Abraham Lincoln is one of the ghosts people claim to have spotted inside a working government building. Visitors can follow a lantern through its dark halls each October to hear the stories for themselves.
That’s only one stop on this list. Another spot was a convent before it became an arts center, and people report hearing piano music late at night. A third is a Victorian stone house said to hide secret chambers behind its walls.
I love that Ohio’s spookiest places are also some of its most historic. You get real stories about real people, plus a little goosebump action on the side. No fake blood or actors jumping out of closets required.
So grab a flashlight and a friend who won’t scream too loudly. Just imagining myself wandering through those shadowy halls, listening to eerie stories and wondering what might be waiting around the next corner, is enough to give me goosebumps.
1. Ohio State Reformatory
Few prisons land a starring role in Hollywood, but this Mansfield giant pulled it off. The Shawshank Redemption was filmed here, and the building still draws movie fans from far away.
Honestly, it looks more like a storybook castle than a lockup. Construction ran from 1886 to 1896, and those gothic towers make quite a first impression.
Young offenders were the first people held here. Later, it became a maximum-security institution before closing in 1990.
Why did it close? Conditions inside were ruled inhumane, which gives the stories you hear on tour some real weight.
Good news for planners is that the reformatory operates year-round. Still, fall feels like the perfect season for those long, echoing cellblocks.
You can choose a self-guided visit if you like wandering at your own speed. Guided tours work better if you want someone filling in the backstory as you go.
Movie buffs should check out the Hollywood Meets History Tour. It connects scenes from the film to the real past behind these walls.
The Beyond the Bars Tour takes a different angle on the facility. Paranormal programs round things out for anyone hoping to catch something unexplained.
This place has earned a reputation as one of America’s most haunted spots. That’s a bold title, and plenty of ghost hunters show up to test it.
Haven’t seen the movie? The size and history of the building still make the trip worth your time.
Plan for lots of walking, because this place is enormous. Bring patience too, since ghosts don’t exactly follow a tour schedule.
Address: 100 Reformatory Rd, Mansfield, OH 44905
2. Thurber House
Most haunted houses don’t come with a funny story written by the ghost’s most famous witness. James Thurber grew up partly in this Columbus home and turned one strange night into The Night the Ghost Got In.
The house dates to 1873 and now serves as a nonprofit literary arts center and museum. It’s a fun mix of book lover’s paradise and spooky stop.
Here’s a detail I adore. The museum encourages you to act like a guest, so you can sit on the furniture and even play the piano.
Displays include Thurber artifacts and memorabilia. A historical marker also sits on the property for anyone who likes reading the official story first.
Now for the eerie part. Visitors and staff have reported books flying off shelves and footsteps with nobody around.
Some people believe Thurber himself still hangs around. Others point to the presence of a former owner.
The land adds another layer to the lore. The Ohio Lunatic Asylum once stood here and burned down in 1868.
Museum days are Tuesday, Thursday, Saturday, and Sunday afternoons. Self-guided tours run on those days, and guided tours are offered on most of them.
Fans of classic American humor will get the most out of a visit. Read The Night the Ghost Got In before you go, and the rooms will feel even more alive.
Kids who love quirky stories might enjoy it too. A ghost tale that makes you laugh is a pretty gentle way to start a spooky season.
Just maybe keep an eye on those bookshelves while you browse.
Address: 77 Jefferson Avenue, Columbus, OH 43215
3. Historic Licking County Jail
Carved cat-like creatures watch from the window sills of this old Newark jail. Talk about a building that keeps an eye on its guests.
The Historic Licking County Jail opened in 1889. Architect Joseph Warren Yost designed it in the Richardson Romanesque style, with heavy stone and bold arches.
It served as the county jail for nearly a century. The doors finally closed on inmates in 1987.
That long stretch brought plenty of hardship. At least three sheriffs and nineteen inmates lost their lives during its history, which explains much of the eerie reputation.
Guided tours walk you through the building’s past as a penal institution. You’ll get the facts first, which makes the ghost stories hit harder.
Feeling bold? Public ghost hunts let you join other curious visitors after hours.
