A sandwich run in downtown Springdale can end with a bag of imported butter, a box of dried pasta, and a lunch that tastes like a trip abroad. Northwest Arkansas has plenty of places to eat, but few double as a deli and a tiny European-style market. This shop sits on Main Street, holds a perfect 5-star score across 164 reviews, and keeps locals coming back for more than lunch.
Read on to find out what is on the shelves, what is behind the counter, and how to plan a stop that turns an ordinary weekday into something worth talking about.
A Springdale Stop With a European Accent
Zelli Pasta is found at 111 S Main St Ste A in Springdale, Arkansas, United States. It is a pasta shop that works as an Italian deli and a small grocery in one.
The listing describes it simply as a pasta shop, but the shop does much more than that. Sandwiches are the most talked-about item, with sandwiches drawing more than 40 mentions in the shared feedback.
Downtown Springdale gives the place an easy, walkable setting. A lunch break here can include a sandwich at a table, a quick browse of the shelves, and a bag of groceries for dinner at home.
That mix is the hook. One stop covers a meal now and ingredients for later, which is why plenty of regulars treat it as part of their weekly routine.
The score tells its own story too. A 5-star average over 164 reviews is not easy to earn, and it hints that the shop delivers on what it promises.
From Tiny Counter to Roomier Digs
The shop recently moved to a new spot, and the change has been a hit. The earlier space was mostly a grab-and-go setup with little room to move around.
The current location now has seating, which regulars call a huge win. Diners can sit down with a sandwich instead of eating in the car.
Drink choices were a small worry after the move, since more people were staying to eat. The shop answered that quickly, and the selection has since grown into a good variety.
That kind of quick response says a lot about how the owners run things. They listen, adjust, and keep the shop moving forward.
The move also gave the shelves more breathing room. Shopping while waiting for an order is now a pleasant part of the visit rather than a squeeze.
Fans of the old spot say the quality carried over. New walls, same sandwiches.
The Italian Sandwich Everyone Keeps Mentioning
The Zelli Italian is the headliner. The phrase Italian sandwich comes up again and again, and plenty of people call it the best in Northwest Arkansas.
The bread gets special praise for its crisp crust and fresh bake. The fillings are balanced rather than piled sky high, so each ingredient stands out on its own.
A Calabrian chili mayo adds a zippy kick, and the provolone and meats hold their own. One fan from New Jersey noted that it is not stacked as high as back home, yet still perfectly balanced and full of flavor.
Chicago-area transplants say it would hold up in their hometown too. That is a bold claim, and it keeps showing up.
For anyone deciding what to order on a first trip, this is the safe and delicious bet. Ordering it feels like a rite of passage.
Beyond the Italian: Other Sandwich Favorites
Plenty of regulars have worked their way through the whole menu. The Italian ham with French butter gets a strong recommendation, and the ham and butter pairing has reminded some diners of France.
A mortadella sandwich earned a fan who drove in from out of town just to try it. The Dodge City sandwich also appears among the popular topics.
Prosciutto is another name that surfaces often, and it is praised as amazing. Cured meats show up across the menu and the shop shelves.
Pasta salad on the side has also won over a neighbor from the shop next door. That diner admitted to finishing the whole thing, and has no regrets.
Variety makes repeat visits easy. Anyone who keeps ordering the same thing might want to branch out next time.
Pasta by the Pound, Fresh and Dried
The shop started with pasta, and it still shows. Fresh and dried varieties line the shelves, and pasta by the pound is a notable topic among regulars.
Dried pasta gets frequent mention, with fans saying it beats the big corporate brands. One home cook buys semolina here and picks up fresh lasagna sheets too.
Eight sheets, about one pound, were enough to fill a standard casserole dish and a smaller one for the freezer. That kind of math makes the price feel fair.
A take-and-bake lasagna is another hit for anyone who wants dinner without the work. House-made pasta sauces fill out the shelves for easy pairing.
