Some sandwiches are lunch, and some are a reason to fill the gas tank. Across New York, from Buffalo to the Bronx, there are still Italian delis where the meat gets sliced to order, the sausage is made in-house, and the hero is big enough to split, though most people won’t.
These are not trendy spots or chains with a slick app. They are counters with imported cheeses in the case, olive oil on the shelves, and lines that form before noon on a Friday.
This list covers 12 of them, spread across Upstate cities, Long Island, Westchester, and the boroughs. Each one earns its place with something specific, whether that is a tomato pie, a chicken cutlet sandwich, or a shop that has been feeding Red Hook since the 1920s.
Save it for your next road trip, or send it to the friend who always knows where to eat.
1. Rosticceria Rossi & Sons, Poughkeepsie, NY
Bring an appetite and maybe a second person, because the sandwiches at this Poughkeepsie counter run large. Rosticceria Rossi & Sons sits at 45 S Clover St, and it has the feel of a family deli where the staff treat regulars like they belong there.
The menu stretches well past cold cuts. Expect paninis, classic sandwiches, hot food, pastas, and salads, plus imported Italian meats and cheeses you can take home by the pound.
Fresh meats and pasta are also sold to go, so a lunch stop can easily turn into dinner shopping. Prices generally land around $10 to $20 per person.
A few practical notes help. The shop is open Monday through Friday from 10:30 AM to 6 PM and Saturday until 5 PM, closed Sundays, with free street parking nearby and no public restroom.
Thursday and Friday afternoons get busy. If you are coming up from farther down the Hudson Valley, a weekday morning is the easier window.
2. M Pellegrino Importing Co, Albany, NY
Capital District sandwich fans have a simple order here: the Italian mix sub. At M Pellegrino Importing Co on Central Avenue, the meat and cheese are sliced fresh and the subs are built to order.
Part grocery store and part deli, the shop carries a solid range of Italian imports along with cold cuts and cheeses. Homemade sausage and meatballs show up in the case too, which gives home cooks another reason to stop.
Save room for a cannoli. It is one of the sweeter reasons people leave with more than they planned.
The space is clean and the staff are friendly, and it moves like a working neighborhood shop. Hours are Monday through Friday from 9 AM to 5 PM and Saturday from 8 AM to 3 PM.
Fridays tend to stay busy from morning on. If you are driving in from Saratoga or the Berkshires, a Saturday morning run makes sense since the doors open early.
3. Roma Sausage & Deli, Utica, NY
Utica has its own Italian food vocabulary, and tomato pie is near the top of it. Roma Sausage & Deli on Bleecker Street serves that local favorite alongside submarine sandwiches and straightforward Italian eats.
The name gives away the specialty. The Italian sausage here has a strong following, and the sausage rolls are big enough to count as a meal.
Shoppers also grab the deli’s own sauce, pasta, and meatballs to take home. Prices sit in the $10 to $20 range, and the shop has an old-town feel that fits its Mohawk Valley block.
Timing matters with this one. It opens at 7 AM Tuesday through Saturday, closes at 3 PM, runs until 1 PM on Sunday, and stays closed Monday.
There is no dine-in, so plan on takeout. A free parking lot and street parking make the stop quick, and Friday and Saturday mornings bring the biggest crowds.
4. Vince’s Gourmet Imports, North Syracuse, NY
Eggplant parm on a sub roll might be the sleeper hit of Central New York. Vince’s Gourmet Imports in North Syracuse turns it out next to its signature Italian sandwiches, and both have earned a loyal crowd.
The store works as a full Italian grocery too. Gourmet imports, prepared meals, organic products, and a produce section with a strong reputation share the floor with the deli counter.
I like this stop for a weeknight shortcut. You can grab a sub for now and a prepared dinner for later without making a second trip.
Vince’s sits at 440 S Main St with on-site parking, a restroom, and free wi-fi. Hours run Monday through Saturday from 9 AM to 7 PM, and it is closed Sunday.
Wednesday and Friday daytime hours are the busiest. Evenings are noticeably calmer, which helps anyone heading over after work.
5. Calabresella’s New York Style Deli, Rochester, NY
Rochester has plenty of sub shops, but a locally owned, long-established Italian deli is a different thing. Calabresella’s on Buffalo Road has built its name on huge, high-value sandwiches made with quality Italian meats, cheeses, and house specialties.
Both hot and cold subs get attention here. The steak sub is a regular pick, and homemade sausage adds a house-made touch.
The pastry case is half the fun. Fresh Italian cookies and cannoli make it hard to leave with only a sandwich.
Unlike some places on this list, you can sit down. There is a relaxed dining area, a free parking lot, a restroom, and curbside pickup if you would rather stay in the car.
Open Monday through Friday from 9 AM to 6 PM and Saturday until 4 PM. Thursday and Friday daytime hours fill up fastest, with most orders landing in the $10 to $20 range.
6. Guercio & Sons Inc, Buffalo, NY
Grant Street on Buffalo’s West Side is home to one of the city’s classic Italian markets. Guercio & Sons is known first for its fresh produce, then for the sandwiches made to order at the deli counter.
Those sandwiches have a devoted following. The pasta salad gets nearly as much love, so ordering both is the move.