Private ghost hunts are also available if you’d rather bring your own crew. Sharing nervous laughs with friends is half the fun.
During hunts, you may get the chance to use specialized equipment for paranormal investigation. Watching a meter spike in a silent cell is a special kind of thrill.
Visitors often claim to sense lingering spirits of former prisoners. Whether you believe or not, the stories are hard to shake.
Architecture fans should take time outside too. Those carved details are easy to miss if you rush straight through the door.
Newark makes a handy fall day trip from central Ohio. Pair the jail with a stroll downtown and you’ve got a full afternoon of history.
Address: 46 S. 3rd St., Newark, OH 43055
4. Landoll’s Mohican Castle
A real castle in the Ohio hills sounds like a fairy tale. Add a private graveyard around 230 years old, and the story gets a lot spookier.
Landoll’s Mohican Castle sits in the woods near Loudonville. Its supernatural history even earned a spot on A&E’s Ghost Hunters.
Fall is prime time here. Ghost Walk and Haunted History Tours run nightly through September and October.
Each walk lasts a little over an hour. Guides lead you across the property while sharing the tales tied to the land.
Want to go deeper? Groups can schedule full paranormal investigations with access to some of the most active areas.
The guided walk explores historic Heyd Cemetery and a replica of Jacob Heyd’s 1830s log cabin. Along the way, visitors hear stories about early settlers and unexplained events associated with the property.
Heyd Cemetery is the private graveyard on the grounds. Old stones surrounded by quiet woods make a powerful backdrop for ghost stories.
The Macbeth cottage gets special attention. It’s considered one of the most active spots for paranormal activity on the property.
I love that this place blends whimsy with goosebumps. Turrets by day, shadows by night.
The Mohican area is famous for fall color, so plan a scenic drive before your evening walk. Leaf peeping and ghost hunting make a surprisingly great combo.
Book ahead for October weekends if you can. Then pack a flashlight and maybe a friend with steady nerves.
Address: 561 Township Road 3352, Loudonville, OH 44842
5. Collingwood Arts Center
Ghostly nuns and late-night piano music are not what most people expect from an arts center. Toledo’s Collingwood Arts Center serves up both, at least according to visitors.
The building’s roots run deep. Parts date back to 1872, and the main section was built in 1905.
Over the years, it served as a convent, a college, and an academy. Today, it’s home to visual arts studios and artists-in-residence.
The Gothic and Romanesque design gives it serious spooky style. It’s also listed as a registered historical site.
So what do people report? Orbs, ghostly nuns, and piano music drifting through the halls late at night.
That reputation caught national attention. Ghost Hunters investigated the building in 2022.
You can join public ghost hunts and tours inside these historic walls. Private ghost hunts are an option for groups wanting their own session.
Daytime explorers have a choice too. Tours are offered on Saturdays from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m., during hours for The Weird Store.
Yes, there’s a shop called The Weird Store. Honestly, could a name fit this building any better?
I like that art and ghost stories share the same address here. Creativity by day, mystery by night feels very on brand.
Toledo makes a fun fall getaway from anywhere in northwest Ohio. Swing by on a Saturday, then decide if you’re brave enough for a nighttime hunt.
Address: 2413 Collingwood Blvd, Toledo, OH 43620
6. Historic Zoar Village
Lantern light, old brick buildings, and a tiny village founded by German religious separatists. Zoar practically writes its own ghost story.
The village was founded in 1817. Today, it’s a designated National Historic Landmark with around two centuries of history packed into a few streets.
Each October, Historic Zoar Village hosts its popular Ghost Tours. They run on select Friday and Saturday dates throughout the month.
Tours leave from the Zoar Store. Groups head out every fifteen minutes between 6:30 and 8:45 p.m.
Guides carry lanterns as you walk. Along the way, they share haunted tales and strange encounters reported by staff, visitors, and residents.
That mix of sources is what makes it fun. These aren’t just old legends, since some stories come from people living there now.
Hungry before the spooks begin? Ghost Tour Dinners are offered on a couple of dates before the walks.
