One shop on this list lets you watch its fresh mozzarella get made by hand, right there, every single day. I love that. Cheese this soft and milky should come with a front-row seat.
Another spot makes its mozzarella fresh at the deli counter daily. The first shop sells its version in a one-pound ball or a braid, salted or unsalted. Yes, braided cheese is a thing, and I fully support it.
Pennsylvania has a long Italian deli tradition, and some of these families have been slicing and stacking for generations. One grocery family’s story goes back to 1905. Another business started as a simple produce stand in 1929.
Whether you like it tucked into a hoagie or eaten straight from the counter, fresh mozzarella is reason enough to make a stop. Just don’t be surprised if you leave with more than you planned.
1. Talluto’s Authentic Italian Foods

Cheese-making as a spectator sport?
On South 9th Street in Philadelphia, you can watch fresh mozzarella get made daily.
That alone makes this stop worth circling on your map.
The shop sits inside the historic Philadelphia Italian Market, so the street itself adds to the fun.
The family story stretches back further than you might guess.
The Tallutos arrived in the United States in 1910.
Joseph Talluto founded the business in 1967 with a ravioli machine.
That’s a pretty humble start for a name so many pasta fans now know.
The 9th Street store opened in 1980.
Today the business is in its third generation, which is a lot of family dinners spent talking shop.
Now, about that mozzarella.
It’s made by hand daily, and you can choose salted or unsalted.
You can also pick your shape.
Grab a one-pound ball or go for the braid, which looks like the cheese version of a fancy hairstyle.
Unsalted works nicely if you plan to season it yourself at home.
Salted is ready to eat straight from the wrapper, if you can wait that long.
Burrata fans, you have news too.
Talluto’s makes handmade burrata daily, so you don’t have to pick one creamy favorite.
Pasta is part of the routine here as well.
The Philadelphia location makes fresh pasta daily, which gives your mozzarella the perfect dinner partner.
Think about building a whole meal in one stop.
Fresh pasta, fresh mozzarella, and a handful of Italian pantry products could cover your entire evening.
The store carries a variety of Italian products beyond the cheese case.
That makes it easy to wander a bit and leave with more than you planned.
A smart tip is to bring a small cooler if you’re driving far.
Fresh mozzarella tastes best when it stays cool on the trip home.
Also, give yourself time to explore the surrounding market.
The neighborhood setting turns a quick cheese run into a fun little outing in Pennsylvania’s biggest city.
Watching your cheese get made is a rare treat.
Eating it soon after might be even better.
Address: 944 South 9th Street, Philadelphia, PA 19147
2. DeLallo Italian Marketplace

A mile-long olive bar sounds like a tall tale.
DeLallo Italian Marketplace really does describe its Olive and Antipasti Bar that way.
Before you get lost among the olives, head to the deli.
The team says it makes mozzarella fresh right there at the deli daily.
That’s the kind of promise cheese lovers remember.
Fresh mozzarella made on site means you’re not waiting on a truck from far away.
The roots here go back to 1954.
George and Madeline DeLallo started it as a roadside Italian market.
Over 70 years later, the name carries serious weight.
DeLallo is also known as a pioneer of the fresh olive and antipasti bar idea, introduced in the 1980s.
So yes, those olives come with history.
You’re basically snacking on a piece of Italian food retail lore.
The Specialty Cheese Counter cuts cheese fresh to order.
That’s handy if you want a little sharp cheese to sit beside your soft mozzarella.
The Full-Service Delicatessen offers imported Italian meats.
It also carries house-made oven-roasted turkey breast, which is great for anyone who prefers lighter sandwiches.
Sausage fans get a treat too.
DeLallo makes homemade Italian sausage fresh daily.
Then there’s the bread.
Loaves come out of the in-store Italian Bakery each morning.
Put those pieces together and you have a ready-made picnic.
Fresh bread, fresh mozzarella, a scoop from the olive bar, and some imported meats.
Short on time for cooking?
The Prepared Foods Counter offers made-from-scratch items you can carry home.
Here’s a useful plan for your trip.
Make a list before you go, because a store this size can tempt you down a lot of aisles.
Jeannette sits east of Pittsburgh along Route 30.
It’s an easy stop if you’re cruising through western Pennsylvania and need a lunch upgrade.
Just don’t promise yourself you’ll only grab mozzarella.
That olive bar has other ideas.
Address: 6390 Route 30, Jeannette, PA 15644
3. Stravino’s Italian Market

