9 Best Pie Shops in Tennessee for a Slice of Heaven

Craving a slice that tastes like home and a little bit of heaven too? Tennessee is packed with cozy bakeries where buttery crusts meet luscious fillings, and each bite tells a story of Southern comfort. This curated list brings you the spots locals whisper about and road trippers detour to find, from fried pie legends to café classics with serious charm. Ready to plan your sweetest Tennessee tour yet? Let’s dig in and find your new favorite pie stop.

1. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop (Knoxville, TN)

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop feels like stepping into a warm Knoxville hug. You see golden crusts stacked high and smell vanilla and browned butter drifting through the room. The buttermilk pie is silken and tangy, with a crackly top that shatters just right under your fork.

Slice into the pecan and you get caramel depth without being cloying, plus a crust that stays crisp. Seasonal flavors keep things interesting, yet the classics hold center stage. Service is cheerful and quick, perfect for grabbing a whole pie or sharing a slice.

Take one to the park or savor it at a sunny table. Either way, you taste tradition done thoughtfully, with every crumb buttery and kind.

2. Pie R Square (Red Bank, TN)

Pie R Square in Red Bank feels handmade in the most heartfelt way. The pies look like something your favorite aunt baked, but the flavors are dialed in with precision. Expect flaky crusts that hold together, rich fillings, and a rotating board that keeps regulars guessing.

Cherry has bright tartness balanced by a gentle sweetness, while chocolate cream lands lush without heaviness. The staff guides you toward the day’s best slice with friendly honesty. You leave with a box and a grin, plotting your next visit.

It is small, so come early for prime choices. Whether you crave fruit or custard, the vibe whispers slow down, take a bite, and enjoy Red Bank’s quiet magic.

3. Pie Sensations (Columbia, TN)

Pie Sensations brings that old school Columbia comfort you crave on a rainy day. The moment you walk in, buttery aromas and friendly voices meet you. Their custard and fruit pies lean nostalgic, yet fillings taste remarkably fresh and bright.

Coconut cream is pillowy with toasted flakes, and the apple slice has tender fruit with cinnamon that whispers, not shouts. Crusts are sturdy without losing tenderness, ideal for fork or hand. The staff keeps things warm and personal, remembering regulars and favorite flavors.

It is the kind of spot you suggest to out of town friends without hesitation. Grab a whole pie for gatherings, or sneak a solo slice. Either way, comfort arrives promptly.

4. Lynnville Fried Pie Company (Lynnville, TN)

Lynnville Fried Pie Company is pure road trip treasure. Crispy, golden pockets cradle gooey fillings that steam when you break them open. The dough is lightly sweet and crackly, delivering that irresistible contrast against warm apples, peaches, or chocolate.

You can eat these pies on the go, which makes stopping here a delicious detour. The fruit options taste like summer afternoons, while the custard and chocolate lean indulgent. Staff keeps pies moving fast, so freshness stays high and lines stay happy.

Take an extra for later, because they vanish quickly. With each bite, you get fairground fun meeting small town craft. Lynnville proves fried pies can be simple, nostalgic, and absolutely unforgettable.

5. The Three Mothers Cuisine & Bakery (Murfreesboro, TN)

The Three Mothers Cuisine & Bakery feels like a family table set for dessert. Pies are unapologetically home style, with thick fruit layers and custards that set just right. The crust has that tender chew you love, with a buttery finish that lingers.

Expect comforting staples like pecan, apple, and chocolate cream, plus occasional seasonal twists. Portions are generous without losing finesse. The staff greets you like a regular, even on your first visit, and offers warm guidance for indecisive moments.

Take a slice to a nearby bench and watch Murfreesboro stroll by. It is sweet, simple, and all heart. This bakery excels at honest flavors that taste like tradition, plated with everyday joy.

6. Julia’s Homestyle Bakery (Murfreesboro, TN)

Julia’s Homestyle Bakery welcomes you with sunshine and sugar. The glass case gleams with seasonal fruit pies, banana cream, and chocolate silk that looks like a celebration. Crusts are dependable and buttery, offering a sturdy base for plush, well balanced fillings.

Banana cream is a sleeper hit, with ripe banana notes tucked into velvety custard. The fruit pies favor real produce over syrupy sweetness, which keeps slices lively. Friendly service adds to the easygoing rhythm, perfect for weekday pick me ups or weekend gatherings.

Grab a whole pie for birthdays or just because. You will taste steady craftsmanship alongside joyful comfort. Julia’s keeps Murfreesboro smiling, one golden slice at a time.

7. Merridee’s Breadbasket (Franklin, TN)

Merridee’s Breadbasket is Franklin’s cozy heartbeat, where pies meet café chatter. The room hums with locals, fresh coffee, and the scent of butter warming in the oven. Slices arrive generous, crusts browned to perfection, and fillings bright with seasonal fruit.

Try the chess or pecan for classic comfort, then chase it with coffee and conversation. The café vibe makes lingering easy, whether you bring a laptop or a friend. Staff keeps things moving while staying genuinely kind.

Take a whole pie to a porch swing and let the town’s charm set in. You taste small town hospitality in every bite. Merridee’s turns simple pie into a memorable Franklin ritual.

8. Baked on 8th (Nashville, TN)

Baked on 8th is Nashville’s dessert destination when you want something playful and indulgent. The pies are modern without losing heart, with confident flavors and clean textures. Expect crisp crusts, balanced sweetness, and photo ready slices that taste even better than they look.

Key lime sings with citrus, while peanut butter chocolate layers pure nostalgia over silk. Rotating specials keep you watching their feed and planning repeat visits. Staff is upbeat and helpful, steering you toward sleeper hits and seasonal stars.

Pick up a pie before a show or bring slices to a picnic on the greenway. You will leave feeling treated, not just fed. This bakery makes dessert feel like an event.

9. Proper Pie Co. (Richmond, VA)

Proper Pie Co. is a curveball outside Tennessee worth the detour. Known for New Zealand style pies, they deliver golden crusts with confident lamination and creative fillings. Sweet slices sit beside savory options, making this a versatile stop when cravings collide.

On the sweet side, try lemon curd or seasonal fruit with clean, bright flavors. Textures feel precise and satisfying, and the crust flakes beautifully. Lines can stretch, but the pace stays friendly and efficient.

If you love pies with character, this spot rewards curiosity. Grab one sweet, one savory, and compare notes as you wander Richmond. The craftsmanship bridges comfort and adventure, turning pie time into pure discovery.