In Central Pennsylvania, a bakery serves a breakfast sandwich on spaghetti bread. Its name is Spaghet A Load of This, and I grinned the moment I read it.
That silly sandwich sent me down a rabbit hole. One roadside bakery has sold shoo-fly pie since 1946. Another calls itself the Home of the Long John and has baked from scratch since 1954.
Then there’s a bakery porch that stays open for self-serve treats until 8 p.m., seven days a week. I love that kind of trust, and I love that the porch exists at all.
From old-fashioned pies to giant pastries and a sandwich made with spaghetti bread, these bakeries have plenty of personality. I’d be tempted to try something classic at one stop and save room for that spaghetti sandwich at the next.
1. Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop

Ten straight years of being voted number one is a serious brag for a pie.
Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop owns that streak with its shoofly pie, and honestly, it earned the swagger.
The shop sits in the heart of Lancaster County’s Amish country.
It was established in 1972 and has remained family-owned and operated.
Some recipes here come from Grandma Smucker’s originals.
You can’t fake that kind of family thread, and it shows in how old-fashioned the lineup feels.
Shoofly pie is the headliner, but the supporting cast is huge.
Look for whoopie pies, fresh-baked bread, potato rolls, sticky buns, and cinnamon buns.
Potato rolls deserve a mention on their own.
They’re a Pennsylvania Dutch staple, and a bag of them turns plain sandwiches into something special.
Fall fans should keep an eye out for cider donuts.
Apple fritters and cookies round out the counter for anyone who can’t pick just one treat.
The bakery is only part of the fun.
A gift shop sells locally made Amish crafts, bulk foods, and canned goods for your pantry back home.
Traveling with kids?
An outdoor play area, a petting zoo, and a picnic area mean the little ones get their own reward for good car behavior.
Early birds win here, too.
Doors open at 8 a.m.
Monday through Saturday, and the shop closes at 5:30 p.m.
Sunday is a day off, so plan your pie run accordingly.
A Saturday morning stop pairs nicely with a slow drive through the surrounding farmland.
Grab a shoofly pie for the table and a sticky bun for the ride.
Your Pennsylvania road trip deserves at least one sweet souvenir that doesn’t fit on a shelf.
Address: 542 Gibbons Road, Bird in Hand, PA 17505
2. Achenbach’s Pastries

Any bakery that calls itself the Home of the Long John is making a bold promise.
Achenbach’s Pastries in Leola has backed it up since 1954.
That’s more than seven decades of scratch baking in one Lancaster County town.
The bakery is celebrating 72 years in business, which is longer than most of us have been eating donuts.
So what exactly is a Long John?
It’s an elongated donut, and here you’ll find versions filled with chocolate, coconut, or peanut butter.
Pick one flavor, or be smart and grab a mix.
Nobody at the breakfast table will complain about choices.
The menu goes far past donuts.
Breads include wheat, garlic, iced raisin, and a deluxe cheese loaf that sounds like a sandwich waiting to happen.
Rolls cover the basics for any cookout, from potato and kaiser to hamburger and hot dog buns.
Picnic planning just got easier.
Pie lovers have plenty to weigh, too.
Apple, cherry, blueberry, milk apple, oatmeal, and lemon sponge show up on the list.
Lemon sponge and milk apple are old-school flavors you rarely see outside Pennsylvania Dutch country.
If you spot them, consider it a sign.
Still browsing?
Vanilla buns, sticky buns, eclairs, cannolis, croissants, fruit stollen, and whoopie pies keep the case interesting.
The bakery leans proudly on its no preservatives-added homemade goodness.
That means you’ll want to eat your haul fairly soon, which is hardly a hardship.
Hours run 5:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. on weekdays and until 3 p.m. on Saturdays.
Sundays are closed, so don’t let a Long John craving catch you off guard.
Address: 375 East Main Street, Leola, PA 17540
3. Dutch Haven Shoo-Fly Pie Bakery