The quiet setting does a lot of heavy lifting. A communal settlement this old feels mysterious once the sun goes down.
I can’t think of a cuter way to get a little scared. It’s spooky, but in a storybook kind of way.
Dates fill up, so check the schedule early in the fall. Halloween weekend especially sounds like a fun night to wander these streets.
Dress for an October evening outdoors in Ohio. A lantern helps, but a good jacket helps more.
Address: 198 Main Street, Zoar, OH 44697
7. Haunted Waterville Tours
Ghost hunting by horse-drawn trolley? Waterville turns a spooky night into a full-on ride through history.
Haunted Waterville Tours come from the Waterville Historical Society. They run on select October evenings, including Halloween night.
Your adventure starts at the Robbins House Museum. The house itself predates the Civil War, so the eerie mood begins right away.
Before rolling out, you’ll meet with paranormal experts. Think of it as a briefing before your mission.
Then you climb aboard the trolley. It carries you through downtown Waterville to several buildings with haunted reputations.
One featured stop is the Columbian House. It was built in 1828 as an inn, which means plenty of travelers passed through.
The Sargent House is another highlight. It’s believed to be one of Waterville’s earliest homes.
Each tour lasts about 90 minutes. That’s long enough to hear real stories without anyone getting too restless.
I love that this tour leans on local history first. The paranormal parts feel richer when you know who once lived and worked in these buildings.
Families and friend groups could both have a blast here. The trolley adds a playful touch that keeps things from getting too intense.
Waterville sits just southwest of Toledo along the Maumee River. Make an evening of it and grab a bite in town before your tour.
Address: 114 S River Rd, Waterville, OH 43566
8. Ohio Statehouse
Lawmakers work here by day, but October nights belong to the ghosts. The Ohio Statehouse hosts Haunted Statehouse Tours that sound like a history class with the lights turned off.
Guides lead you by lantern through darkened halls and chambers. Along the way, you meet historical figures and hear spooky tales from Ohio’s past.
The building’s story goes beyond politics. It was built by Ohio Penitentiary inmates and served as a Civil War hospital.
That past fuels some memorable reports. People claim to have seen Civil War soldiers and prisoners wandering the building.
Then there’s the Lady in Gray. Her name alone is enough to make you glance over your shoulder.
The most famous reported visitor might surprise you. Some say Abraham Lincoln has been spotted here.
For 2026, the Haunted Statehouse Tours were scheduled for October 16, 17, 23, and 24, with departures every half hour from 7 PM to 8:30 PM. This year’s tours have sold out, so visitors hoping to experience them should watch for future announcements.
These tours are recommended for ages 12 and up. Younger kids might enjoy a daytime visit more.
I love the idea of seeing such an important building in a totally different light. Or, really, in almost no light at all.
Downtown Columbus is easy to explore before or after your tour. Capitol Square looks especially striking when the evening settles over the city.
Bring curiosity and leave the skepticism at the door, at least for an hour. You might hear footsteps nobody can explain.
Address: 1 Capitol Square, Columbus, OH 43215
9. Kelton House Museum & Garden
A ghost spotted smoking in the garden is not your usual museum exhibit. At the Kelton House Museum and Garden in Columbus, that story comes with the tour.
Fernando Kelton and his wife, Sophia, built the mansion in 1852. Its Greek Revival and Italianate architectural details make it one of Columbus’s most distinctive historic homes.
The family’s history is powerful. The Keltons were active abolitionists who sheltered people escaping slavery.
A self-guided audio tour includes an Underground Railroad Learning Station. It’s a moving part of the visit, not just a side note.
Guided tours also cover the haunted side of the house. Docents share their own encounters with apparitions, which makes the stories feel close.
Fernando’s son Oscar is the best-known spirit. He was a Civil War soldier who never came home, and people report seeing him smoking in the garden.
Fernando himself is said to linger after a fall in the house. His daughter Anna also appears in the stories.
Visitors mention unexplained whispers and objects that move. Little moments like that stick with you long after you leave.
Around Halloween, special Victorian ghost tours take over. One past program, Fernando’s Funeral, focused on the family’s tragic stories and recent spooky experiences.
