Somewhere in Illinois Amish country, a grocery run can turn into a road trip full of surprises. We’re talking country bakeries, old-fashioned meat markets, and little shops where the shelves hold things you won’t find at your usual supermarket.
I love that kind of shopping. One stop might send you home with homemade bread and fried pies. Another could fill your cooler with fresh meat, while a country store tempts you with pantry staples you didn’t know you needed.
And then there are the sweet treats. Cinnamon rolls, homemade chocolates, and baked goodies have a way of making that shopping list grow longer.
So bring a cooler, leave some room in the trunk, and come hungry. You might head out for a few groceries and come home with enough treats to last the whole week.
1. The Homestead Bakery
Eighteen flavors of angel food cake is not a menu. It’s a dare, and you should accept it.
The Homestead Bakery sits south of Arthur, out in the quiet county roads of Amish country. It has been baking from scratch since around 2006, so these folks have had plenty of practice.
Start with the caramel-iced cinnamon rolls. They’re a signature item, and they make a strong case for skipping the store-bought tube kind forever.
Bread fans have choices, too. Honey white and wheat loaves share shelf space with sweet and specialty breads.
Then come the angel food cakes, with more than 18 flavors on the roster. That’s enough to try a new one on a lot of weekends before you repeat.
Cookies get serious attention here as well. You’ll find a variety of them, plus iced cut-out cookies that look ready for a party.
Fall brings the famous iced pumpkin cookies. They’re seasonal, so plan your visit when the leaves start turning if those are on your wish list.
Here’s a smart move for your trip. Grab a jar of something from the shelf of locally made jams, jellies, butters, and salsa.
That way your fresh bread has a partner at home. A loaf of honey wheat with homemade jam beats a plain slice of sandwich bread any day.
Timing matters at this bakery. It’s open Wednesday through Saturday, and it runs seasonally through spring, summer, and fall.
So don’t plan a snowy January road trip around it. Check the season before you go, and give yourself a little wiggle room.
One more tip might save your car seats. Bring a flat box or a sturdy tote, because iced treats and bumpy country roads don’t always get along.
Address: 1749B E County Rd 1900 N, Arthur, IL 61911
2. Beachy’s Bulk Foods
Back in 1990, this whole operation ran off a back porch. The goods were simple: eggs, day-old bread, and milk.
Today Beachy’s Bulk Foods is a full bulk food store in Arthur. That’s quite a glow-up from a porch table.
The shelves now cover a lot of ground. You’ll see bulk foods, everyday groceries, fresh baked goods, and deli items.
There’s more beyond the food aisles. Frozen foods, household items, health supplements, and cleaning products round out the stock.
So yes, you can actually replace a regular grocery trip here. That’s the whole point of this list, after all.
Now for the fun stuff. Homemade pies and artisan breads are big draws, so leave room in the cart.
Spice lovers, this is your playground. Bulk spices let you buy just what you need, which beats tossing half a jar later.
Loose teas and specialty goods add even more reasons to wander. Go slowly and read the labels, because surprises hide on these shelves.
Then there’s the peanut butter station. You can get peanut butter made fresh, and that alone makes for a great story at dinner.
Got a sweet tooth? Plan around Thursday or Friday, because that’s when donuts show up.
Hours are friendly for early birds. The store opens at 7 a.m. Monday through Saturday, closing at 5:30 p.m. on weekdays and 4:30 p.m. on Saturday.
A quick strategy helps here. Make a list for staples, then give yourself permission to grab one wild card item.
Maybe it’s a new tea or a spice you can’t pronounce yet. Either way, your kitchen gets more interesting.
Address: 259 N CR 200E, Arthur, IL 61911
3. Shady Crest Farm Market
Fried pies only show up on Fridays and Saturdays here. Mark your calendar like it’s a holiday, because it kind of is.
Shady Crest Farm Market, also called Shady Crest Market and Deli, wears a lot of hats. It’s a farm stand, an apple orchard, a deli, and a grill.
Fresh fruits and vegetables come first. That makes this a handy stop when you want produce with a farm address instead of a shipping label.
The deli counter offers meats and cheeses. Pair them with bread from another stop on this list, and lunch is handled.
Baked goods are a big part of the fame. Look for unique cookies, pot pies, jams, and butter alongside those weekend fried pies.
Pot pies are a busy cook’s best friend. Toss one in the oven on a tired weeknight, and you look like a kitchen hero.
Need a treat on the spot? Hand-dipped ice cream and homemade fudge are waiting.
Hungry right now instead of later? The grill serves sandwiches and hot meals, so you can eat before you shop.
That’s a pro move, honestly. Shopping on an empty stomach usually ends with way too many cookies in the bag.
There’s also a gift store for browsing. In fall, plants and pumpkins join the lineup, which makes porch decorating easy.
The market is open 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. on weekdays and 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. on Saturday. The deli and grill keep their own hours inside those times.
So check before you count on a hot sandwich. Then grab a pie for the road and one for the people waiting at home.