Some family businesses move once.
Stravino’s has moved twice and kept going strong for more than a century.
The original shop opened in 1916 in Cementon.
In the 1920s it relocated to Allentown.
Then came 1998 and the move to Whitehall.
That’s where you’ll find the market today on 5th Street.
Picture the menu of moving boxes in that history.
Somewhere along the way, somebody definitely labeled one “CHEESE, HANDLE GENTLY.”
Cheese is a big deal here.
The market carries 47 different types of cheeses, which means decision time could take a while.
Fresh mozzarella shows up in the hoagie conversation.
A customer review specifically mentions it in their hoagies, and that pairing is hard to argue with.
You’ll also find imported Italian cheeses, pasta, meats, and home goods.
It’s a one-stop shop for a full Italian dinner, from the pot to the plate.
Prosciutto di Parma is on hand for the classic combo.
Fresh mozzarella plus thin prosciutto is a lunch that needs very little help.
Olives and a variety of salumi round out the shelves.
Build yourself a snack board and you’ll look like you planned for days.
Timing matters with this one.
Stravino’s lists hours of Monday through Saturday, 8 a.m. to 4 p.m., and it’s closed Sunday.
That means weekend cravings need a Saturday plan.
Don’t wait until Sunday afternoon and stand outside feeling sad about it.
Morning visits are smart if you want a hoagie for lunch.
The 8 a.m. opening gives you plenty of time to stock up.
Whitehall is right in the Lehigh Valley.
It’s an easy detour if you’re near Allentown and craving something better than a drive-thru sandwich.
The long history gives the place real staying power.
A shop that has lasted since 1916 clearly knows how to keep people coming back.
And with 47 cheeses to explore, you’ll have reasons to return.
Just start with the mozzarella.
Address: 269 5th St, Whitehall, PA 18052
4. Giacomo’s Italian Market & Grille

Any sandwich called the Godfather had better deliver.
At Giacomo’s in Easton, it comes with prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, and roasted peppers.
That’s an offer your lunch break can’t refuse.
Sorry, the joke was right there.
The business started in 1975.
Giacomo and Gina Famularo opened it on Washington Street in Easton.
In 2003, the market moved to its current Cattell Street location.
More than two decades later, it’s still stacking sandwiches there.
House-made sausage is one of the specialties.
If you love a good sausage sandwich, add that to your list right away.
Fresh mozzarella isn’t only tucked inside subs.
The market has shown it for sale alongside other Italian cheeses, so you can take some home.
The shelves include Italian grocery items too.
Grab pasta and sauce, and your mozzarella has a reason to melt.
Fresh and cured meats sit near the cheeses.
It makes for an easy plan if you’re putting together an antipasto tray for friends.
Olives and freshly made salads are part of the lineup.
Those come in handy when you want something lighter next to that big sub.
The hours run early on weekdays.
Giacomo’s opens at 9 a.m. and serves customers until 3 p.m.
Saturday hours are 9 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Sundays are closed, so plan your craving around that.
An early opening makes this a sneaky good stop before work.
Pick up lunch in the morning and feel smug by noon.
Easton sits right on the edge of Pennsylvania near New Jersey.
It’s a handy pause if you’re traveling through the Lehigh Valley.
The Godfather is the obvious first order for mozzarella fans.
Still, keep an eye on that house-made sausage for round two.
Family-founded and still going, this market has earned its spot.
Your sandwich will probably agree.
Address: 700 Cattell St, Easton, PA 18042
5. Amici Italian Market & Deli

