturday and waited only about five minutes.
Timing matters, so arriving earlier in the day or on a weeknight is a safer bet. Weekend lunch can also be busy with groups.
Parking is on the street, usually around the block. Allow a few extra minutes to find a spot, especially at peak hours.
High chairs are available for little ones. Families with babies should still expect a wait during busy stretches.
The official website is deninossi.com for menu details. With a little planning, the visit stays relaxed from the moment you park.
9. A Verdict Served Thin and Crispy
Some places earn their reputation once, and others keep earning it every night.
Denino’s falls firmly in the second group. With a 4.6-star standing across more than 3,000 opinions, the numbers back up the loyalty.
The appeal is easy to explain. Thin crust pies, generous portions, a fast kitchen, and a family-owned spirit that has not drifted.
It is not fancy. Paper plates, tight tables, and an occasional wait are part of the deal.
Those small trade-offs rarely bother anyone. The people who grew up here keep coming back, and they keep bringing new faces with them.
For first-timers, a cheese pie and an order of calamari make a smart start. After that, the garbage pie or clam pie offers a deeper look at the menu.
In a city where so much changes so quickly, this Port Richmond parlor feels like steady ground. Staten Island has kept one of its best traditions intact, and it is still coming out of the oven, one thin crust pie at a time.
Share this story