The shop keeps a traditional market setup, which makes it a good place to stock up on produce while you wait. It has the kind of everyday usefulness that keeps a neighborhood market going.
Plan your trip carefully. Guercio & Sons is open Tuesday through Saturday from 9 AM to 5 PM and closed Sunday and Monday.
There is no public restroom. Friday and Saturday afternoons draw the biggest crowds, so earlier in the day is smoother if you are coming in from the suburbs or Niagara County.
7. Casa Italiana, Canandaigua, NY
A Finger Lakes day trip needs a lunch plan, and this family-owned market in Canandaigua makes a strong case. Casa Italiana on Parrish Street serves sub sandwiches and pizza alongside imported meats, cheeses, and Italian treats.
Single-size sandwiches are a highlight. They suit anyone who wants a proper Italian sub without committing to a giant one.
A bakery side rounds things out. That makes it easy to pick up something sweet for the drive home.
This is also one of the more flexible stops on the list. It is open seven days a week, Monday through Friday from 8 AM to 7 PM, Saturday until 6 PM, and Sunday from 9 AM to 4 PM.
Free lot and street parking, plus a restroom, keep things easy for road trippers. Afternoons stay busy most days of the week.
8. Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros, Mamaroneck, NY
Look up when you walk in. At Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros, prosciutto and sopressata hang from the ceiling, which tells you plenty about the priorities here.
This Mamaroneck Avenue shop is a Westchester neighborhood institution for Italian meats, cheeses, breads, and pastas. Shelves hold imported products like olive oil and coffee, and hot preparations come out daily.
The sandwich board has its own personalities. The Italian combo comes loaded with meat, the Juice Special carries generous prosciutto and eggplant, and the Mamaroneck’s Finest is stacked with chicken cutlets.
Prices run about $10 to $20 per person. Hours are Monday through Saturday from 8 AM to 6 PM and Sunday until 3 PM.
Thursday afternoons are the busiest. A Friday morning visit tends to be quieter.
9. Dominick’s Italian-American Deli, New Hyde Park, NY
Chicken fingers are not the first thing most people expect from an Italian deli. At Dominick’s in New Hyde Park, they are a signature, sharing the spotlight with Italian-style heroes.
This longtime Herricks Road spot serves hot and cold Italian and American sandwiches, soups, and salads. The bread is soft inside with a crusty outside, and the American and Italian sandwiches come generously filled.
The deli counter reads like a true Italian shop. Prosciutto, hot and sweet soppressata, and cappicola are regular fixtures, along with plenty of prepared foods.
Expect a line. It is not the cheapest lunch on Long Island, though most visits land around $10 to $20.
Dominick’s opens at 7 AM daily and closes at 6 PM Monday through Saturday and 5 PM Sunday. Free parking lot and street parking are available, but there is no public restroom.
10. Faicco’s Italian Specialties, New York, NY
Bleecker Street has changed a lot over the years, but Faicco’s has held its ground as an enduring Italian market. The shop makes its own sausages and sauces and stocks meats, cheeses, oils, and imported ingredients.
The sandwiches are big and generous with the meat. Popular picks include the sausage and broccoli rabe, the Italian Special, the chicken pesto, and a smoked mozzarella sandwich.
Don’t skip the arancini. They come warm and crispy, made with in-house cheese.
The interior is a draw on its own, with Italian snacks and ingredients lining the space. Plan to eat elsewhere, since there is no dine-in.
Prices here run higher, around $20 to $30 per person. Faicco’s is closed Monday, open Tuesday through Saturday from 9 AM to 6 PM, and Sunday until 2 PM.
11. Defonte’s Sandwich Shop, Brooklyn, NY
Since the 1920s, Defonte’s has been stuffing heroes with fried eggplant and chicken parm on Columbia Street. That makes it one of the oldest stories on this list, and Red Hook still lines up for it.
The menu has some local legends. The Roast Pork Special, Italian Combo, chicken cutlet, Brooklyn Boy, and Golden Boy are among the regular orders.
The chicken parm comes on crusty bread with a balanced mix of sauce, cheese, and cutlet. Breakfast is served too, since the doors open at 6 AM.
It is a historic, casual counter-service shop with some seating, including outdoor space. Reservations are not taken, and it is good for kids.
Bring cash, because it is cash only. Hours are Monday through Saturday from 6 AM to 4 PM, closed Sunday, and Friday daytime gets the longest lines.
12. Joe’s Italian Deli, Bronx, NY
Picking a single best deli in the Arthur Avenue area is a serious debate in the Bronx. Joe’s Italian Deli on East 187th Street belongs in that conversation.
This enduring old-school shop sells Italian meats, oils, and pastas, plus hot meals and housemade mozzarella. The store is well organized, with a rustic area and friendly staff.
The bread is the secret weapon. It is pillow-soft, which works well with grilled chicken, Italian cold cuts, or roast beef.
Italian sauces and sparkling drinks round out the shelves. Most visits come in around $10 to $20.
Joe’s is open Monday through Friday from 8:30 AM to 5:30 PM, Saturday until 6 PM, and Sunday until 3 PM. Street parking is paid, so build in a few minutes to find a spot.
Every list like this needs a strong finish, and Joe’s fits. From Buffalo to the Bronx, these delis prove the old-fashioned sandwich counter is alive and well in New York.
Share this story
