Hickory smoke and a cowboy-cut ribeye share the same sentence on this menu, and my stomach noticed right away. The steaks here cook over real hickory wood, and that one detail changes everything.
The menu also lists Marshall Dillon’s Ribeye, Whiskey River Sirloin, and a New Orleans steak. Then there’s a salad bar, which feels like a small gift in a world of tiny side salads.
I like how this place keeps its feet planted in small-town Tennessee. It sits near some serious backcountry, so hikers and road-trippers have a solid reason to stop.
I believe a steakhouse with a drive-thru window deserves attention on principle alone. Yes, you can call ahead and grab a hickory-grilled steak without leaving your truck.
The Hickory Fire Is the Whole Reason You Should Make This Drive
Wood smoke does something to beef that a flat gas grill simply can’t copy. At Preston’s Steakhouse in Oneida, the steaks go over hickory, and that choice shapes every bite on the plate.
Hickory is a classic Southern wood for good reason. It burns hot and brings a bold, smoky flavor that pairs beautifully with rich cuts like ribeye.
A ribeye is already a well-marbled steak. Those thin streaks of fat melt as it cooks, and the hickory adds a smoky edge on top of that buttery richness.
Here’s a helpful tip for first-timers. Order your steak at the doneness you truly enjoy, and say it clearly when you order. A good hickory grill rewards a cook who knows exactly where you want to land.
Medium-rare is a popular pick for ribeye because it keeps the inside juicy. Still, the right temperature is the one that makes you happy, not the one a food snob recommends.
I love that this restaurant leans on an old-school cooking method. Plenty of places chase trends, but a wood fire never really goes out of style.
There’s also something comforting about a meal cooked the way people have grilled meat for generations. It feels honest and simple, like dinner at a family cookout that someone took very seriously.
So when the title says mouthwatering, it isn’t kidding around. The hickory is the headline, and everything else on the menu gets to ride along with it.
Pick Your Ribeye Like You’re Choosing a Favorite Truck
Two ribeye names on one menu means you’ve got a decision to make. Preston’s Steakhouse offers a Cowboy-cut Ribeye and Marshall Dillon’s Ribeye, and both sound like they came straight off a ranch.
A cowboy cut usually means a thick, bone-in ribeye. That bone isn’t just for looks, since it helps the meat hold its shape and gives you something fun to pick at.
Marshall Dillon’s Ribeye has a name that sounds like it should wear a badge. If you’re the type who orders the thing with the best name, this one might win you over before the server finishes talking.
Not sure which to grab? Think about how hungry you actually are, not how hungry you feel while staring at a menu.
Big bone-in steaks can be a project. Give yourself time to enjoy it, and don’t plan a long hike right after dinner.
Sharing is another smart move if your group likes variety. One person orders a ribeye, another picks something different, and suddenly the whole table gets a taste of everything.
Whichever ribeye you choose, the hickory grill does the heavy lifting. The smoke settles into that marbled meat and turns a good steak into a memorable one.
Honestly, I can’t imagine leaving without trying at least one of them. Coming here and skipping the ribeye would be like visiting the Smokies and staring at your phone the whole time.
Save room, though. The rest of the menu has a few surprises waiting.
Not a Ribeye Person? The Menu Has Your Back
Every group has that one friend who doesn’t want a big steak. Good news, because the menu at Preston’s Steakhouse stretches well beyond ribeyes.
Sirloin fans can look at the Whiskey River Sirloin or a classic sirloin. There’s also a New Orleans steak, which sounds like it brought a little Louisiana flair up to the hills.
Ribs show up on the menu too, and there’s even a steak and rib combo for people who refuse to choose. That’s a win for anyone with a big appetite and zero patience for tough decisions.
Beef tips are another option on the lineup. They’re a solid pick if you want steak flavor in smaller, easy-to-eat pieces.
Pork chops and chicken give non-beef eaters plenty to work with. Then there’s catfish, a Southern favorite that feels right at home in a Tennessee dining room.
Even pasta makes an appearance, with spaghetti on the menu. It’s a handy choice for kids or anyone who just wants something simple and filling.
If you’re eating plant-based, it’s worth asking your server what the kitchen can do.
I like a steakhouse that doesn’t leave anyone sitting there with only a dinner roll. A wide menu means the whole crew can come along, even the picky cousin.
And let’s be fair here. A hickory grill makes almost anything taste better, not just the fanciest cut.
Build Your Own Bowl of Green at the Salad Bar
A salad bar feels a little like a time machine. Preston’s Steakhouse still has one, and it’s a favorite part of the meal for plenty of folks who stop by.
Why does that matter so much? Because a salad bar puts you in charge, and nobody gets stuck with a sad wedge of plain lettuce.
You can pile on what you love and skip what you don’t. Picky eaters, rejoice, because the onions can stay right where they are.
There’s also a practical side to this. Starting with something light and fresh helps balance a big, smoky steak dinner.
Here’s a smart strategy for your plate. Keep your salad on the smaller side if you’ve ordered a large ribeye, since you’ll want room for the main event.
Kids usually love salad bars too. Letting them build their own plate can turn a regular dinner into a small adventure.
I believe a salad bar says something about a restaurant’s personality. It’s generous, a little old-fashioned, and focused on letting people eat how they like.
Pair your salad with a glass of sweet tea and you’ve got a very Southern start to the evening. Then you can sit back and wait for the hickory grill to do its thing.
Just don’t make three trips before your steak arrives. Your future self, staring down a cowboy-cut ribeye, will thank you for showing some restraint.
Fried Okra and Sweet Potatoes Deserve Their Own Spotlight
Southern sides can steal a show if you let them. At Preston’s Steakhouse, fried okra and sweet potatoes give the steaks some serious competition for attention.