Chicken cutlets have a fan club, and Tony B is apparently the president.
Amici’s Tony B’s Chicken Cutlet sandwich gets topped with fresh mozzarella, roasted red pepper, and balsamic glaze.
That combo hits a lot of notes at once.
You get crunch, creaminess, sweetness, and a little tang.
Amici Italian Market and Deli sits on South Broad Street in Lansdale.
It’s described as a neighborhood favorite in town for years.
Caprese lovers have two ways to go.
There’s a Caprese sandwich and a Caprese salad, and both put fresh mozzarella front and center.
Pick the salad when you want something lighter.
Pick the sandwich when you want bread to catch every drip.
The menu goes beyond mozzarella, of course.
You’ll find Italian sandwiches, hoagies, and fresh deli meats.
Feeding a crowd?
Amici offers family-style meals, which can save you from cooking for a houseful of hungry people.
That’s a solid move for birthdays, game days, or long weekends.
You handle the plates, and the deli handles the rest.
Online ordering is available too.
It’s handy when you want to skip the waiting and just grab your bag.
The hours are friendlier than many delis.
Amici is open seven days a week, including Sunday from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Weekday hours are 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Saturday runs from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m.
That Sunday window is great news for weekend cravings.
Plenty of Italian markets close that day, so this one gives you options.
Lansdale is in Montgomery County, northwest of Philadelphia.
If you live in the suburbs, this could become your easy go-to.
A smart first visit might include one cutlet sandwich and one Caprese salad.
Split them with a friend and call it research.
Fresh mozzarella shows up in several of the menu’s best-known items here.
Clearly, nobody at Amici is shy about cheese.
Address: 541 South Broad St, Lansdale, PA 19446
6. Leonard Labriola’s Italian Markets

A produce stand in 1929 doesn’t sound like the start of a cheese story.
For Leonard Labriola Sr., it was the beginning of a family business that’s still running.
He started it in Pittsburgh as a simple stand.
Three generations later, the Labriola name sits on multiple Italian markets.
The Aspinwall location is on Freeport Road.
It’s an easy stop for folks on the eastern side of the Pittsburgh area.
Fresh mozzarella is listed among the premium cheeses.
So yes, you can walk out with a ball for tonight’s dinner.
Now for the fun twist.
Labriola’s pepperoni rolls are stuffed with fresh mozzarella cheese.
Pepperoni rolls are a western Pennsylvania favorite.
Adding fresh mozzarella feels like giving a classic snack a little upgrade.
These make a smart grab-and-go pick.
Toss one in your bag for a road trip and thank yourself later.
The deli also offers imported deli meats.
Pair them with fresh mozzarella and you’ve got a no-cook lunch ready in minutes.
Not a mozzarella-only household?
There’s a wide variety of other cheeses for picky eaters and cheese explorers alike.
Made-to-order sandwiches are on the menu too.
Ask for one built your way if you know exactly what you want.
Aspinwall’s hours make planning simple.
The market is open Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m.
Saturday runs 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Sunday hours are 9 a.m. to 2 p.m., so early birds win on the weekend.
A family business lasting since 1929 says a lot.
Keeping a store going that long takes steady hands and good food.
Here’s a tip for your first trip.
Grab a pepperoni roll to eat now and a ball of fresh mozzarella to eat later.
That way you get the snack and the dinner plan.
Everybody wins, especially you.
Address: 605 Freeport Road, Aspinwall, PA 15215
7. Groceria Merante

Family history at this Oakland grocery goes back further than most people’s family photo albums.
The Merante grocery legacy began in 1905 with Pasquale Merante.
Groceria Merante opened at its current Bates Street location in 1979.
It’s been serving the neighborhood from that spot ever since.
So where does the mozzarella come from?
The store lists ricotta and mozzarella under Lamagna Cheeses, made locally.
Local cheese has real appeal.
It means your mozzarella didn’t need a passport to reach your sandwich.
Ricotta sits right beside it, which is good news for lasagna makers.
Grab both and your baking dish is halfway there.
The cheese case doesn’t stop with those two.
Groceria Merante also carries a large assortment of other domestic and imported cheeses.
Sausage gets the homemade treatment here.
You can pick hot or mild, depending on how bold you’re feeling.
Prosciutto is on hand too.
Thin slices with fresh mozzarella make one of the simplest Italian pairings around.
Like familiar deli brands?
The store also offers Boar’s Head meats and cheeses.
Fresh produce helps finish your shopping list.
Add some tomatoes and basil, and you’re on your way to a homemade Caprese.
Bread arrives fresh daily.
That matters, because good mozzarella deserves better than a sad, squished loaf.
Bates Street sits in Pittsburgh’s Oakland area.
If you’re near the universities or hospitals, this is a handy place to stock up.
Here’s an idea for a no-fuss supper.
Pick up mozzarella, ricotta, sausage, and bread, then let your kitchen handle the rest.
A grocery family story stretching back to 1905 is something special in Pennsylvania.
It shows how deep Italian food roots run in this city.
You don’t need a fancy reason to stop by.
A craving for locally made mozzarella is more than enough.
Address: 3454 Bates St, Pittsburgh, PA 15213
8. Jimmy & Nino’s