Before Lancaster County had a long list of attractions, it had a shoo-fly pie stop on Route 30.
Dutch Haven opened in 1946 and is recognized as Lancaster’s first tourist attraction.
Let that sink in for a moment.
A pie shop got there first, which feels exactly right for this part of the country.
The star here is the wet-bottom shoo-fly pie.
That version has a gooey layer under the crumb topping, and it’s the style the bakery is famous for.
Time Magazine once pointed to Dutch Haven for America’s Best Shoo-Fly Pie.
That’s a big stamp of approval for a dessert many folks outside Pennsylvania have never tried.
Never had shoo-fly pie?
This is a fine place to start your education.
Fair warning, one slice may turn into a whole pie riding home in the trunk.
The bakery also sells whoopie pies and cookies.
Seasonal treats rotate in, so a repeat visit can bring a surprise or two.
Part of the charm is the roadside landmark feel.
Dutch Haven doubles as a gift shop, with Pennsylvania Dutch gifts and souvenirs sold alongside the baked goods.
That makes it a handy stop for travelers.
You can grab a pie for dessert and a keepsake for the friend who watered your plants.
Hours are generous for a bakery.
Weekend mornings start at 9 a.m., and Friday and Saturday evenings stretch until 7 p.m.
Late-afternoon cravings are covered, too.
That’s good news if your Lancaster day runs long and dinner plans need a sweet finish.
Some traditions are worth keeping simple.
A shoo-fly pie from the place that started Lancaster’s tourism story feels like one of them.
Address: 2857A Lincoln Highway E., Ronks, PA 17572
4. Sunnyside Pastries

Plenty of businesses start small, but this one started in a farmhouse kitchen.
In 1993, Eli and Sarah Lantz and their nine children began baking and selling at the Green Dragon Market.
Eleven people in one kitchen sounds like chaos.
It also sounds like a lot of helping hands for rolling dough.
Sunnyside Pastries opened its retail bakery in East Earl in 2007.
In early 2016, Eli and Sarah retired and sold the business to their daughter and son-in-law.
That’s a family story that keeps going.
The bakery remains Amish family-run, with most items made from scratch.
Pie choices here lean fun and creative.
Cherry and pumpkin share space with chocolate mocha, lemon blueberry, pear cranberry, and salted caramel apple.
Peanut butter, pecan, and coconut cream pies are on the list, too.
Choosing one might take longer than the drive.
The donut lineup is classic Lancaster County.
Long Johns, Danishes, fritters, cinnamon twists, cake doughnuts, and cinnamon buns make an appearance.
Bread fans get a surprise.
Alongside whole wheat, white sandwich, sourdough, and rye, you’ll see green chile focaccia and jalapeno cheddar biscuits.
Cookies include ginger molasses, lemon sugar, and a gluten-free oatmeal chocolate chip.
Take and Bake Cookie Dough lets you finish the job in your own oven.
Timing matters at this one.
The retail store opens only Thursday through Saturday, starting at 6 a.m.
It closes at 6 p.m. on Thursdays and Fridays and 4 p.m. on Saturdays.
Mark your calendar, because a Tuesday craving will have to wait.
Address: 421 Weaverland Valley Rd, East Earl, PA 17519
5. Kauffman Orchards

Few things beat a bakery that grows its own ingredients.
At Kauffman Orchards in Bird-in-Hand, the baked goods are crafted with produce from the farm itself.
That’s farm-to-oven in the most literal sense.
The apples don’t take a long truck ride before they become dessert.
Apples steal the show here, no surprise.
Look for apple dumplings, apple butter, apple cider, and apple cider donuts.
An apple dumpling is a Pennsylvania Dutch classic.
It’s an apple wrapped in pastry and baked, and it’s comfort food at its finest.
Cider donuts are the snack you’ll want for the drive.
A cup of cider next to them makes a pretty perfect pairing.
Apple butter is a smart pick for later.
One jar stretches the farm visit into a week of better toast.
The market sits on working farmland that has operated for generations.
That history connects your snack to land that’s been tended for a long time.
Because the baking follows the farm, flavors reflect the season.
What you find may shift as the harvest moves along.
That’s part of the fun with a place like this.
A spring visit and an autumn visit can feel like two different trips.
Check hours before heading out, since farm market schedules can change with the seasons.
A quick look at their social pages can save you a wasted drive.
Kauffman Orchards sits right on Old Philadelphia Pike.
That makes it easy to pair with other stops around Bird-in-Hand.
Old-school baking doesn’t get much more basic than fruit, flour, and a family farm.
Bring home a bag of donuts and maybe a dumpling for whoever stayed behind.
Address: 3097 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird-in-Hand, PA 17505
6. Thom’s Bread