Some customers say the pasta has become a staple at home. A few even call it some of the best they have had in Northwest Arkansas.
A Pantry Stocked With Imports
Browsing the shelves feels a bit like shopping a boutique grocery. Imported sundries, tinned fish, olives, and house-made pasta sauces fill the space.
The selection is wide without feeling cluttered. Shoppers say it is not so crowded with products that it gets all over the place.
Specialty items that are hard to find locally are a draw. Pistachio paste is one example, and shoppers who usually search online for such items are happy to find them in person.
Charcuterie supplies and parmigiano reggiano are regular stops for some. One reviewer said imported goods come at a fair import price.
Even pet owners get a nod, since the shop has carried dog toys. Gluten-free shoppers also say there is plenty to buy, even if the fresh pasta is off the list.
The Butter Case Worth a Detour
Tucked in the refrigerator is a small treasure. European butter has become a quiet star here, and regulars say to check out the butter selection.
One shopper learned only recently that the shop carries it and was thrilled. French butter shows up on a sandwich too, tying the shelf to the counter.
The cold case also holds parmigiano reggiano for those stocking up. Pair it with fresh pasta and the shopping list is nearly done.
Such small finds are part of the charm. A quick lunch can turn into a pantry upgrade with very little effort.
Staff members are known to share useful details about what they carry. Asking a question here often leads to a good recommendation.
Gifts, Boxes, and a Monthly Surprise
Gift shopping is a strong suit. Shoppers describe unique gifts for foodie friends and family lining the shelves.
One customer ordered online for pickup and then built a custom gift box in person. That two-step process turned out to be a fun experience.
Snack boxes make a handy quick lunch on the go. They are a good option for anyone short on time.
A monthly Pasta Box subscription has also been mentioned, giving fans a way to bring the shop home on a schedule. Stickers and chocolate near the register tempt anyone with spare change.
Gift boxes make this a smart stop before a birthday or holiday. They also suit adults planning a thoughtful present for a food-loving friend.
The People Behind the Counter
The team earns steady praise. Customers describe staff as friendly, knowledgeable, and happy to explain what they are preparing and why.
One guest with a pistachio allergy said the two men running the counter and kitchen were kind and accommodating. That attention makes a difference for anyone with dietary concerns.
Another shopper called one employee among the most pleasant people encountered in a long time. Words like welcoming and inviting come up often.
Fans also noticed when the shop was busy and staffing felt thin. The owners responded publicly and invited the conversation to continue by email.
Overall, the shop is known as a local business that makes its own bread, pasta, and sandwiches. That hands-on approach shows in the way the team talks about the food.
Planning the Visit: Hours and Timing
The shop is open Monday through Saturday from 10 AM to 6 PM. Sunday is a rest day, so plan accordingly.
The shop is at 111 S Main St Ste A in downtown Springdale. A good-sized crowd can gather at lunch, though the wait for food has been described as short.
One regular suggested bringing about fifty dollars to feed two people well and still have change for a sticker or chocolate. That is a helpful guide for budgeting a sandwich lunch plus a few shelf finds.
The website at zellipasta.com is handy for ordering ahead or checking details. Online ordering for pickup has worked well for gift boxes.
Seating is available now, though space is cozy. Solo diners and pairs fit best.
Worth the Drive, Worth the Return Trip
This is a small shop with a big reputation. Some guests have driven in from out of town just to eat here.
Others wish it had a second location in Bentonville or Rogers, since they would visit even more often. That wish says plenty about how much people enjoy it.
The shop suits adults and friends looking for a casual lunch, as well as home cooks who want better ingredients. It works as a short, satisfying outing that turns an ordinary weekday into something special.
A sandwich, a bag of pasta, and a block of good butter make a full trip. For Northwest Arkansas locals and visitors alike, this Springdale deli-market makes Europe feel closer than expected.
Share this story