Fried okra is a classic Tennessee table staple. It’s crunchy, bite-sized, and very easy to keep eating long after you meant to stop.
If you’ve never tried okra, frying it is the friendliest way to start. The breading keeps it crisp and makes it feel like a snack instead of a vegetable lesson.
Sweet potatoes bring a totally different mood to the plate. Their natural sweetness pairs nicely with the smoky flavor that hickory gives a steak.
The menu covers other comfort sides too. Baked potatoes, mashed potatoes, fries, broccoli, and slaw are all part of the lineup.
Here’s a fun way to plan your order. Pick one side that feels familiar and one that feels a little new, so dinner has both comfort and adventure.
Appetizers are worth a look as well. Fried mushrooms and potato skins are on the menu, and they make sharing at the table feel easy and fun.
Did you know okra has been part of Southern cooking for centuries? It traveled a long way to land on plates across Tennessee, and it earned its spot.
I love when a steakhouse gives its sides real attention. A great steak with boring sides is like a great song with the volume turned down.
Burger Lovers Get a Saucy Reward Here Too
Steakhouses and burgers make a lot of sense together. Think about it, because a kitchen that knows beef this well should also know how to handle a patty.
Preston’s Steakhouse offers several burgers, including a Hickory Burger, Bacon Burger, and Mushroom Swiss Burger. These classic burger choices give visitors plenty of options beyond the steak menu.
Barbecue sauce on a burger adds a sweet and tangy layer. It works beautifully with a smoky, grilled flavor, which makes it a natural fit for a hickory kitchen.
A burger is also a great choice for lunch. The restaurant offers lunch on select days, so a midday burger break can fit right into a road trip.
Burgers are often a budget-friendly way to enjoy a steakhouse too. You still get that grilled goodness without committing to a giant cut of meat.
Pair it with fries or potato skins if you’re feeling extra hungry. Or keep things balanced with a trip to the salad bar first.
This is also a handy option for kids or teens who aren’t ready for a big steak. Most young eaters will happily trade a ribeye for a saucy burger any day.
I like that the menu doesn’t treat burgers like an afterthought. Offering several burger varieties gives diners more choices when they’re craving something other than steak.
So go ahead and order the burger at a steakhouse. Nobody here is keeping score.
Yes, There’s a Drive-Thru, and It’s Kind of Genius
A steakhouse with a drive-thru sounds like a made-up idea. Preston’s Steakhouse actually has one, and it’s a big perk for busy families.
Here’s how it works. You call in your order ahead of time, then roll through the drive-thru window to pick it up.
That’s perfect for nights when cooking feels impossible. Your family still gets a hickory-grilled dinner, and nobody has to change out of their comfy clothes.
Travelers love this kind of setup too. If you’re staying nearby after a long day outdoors, takeout can be a relaxing way to wrap things up.
One practical tip makes a big difference. Ask the staff to slice your steak before they pack it up.
Plastic knives and thick steaks don’t always get along. A pre-cut ribeye saves you from wrestling your dinner on a hotel nightstand.
Plan your timing during busy hours as well. Calling a little early helps, since a popular kitchen may need extra time when the dining room fills up.
I think this drive-thru says a lot about the restaurant’s small-town spirit. It’s practical, friendly, and built around how real people in Tennessee actually live.
Of course, eating in has its own charms. But on a rainy evening, grabbing a steak through a window feels like a tiny victory.
Wood, Warmth, and a Lodge-Style Look Set the Mood
Rustic is the right word for this dining room. Preston’s Steakhouse has wood furniture, a fireplace, and decor that gives it a lodge-in-the-woods feel.
That style fits the food perfectly. A hickory-grilled steak just makes more sense in a room full of wood than in a shiny, modern space.
On a chilly evening, a fireplace setting is hard to beat. It turns a regular dinner into something cozy, especially after a day spent outdoors.
The decorations add character too. They give your eyes something fun to explore while you wait for your order to arrive.
This kind of space works well for lots of occasions. Family dinners, birthday meals, and casual date nights all feel at home here.
Groups and teams can gather here as well. A relaxed dining room makes it easier to talk, laugh, and pass plates around without feeling stiff.
Here’s a simple tip for planning ahead. If you’re bringing a bigger group, call before you go so the staff can be ready for you.
I believe a restaurant’s look should match its menu. When the room feels rustic and the steak tastes smoky, everything clicks into place.
It’s the kind of setting that slows you down in a good way. Dessert suddenly sounds like a great idea, and nobody’s in a rush to leave.
Plan Your Visit Around a Big South Fork Adventure
Hungry hikers, this one’s for you. Preston’s Steakhouse sits at 19787 Alberta St, Oneida, TN 37841, not far from the Big South Fork National River and Recreation Area.
Big South Fork is a huge outdoor playground. It’s known for river gorges, sandstone arches, trails, and plenty of room to explore.
That makes this steakhouse a natural stop before or after a day in the woods. Few things feel better than a smoky ribeye after miles on a trail.
Timing matters, so check the schedule before you go. The restaurant is open Wednesday through Saturday from 11 AM to 9 PM.
Sunday hours run from 11 AM to 5 PM. That makes Sunday perfect for a late lunch or an early dinner after church or a morning hike.
Mondays and Tuesdays are closed. Don’t plan your big steak night for the start of the week, or you’ll end up with gas station snacks.
Oneida itself has that friendly, small-town Tennessee pace. It’s a nice change from crowded tourist strips, and it makes a meal feel more personal.
I love pairing a great outdoor day with a great meal. Big South Fork gives you the scenery, and the hickory grill handles the reward.
So pack your hiking boots and an empty stomach. Northern Tennessee has a smoky ribeye with your name on it.
Share this story