The goal at this Lancaster bakery is refreshingly simple.
Thom’s Bread aims to capture the wonderful simplicity of a basic Italian loaf.
Inspiration comes from the Italian countryside, carried all the way to Lancaster County.
That’s a long trip for a recipe and a short one for your car.
Loaves here lean European and artisan.
Rustic Italian, sourdough, baguette, and ciabatta country are just the start.
Feeling fancy?
Rosemary olive oil, kalamata olive, cranberry pecan, and raisin walnut loaves add some flair to a dinner table.
Sweet tooth types should hunt down the chocolate boule.
It’s a bread that thinks it’s dessert, and nobody’s arguing.
Caraway rye, honey whole wheat, semolina, and focaccia round out the options.
Dinner rolls, club rolls, and hoagie rolls handle the practical side.
Hungry right now?
Thom’s also serves pizza, panini, and sandwiches.
The Caprese and Madison’s BLT are two names on the sandwich lineup.
Either one shows off the bread, which is the whole point.
A good loaf from a place like this can stretch into several meals.
Toast in the morning, sandwiches at noon, and dipping bread at dinner sounds like a win.
The main bakery sits on Butler Avenue in Lancaster.
It’s open Monday through Friday from 8 a.m. to 7 p.m.
Saturday hours run 7 a.m. to 6 p.m., and Sunday is closed.
A Saturday morning bread run is a solid Pennsylvania weekend habit.
Old-school here means respecting the humble loaf.
Sometimes the best thing a bakery can do is keep bread simple and let it shine.
Address: 113A Butler Avenue, Lancaster, PA 17601
7. Zig’s Bakery & Cafe

Moravian sugar cake on a Lititz menu feels just right.
Zig’s Bakery and Cafe serves it, along with a list of cakes that could feed a family reunion.
The bakery sits inside the historic Brick Gables building.
A spot with that much character fits a menu built on scratch baking.
Cakes are the real flex here.
Angel food, Jewish apple, flourless chocolate, vanilla pound, and lemon pound share the lineup.
Walnut layered coffee cake and shortcake round it out.
Coffee time just got a serious upgrade.
Whoopie pie fans, pay attention.
Flavors include vanilla chocolate, chocolate peanut butter, chocolate mint, red velvet, oatmeal, and pumpkin.
That’s six ways to enjoy a Pennsylvania classic.
Grab a few and run your own taste test at home.
Bread choices run just as long.
Country white, potato brioche, cinnamon raisin swirl, dark Italian rye, flax seed, and soda bread are on the list.
Zig’s even bakes English muffins, focaccia, and baguettes.
Dinner and sandwich rolls cover weeknight meals without fuss.
Cookies and cupcakes are there for quick treats.
The cafe side also serves breakfast, sandwiches, salads, and coffee.
That makes Zig’s handy for a full meal, not just a snack.
Lunch plus a loaf to go is a pretty great combo.
Weekday hours run 7 a.m. to 7 p.m., so after-work bread runs are doable.
Saturday closes at 3 p.m., and Sunday is a rest day.
A bakery in a historic building with a cake list this long?
Lititz clearly knows how to keep old-school baking alive.
Address: 800 E Newport Rd, Lititz, PA 17543
8. Alvaro Bread and Pastry Shoppe

Lobster tails at a bakery won’t involve any seafood, and that’s great news.
At Alvaro Bread and Pastry Shoppe in Harrisburg, it’s a flaky Italian pastry.
The bakery is authentic Italian and family-run.
It uses Old World recipes and imported ingredients, which is about as old-school as baking gets.
Its flagship sits in the historic Olde Uptown neighborhood.
Call it a neighborhood bakery with a passport.
Bread is a big deal here.
Country, French, Italian, Italian sesame seed, olive, and dry tomato loaves line up for your attention.
Panini bread, sweet bread, whole wheat rounds, and rolls fill out the list.
A good sandwich has to start somewhere, after all.
The dessert case reads like an Italian holiday table.
Amaretti, biscotti, cream puffs, napoleons, and tiramisu are on it.
Cannoli choices come with cream, ricotta, or chocolate filling.
Indecisive eaters may need one of each.
Cheesecakes, Italian crostata, and macarons add even more variety.
Gelato is there for hot days, or honestly any day.
Alvaro also serves pizza, panini, entrees, and freshly made pasta.
A quick pastry stop can easily become lunch.
Hours at the Olde Uptown shop are unusual, so plan ahead.
It’s open 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. on Mondays and Saturdays.
Tuesday and Wednesday hours run 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.
The shop closes Thursday, Friday, and Sunday.
Harrisburg may be the capital of Pennsylvania, but this little shop brings a slice of Italy to town.
Bring an insulated bag if gelato is coming home with you.
Address: 236 Peffer Street, Harrisburg, PA 17102
9. The Pennsylvania Bakery