Address: 2046 County Road 1800 E, Arthur, IL 61911
4. Yoder’s Kitchen
Shoofly pie sounds like something you’d swat at a picnic. At Yoder’s Kitchen, it’s sitting in the bakery case, ready to come home with you.
This Amish and Mennonite restaurant in Arthur also has a bakery and a gift shop attached. The building came from a project by Das Huber Haus, Inc., finished in 1988.
Let’s talk pie first, because priorities. The bakery lineup includes coconut cream, shoofly, pecan, and banana.
Cake people won’t feel left out. Red Velvet, caramel, carrot, and German chocolate are part of the spread.
The bakery also sells breads, brownies, cinnamon rolls, and cookies. That’s a full dessert table without turning on your oven.
Now, the restaurant side is a whole other reason to visit. It serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, and the buffets are especially popular.
Those buffets typically feature Amish-style comfort food. Think fried chicken, broasted chicken, hot beef pot roast, and country fried steak.
A full salad bar is part of the deal, too. So you can tell yourself the greens balance out the pie.
Here’s a smart game plan for your visit. Eat a meal first, then shop the bakery with a calm, full stomach.
Otherwise, you might walk out carrying four pies and a cake for a household of two. No judgment, but your fridge will have opinions.
Pie travels better when it rides flat on the floor of the car. Cream pies especially want a cool spot, so a cooler is handy.
Bringing friends from out of town? This is an easy first stop in Illinois Amish country, since it feeds you and stocks your dessert plans at once.
Address: 1195 E. Columbia St., Arthur, IL 61911
5. Family Health Foods
A grocery trip doesn’t always have to mean crowded aisles and a cart full of the same old stuff. Family Health Foods in Arthur offers a different kind of shopping experience.
This small specialty store gives visitors a reason to explore beyond the usual supermarkets. Sometimes the most interesting finds are tucked away in places you might otherwise drive right past.
Health-food shopping can be a little adventure of its own. You might discover ingredients you’ve never cooked with or products that inspire a different approach to everyday meals.
Here’s a smart move for your visit. Take your time browsing instead of rushing straight to the checkout.
Read a few labels and see what catches your attention. You never know when something unfamiliar might become a new pantry favorite.
Arthur is already known for its Amish-country shopping scene. Adding a specialty food store to your route gives the day a little extra variety.
And that’s part of the fun. One stop might be all about fresh bread, while another sends you home thinking about what to cook for dinner.
If you’re planning several stops around Arthur, think about what needs refrigeration. Save meat and dairy purchases for later in the trip.
Many businesses in the area keep different schedules from larger grocery chains. Checking opening hours before leaving home is always a good idea.
And don’t forget a reusable shopping bag. It’s a simple way to keep your purchases together while exploring the countryside.
Family Health Foods adds another stop to an Arthur shopping trip. Sometimes changing your grocery routine is all it takes to make an ordinary afternoon more interesting.
Address: 2008 N Co Rd 1800 E, Arthur, IL 61911
6. Country Salvage Store
A few dented boxes started a business that has lasted decades. In 1969, Adlia Gingerich began selling discounted groceries out of his home’s basement.
Those groceries had minor damage from shipping. The food inside was fine, but the packaging had seen some adventure.
Fast forward, and Country Salvage Store is an Amish family-run discount grocery in Arcola. The family has kept it going for more than 45 years.
This is the stop for budget-minded shoppers. Name-brand groceries come at reduced prices, which makes your wallet do a little happy dance.
Pantry staples are the backbone here. Canned goods, baking supplies, and snacks fill a good chunk of the shelves.
The store goes beyond boxes and cans, though. Seasonal fresh fruits and vegetables show up, along with quality meats and frozen items.
You can also find some fresh baked goods and sliced cheeses. That means a sandwich supply run is very doable.
Salvage shopping works best with a flexible mindset. What’s on the shelf can shift, so think of it like a treasure hunt with groceries.
Bring your list, but stay open to swaps. If your usual cereal isn’t there, a different brand might surprise you.
Stocking up on baking supplies is a classic move. Flour, sugar, and friends always come in handy when the holidays roll around.
Hours run 8 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. on weekdays. Saturday closes earlier at 3 p.m., so don’t dawdle on weekend mornings.
Pair this stop with a bakery visit nearby. You’ll save on staples, then spend the savings on cinnamon rolls, which feels like a fair trade.
Address: 435 East County Road 200 North, Arcola, IL 61910
7. Lee’s Bakery
Fried pies, cinnamon rolls, and homemade bread. That’s a pretty convincing reason to take a drive through Illinois Amish country.
Lee’s Bakery sits near Roseville in west-central Illinois, bringing the kind of old-fashioned baking that makes an ordinary grocery run feel like a treat.
The fried pies are a big part of the appeal. These handheld pastries make a sweet snack for the road, assuming you can resist eating one before leaving the parking lot.
Then there’s the bread. Freshly baked loaves have a way of making supermarket bread seem a little less exciting.
Cinnamon rolls and sweet rolls add another reason to browse. They’re the sort of treats that can turn tomorrow’s breakfast into something worth looking forward to.