I appreciate how this house balances real courage with eerie legend. You leave knowing more about Columbus history, not just its ghosts.
Check the schedule early in the fall for themed tours. Then take a slow lap through the garden, just in case Oscar is out.
Address: 586 E. Town St., Columbus, OH 43215
10. Haunted Twin City Opera House
No actors, no staged scares, just you and an old theater after dark. The Haunted Twin City Opera House keeps its ghost hunts refreshingly real.
This opera house dates to 1892. It sits right on the McConnelsville town square, looking every bit the classic small-town theater.
By day and on show nights, it hosts live performances and film screenings. After hours, it turns into a playground for paranormal investigators.
Public ghost hunts let you join a group by reservation. Private hunts work well if you want to bring your own team.
Sessions often start with a historical overview. Knowing the building’s past makes each creak a little more interesting.
You may get to use specialized equipment during the hunt. Holding a device in an empty theater is wonderfully nerve-racking.
Night owls, take note. Investigations can run well past midnight.
Local lore adds another layer. Some believe hauntings in the area come from the destruction of many Native American burial mounds when the town was founded around 1819.
I love how this place stays honest about its scares. If something happens, it wasn’t scripted.
McConnelsville is a quiet river town in southeast Ohio. The drive through the hills in fall makes the trip feel like part of the adventure.
Bring snacks, a charged phone, and a willingness to sit quietly in the dark. Empty seats have never felt so full of possibility.
Address: 15 W Main St, McConnelsville, OH 43756
11. Historic Lebanon Ghost Walk
Warren County’s oldest house plays a part in this ghost walk, and it dates all the way to 1795. That’s the Beedle Log Cabin, tied to the walk’s home base.
The Historic Lebanon Ghost Walk explores downtown Lebanon on foot. A historian from the Harmon Museum leads the way.
Returning walkers get a treat. The tour comes back with a new route and new stops.
Expect spooky stories and a look at the darker side of the community’s past. The focus stays on real local history rather than staged frights.
That approach is my favorite kind of ghost tour. When the facts are strange enough, nobody needs a costume.
Each walk lasts about 75 minutes. Groups are kept small, so you can actually hear the stories and ask questions.
The 2026 ghost walks are scheduled for October 23, 24, 30, and 31, giving visitors several opportunities to explore Lebanon’s haunted history before Halloween ends.
The walk is recommended for ages 13 and up. Part of the reason is the route’s closeness to roadways.
Lebanon’s historic downtown suits a fall evening stroll. Old buildings look even better in the glow of streetlights.
The Harmon Museum is a natural starting point for curious minds. Arrive a bit early to soak in the setting before your group heads out.
Comfortable shoes are a must. Your imagination will do the rest.
Address: Harmon Museum, 105 S. Broadway, Lebanon, OH 45036
12. Franklin Castle
More than twenty rooms and numerous secret chambers make Franklin Castle a dream for anyone who loves a good mystery. Cleveland’s most famous haunted house saves the best for last.
Hannes Tiedemann built the house between 1881 and 1883. That’s why you’ll also hear it called the Tiedemann House.
The four-story stone mansion follows the Queen Anne style. Its towers and dark stone give it serious haunted-house energy.
It stands in Cleveland’s Ohio City neighborhood. Back in the day, its street was one of the city’s most prestigious residential avenues.
The castle joined the National Register of Historic Places on March 15, 1982. It’s widely considered one of the most haunted houses in Ohio.
Now the fun part. Public tours and events let you step inside and see the place for yourself.
Visitors can explore the castle’s history and supernatural legends through special guided experiences, including the Mysterium Tour. The venue also offers Tour & Tarot Tuesday events, which combine storytelling about the house with a tarot reading.
Check the current event calendar for available dates before planning your visit.
Tickets are sold online, so look ahead before you go. Popular nights around Halloween can be tough to snag.
Ohio City is a lively area to explore before your tour. Grab dinner nearby, then see if those secret chambers have anything to say.
Address: 4308 Franklin Blvd, Cleveland, OH 44113
Share this story