Spaghet A Load of This might be the best sandwich name in the state.
The Pennsylvania Bakery in Camp Hill serves it on spaghetti bread.
Its sibling, the Sweetie, comes on a sticky bun.
Both breakfast sandwiches are served until 11 a.m., so sleepyheads miss out.
Silly names aside, this is a serious bakery.
It’s a full-line, family-run shop that makes its products from scratch on the premises.
Cakes are a major focus.
Tortes, cheesecakes, and decorated cakes for special occasions come out of the kitchen.
Cupcakes, cookies, and brownies handle smaller celebrations.
Sometimes a regular Tuesday deserves a cupcake, too.
The pastry list leans classic.
Eclairs, cream puffs, cannolis, and mini pastries are part of the lineup.
Pies include pumpkin and fruit flan.
Breads are made here as well, so you can cover dessert and dinner in one stop.
There’s also a coffee shop with specialty drinks.
Ice cream sits on the menu for anyone who prefers dessert cold.
Free wireless internet makes it easy to linger.
Bring a laptop and turn a pastry break into a productive morning.
Weekday hours run 7 a.m. to 6 p.m.
Saturdays close a bit earlier at 5 p.m., and Sundays are closed.
Planning a party?
Ordering a decorated cake from a scratch bakery beats a last-minute grocery store grab any day.
With a name like The Pennsylvania Bakery, expectations run high.
A sandwich on spaghetti bread proves this place has fun meeting them.
Address: 1713 Market Street, Camp Hill, PA 17011
10. Anna Rose Bakery & Coffee Shop

Building your own donut sounds like a kid’s dream, and grown-ups get to play too.
Anna Rose Bakery and Coffee Shop in downtown Harrisburg offers create-your-own donuts.
That puts you in charge of the toppings.
Go simple or go wild, since nobody’s grading.
Fresh-baked goods come out daily here.
Cupcakes lead the way, with a range of flavor options.
Gluten-free and vegan cupcake choices are part of the lineup.
That’s a thoughtful touch when your group has different needs.
Muffins and cookies cover quick grab-and-go moments.
Cannolis and cheesecakes bring a bit of classic bakery case charm.
Pies are available, too.
So are custom cakes, which come in handy for birthdays, office parties, or random Wednesday wins.
Handmade chocolates are a sweet surprise.
A small box makes an easy gift for someone who deserves a thank-you.
The coffee shop side covers your caffeine needs.
Coffee, cold brew, frappes, and smoothies are on the menu.
Its spot on North Second Street puts it right in Harrisburg’s downtown.
A pastry and coffee before a stroll around the capital city sounds like a solid plan.
Hours fit a workweek schedule.
The shop is open Monday through Friday from 7 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Weekend hours aren’t listed, so check before planning a Saturday visit.
Weekday mornings are your safest bet.
A bakery where you design the donut is a pretty fun way to start the day.
Just don’t blame anyone else if you pile on too many sprinkles.
Address: 100 N. 2nd St., Harrisburg, PA 17101
11. Gable House Bakery

A bakery porch stocked with treats from morning till evening is a lovely idea.
Gable House Bakery in Mifflinburg keeps its Self-Serve Porch open from 7 a.m. to 8 p.m. daily.
That means packaged goods are ready whenever a craving strikes.
The storefront itself opens only on Saturdays, from 8 a.m. to 3 p.m.
The bakery’s mission is to actively brighten lives through goodness.
Honestly, it’s hard to argue with a goal like that.
Baking here is all from scratch.
Breads, breakfast pastries, dessert pastries, and specialty cakes come out of the kitchen.
Local sourcing is a big part of the story.
Local strawberries, for example, go into their fillings.
Weddings are a specialty, too.
Custom wedding cakes and dessert table packages help couples sweeten the big day.
Mini desserts make parties easy.
Whoopie pies, cake balls, cheesecakes, and tiramisu come in small sizes.
Gable House also offers a venue and tearoom.
That opens the door for showers, gatherings, or a fancy afternoon with friends.
The Gingerbread Kit Shop and Lab is a charming extra.
Building a gingerbread project is a fun way to make holiday memories with the family.
Mifflinburg sits farther north than most stops on this list.
That makes it a great excuse for a drive through a quieter corner of Central Pennsylvania.
Street parking is available nearby.
Swing by the porch, grab a treat, and keep the good mood rolling.
Old-school baking and a little trust go a long way here.
Few things beat finding fresh pastries waiting on a porch after dinner.
Address: 441 Chestnut Street, Mifflinburg, PA 17844
Share this story