And don’t overlook the candy. Homemade chocolates and other sweets give you a few extra options when you’re shopping for someone with a sweet tooth.
Here’s a tip. Bring a little extra cash and leave some room in your shopping bag.
It’s easy to arrive planning to buy one loaf and leave with enough baked goods to share with the neighbors.
Shopping at a smaller country bakery also means taking your time. Browse the selection, see what’s available that day, and don’t count on every favorite being in stock.
Planning a Saturday outing? Lee’s Bakery is listed as open Monday through Saturday, but checking current hours before making the drive is a smart move.
Roseville is farther west than the Arthur-area stops on this list, so it makes sense to plan this visit as a separate outing.
And if those fried pies make it all the way home unopened, you’ve got more willpower than most of us.
Address: 105 20th St, Roseville, IL 61473
8. Okaw Valley Orchard
Somewhere in line, a horse might be waiting for a latte order. The drive-thru at Roselen’s Coffees and Delights serves both buggies and cars.
Amish sisters Rose Plank and Lena Otto own and run this Arthur coffee shop. It opened around 2007, long before fancy drinks hit every small town.
Amish baristas craft gourmet espresso drinks here. That fact alone deserves a moment of quiet respect.
The coffee list goes further than espresso. You’ll see coffees, lattes, and teas, so non-coffee folks get options too.
Food is a real part of the visit. There’s a full breakfast and lunch menu, plus sandwiches and homemade scones.
A scone and a latte make a great road trip fuel-up. Grab them early, and you’ll shop the rest of the day with a smile.
Then there’s the ice cream. Roselen’s offers 24 flavors of hand-dipped ice cream, flavored using extracts.
Twenty-four flavors is a lot of choosing. Bring a friend so you can try two and share bites.
Wondering when to stop by? The shop is open Monday through Saturday, which matches the rhythm of the area.
Morning is a natural fit for coffee and breakfast. Afternoon works too, since ice cream is always a fine dessert after shopping.
Use the drive-thru if you’re in a rush. You’ll be part of a line that might include a buggy, which is pretty special.
Honestly, it’s the friendliest kind of traffic jam you’ll ever sit in. Just keep your eyes on the road and not on the horse.
Address: 1045 E Columbia St, Arthur, IL 61911
9. Dutch Valley Meats
More than 400 products line up at this meat counter. That’s a lot of choices before you even think about side dishes.
Dutch Valley Meats began in 1963 as a small butcher shop run by the Beachy family. Loren Yoder bought it in 2016, and today Loren and Ruth Ann Yoder own it with Seth Gallivan.
The shop sits in Arthur, right in the heart of Illinois Amish country. It sells fresh, smoked, and luncheon meats, including beef, pork, and chicken.
The deli is a sandwich lover’s dream. Look for smoked ham, fresh turkey breast, and German bologna.
Cheese gets equal billing. Farmers, Muenster, Swiss, Cheddar, and cheese curds all appear on the deli list.
Cheese curds are a fun snack for the drive. Just maybe save a few for the people back home.
Steak fans should pay close attention. Dutch Valley specializes in dry-aged beef, which is a step up for a special dinner.
Raising your own animals? The shop offers custom processing of beef and hogs, cut the way you want.
Hosting a party is easier here too. Party trays and meat bundles take some stress off your plate, literally.
Here’s a bonus for backyard cooks. The business is a dealer for Smokin’ Brothers Grills, so you can shop smokers and steaks at once.
Hours are 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. on weekdays and 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. on Saturday. Arrive earlier on Saturday so you’re not rushed.
Bring a big cooler with plenty of ice. Meat this good deserves a safe ride home.
Address: 376 E Sr 133, Arthur, IL 61911
10. Das Schlacht Haus
Buffalo and elk are not your average grocery list items. At Das Schlacht Haus, they’re part of the processing lineup.
This Amish custom butchering and processing shop sits in Arthur. It also has a retail store, so you don’t need to bring your own animal to shop.
Beef and pork are the main focus. The team butchers and packages them, and also handles sheep and goats.
That wide range is helpful for hunters and farmers alike. Got elk or buffalo to process? This shop works with those too.
Now, the retail side is where most visitors spend their time. Fresh cuts of meat fill the case, ready for your next dinner.
Sausages come in a variety of styles. They’re an easy win for breakfast, grilling, or tossing into a pasta sauce.
Meat sticks make perfect road snacks. Toss a few in the console for the drive between shops.
Seasonings are on the shelves as well. Grab one to match the cuts you buy, and dinner practically plans itself.
Steak lovers get a double treat here. The shop specializes in dry-aged beef and also carries grass-fed beef products.
Trying both side by side would make a fun cookout experiment. Grill them the same way, then let your taste buds pick a winner.
The retail shop is open Monday through Saturday. As with many spots out here, Sunday is a day off.
It’s also just down the road from The Homestead Bakery. Pick up steaks, then cinnamon rolls, and call that a complete meal plan.
Address: 1758 E County Rd 1900 N, Arthur, IL 61911
Share this story
