Prices keep climbing almost everywhere, but a handful of Hudson Valley thrift shops never got that memo. From Saugerties to Garrison, there are still racks where a dollar buys a shirt and a twenty fills a whole bag.
Many of these stores are run by churches, volunteers, and nonprofits, so your spending helps neighbors too. Here are seven spots that prove old-school bargains are alive and well in the valley.
1. The Well, Saugerties, NY
Five dollars for a full bag. That is the deal The Well has offered on its Fill a Bag $5 days, and it might be the best bargain on this whole list.
The shop sits at 257 Main St in Saugerties and operates under the umbrella of the Saugerties Area Council of Churches. Every person behind the counter is a volunteer, and the staff has a reputation for being kind and genuinely helpful.
Here is the part I like most. All profits go back into the community, funding scholarships for high school seniors, support for the Boys and Girls Club, and financial help for Saugerties residents.
Plan ahead, because hours are limited. The Well opens Wednesday and Friday from noon to 4 PM and Saturday from 11 AM to 3 PM.
The shop is also known as an LGBTQ+ friendly space, so everyone can browse comfortably.
2. Topsy Turvy, Poughkeepsie, NY
Ten items for ten dollars is not a typo at Topsy Turvy. Plenty of good finds here go for about a buck apiece, which makes a twenty feel like a small fortune.
The store sits at 421 Violet Ave in Poughkeepsie and has earned a steady spot on regional thrift loops. Serious shoppers plan whole Saturday routes around stops like this one.
What sets it apart is variety. The racks reportedly mix styles and eras, so one visit might turn up something retro next to something recent.
Hours are not widely posted, so calling ahead at 845-233-5933 is a smart move before you make the trip.
3. Macedonia Thrift Store, Newburgh, NY
Vintage jerseys for a few dollars will get any thrifter out of bed early. At Macedonia Thrift Store in Newburgh, clothing commonly runs between $1 and $5, including brand-name pants, skirts, and those sought-after jerseys.
The shop calls itself a thrift store that brings joy to the Newburgh community, and the pricing backs that up. Some items are so low they almost seem free.
Practical bonus: there is a free on-site parking lot at 85 Dickson St, which is not a given in Newburgh.
Doors open Wednesday from noon to 4 PM, Friday from 9 AM to 4 PM, and Saturday from 9 AM to 5 PM. Saturday mornings give you the longest window to dig.
4. Barn Thrift Shop, The, Pleasant Valley, NY
Out on Route 44, The Barn Thrift Shop makes the case that cheap does not have to mean messy. This nonprofit store is known for being well organized, which saves real time when you are hunting for bargains.
The selection covers a wide range of clothing, home decor, and other affordable goods. Clothing in particular is priced on the super cheap side, so a bag fills up fast.
Schedules are easy here, too. The shop at 1416 US-44 opens Monday through Saturday from 10 AM to 5 PM, giving it the most consistent weekday hours of several stores on this list.
A gender-neutral restroom is available, and in-store pickup is offered.
5. Free to Thrift, Kingston, NY
The cheapest price in thrifting is zero, and Free to Thrift actually has a section of it. Alongside the regular racks, this Kingston shop keeps an area dedicated to totally free stuff.
The rest of the store is affordable and well organized, with clothing, home goods, and toys. You will find typical used thrift items mixed with some new merchandise.
Hours are generous. It opens 10 AM to 7 PM every day except Tuesday, so after-work shopping is possible.
Find it at 104 Smith Ave, with a free parking lot plus free street parking. The store is LGBTQ+ friendly and has a gender-neutral restroom.
6. That Nothing Be Lost Thrift, Garrison, NY
Three full floors. That is the scale of That Nothing Be Lost Thrift in Garrison, and it changes how long you should budget for a visit.
The shop sits at 16 Franciscan Way and connects with St. Christopher’s Inn at Graymoor. Each level holds clothing, housewares, jewelry, and a healthy mix of miscellaneous finds.
The name itself is a nice reminder of what thrifting is about, giving useful things a second life. Prices are consistently good, and the sheer selection means your twenty dollars has plenty of options.
It opens Wednesday through Sunday from 10 AM to 5 PM. I would save this one for a slow weekend afternoon in the Hudson Highlands.
7. Second Show, Hudson, NY
Warren Street is famous for pricey antiques, which makes Second Show a pleasant surprise. Since 1996, this community thrift shop at 519 Warren St has kept prices friendly right in the middle of Hudson’s busiest corridor.
Proceeds benefit Columbia Memorial Hospital, its Auxiliary, and Operation Unite NY. Shopping here supports local health care and community work.
The vibe is real deal, old-school thrift, with good finds and fair prices. Nearly three decades on the same street says a lot about its staying power.
Hours run Tuesday through Saturday, 10:30 AM to 4:30 PM. The shop is LGBTQ+ friendly as well.
Taken together, these seven stores show the Hudson Valley still knows how to stretch a dollar and help a neighbor at the same time.
Share this story