Ordering cheese by the piece feels delightfully old-school.
At Jimmy and Nino’s, fresh mozzarella is listed on the deli menu exactly that way.
No need to commit to a giant tub.
Grab a piece, snack on it, and decide later if you need another.
The shop is an Italian specialty grocer and eatery in Pittsburgh’s historic Strip District.
It’s described as a long-standing name in the neighborhood.
The Strip District is famous for food shopping.
Penn Avenue is lined with places to eat, so this stop fits right in.
Hungry now instead of later?
Try the Prosciutto Fresh Mozzarella Sandwich.
That one keeps things simple and classic.
Salty prosciutto meets mild mozzarella, and lunch is solved.
The deli also offers a variety of other cheeses.
Sliced deli meats are there too, which helps if you’re planning sandwiches for the week.
Pepperoni rolls are another reason people know the name.
In western Pennsylvania, a good pepperoni roll is serious business.
Need a pick-me-up while you shop?
Coffee is on the menu as well.
Timing is the key detail here.
Deli and sandwich hours run Monday through Saturday from 9 a.m. to 2:45 p.m.
That afternoon cutoff comes fast.
Plan a late breakfast or early lunch visit so you don’t miss your sandwich.
Sunday isn’t on the deli schedule.
Save your Strip District mozzarella mission for another day.
A fun approach is to make this part of a bigger Strip District stroll.
Start with coffee, grab a sandwich, and take home some mozzarella by the piece.
Parking in busy food neighborhoods can take patience, so give yourself extra time.
Your sandwich will taste even better after a little hunt.
Whether you grab a pepperoni roll or the prosciutto sandwich, mozzarella fans have plenty to love.
Just watch that 2:45 clock.
Address: 1901 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
9. Pastificio Deli

Some delis hint at freshness.
Pastificio Deli says it plainly on its website: mozzarella made fresh daily on premises.
That exclamation point on the site feels well earned.
Fresh mozzarella made in-house is a big deal in a hoagie town.
The deli sits on Packer Avenue in South Philadelphia.
It’s described as a beloved Philly staple.
Hoagie skills run strong here.
Owners Anthony Messina and Frankie Sangiuliano were finalists in Italian hoagie competitions.
Think about that for a second.
People compete over hoagies, and these two made the final rounds.
Mozzarella fans should look at the Prosciutto Special.
That hoagie pairs prosciutto with fresh mozzarella.
It’s a simple build with a lot of payoff.
When the cheese is made on site, it doesn’t need many extras.
Fresh Mozzarella also appears among the imported cheeses listed.
So you can take some home and not only eat it on a roll.
The deli has featured special sandwiches with fresh mozzarella too.
Keep an eye out, since specials can change.
Homemade pasta is another big draw.
The name Pastificio basically means pasta shop, so that tracks.
Fresh pasta plus fresh mozzarella makes dinner easy.
Add some sauce, and you’re done.
Imported Italian specialties fill out the shelves.
That’s handy when you need pantry items to go with your cheese.
Hours are Monday through Friday, 9 a.m. to 6 p.m.
Saturday runs 9 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Sunday is a day off for the deli.
Plan your Saturday trip if a weekend craving hits.
Packer Avenue is near the South Philly sports complex area.
That makes it a handy stop before a long day out in Pennsylvania’s largest city.
Fresh mozzarella, competitive hoagies, and homemade pasta make a pretty great ending to this list.
Go hungry and leave happy.
Address: 1528 Packer Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19145
Share this story
