Some restaurants chase trends, and some simply outlast them. On the East Side of St. Paul, one family has been serving spaghetti and meatballs since 1933, long before most of today’s menus were even a rough idea.
The meatballs are famously huge, the walls are covered with old photos, and the people running the place still know regulars by name. For Minnesota food-focused day-trippers, that kind of staying power is a real reason to make the drive.
This article walks through the history, the menu standouts, the gluten-free setup, the catering side, and the practical details you need before you go. Stick around, because the spaghetti is only part of the story, and the rest might be the reason you keep coming back.
An East Side Address With Deep Roots
Payne Avenue has seen plenty of change over the decades, yet one storefront has stayed loyal to its pasta.
Yarusso Bros – Italian Restaurant sits at 635 Payne Ave, St Paul, MN 55130, on the East Side of St. Paul, Minnesota. It is a mom-and-pop spot that focuses on Italian classics served in traditional surroundings.
The neighborhood setting matters here. This is not a downtown showpiece or a polished chain location, and it does not try to be.
Instead, it feels like a place built for the community around it. Lifelong customers return again and again, and many families treat it as part of their own history.
The menu sticks to familiar favorites. Spaghetti and meatballs, fettuccine alfredo, ravioli, mostaccioli, and the signature pasta supreme all show up regularly in conversations about the place.
A weekday lunch buffet adds another reason to stop by during the work week. That makes it a practical choice for a midday break as well as a sit-down dinner.
With a 4.6-star standing across more than 1,600 opinions online, the restaurant has clearly earned a loyal following. Plenty of people consider it a cornerstone of Midwest Italian cooking.
Before getting to the plates, though, it helps to know just how long this kitchen has been at work.
Ninety Years and Counting
Back in 1933, the Yarusso family opened their doors, and they have been feeding St. Paul ever since.
That makes the restaurant more than 90 years old. Few family businesses anywhere reach that milestone, let alone keep the same name and style the whole way through.
Family ownership is still front and center. Fred Yarusso, often called Freddy, is known as one of the original members still involved, and staff members like Jerry, Anthony, and Michelle are familiar faces to regulars.
Guests often mention being greeted by a cheerful older gentleman at the door. His good mood seems to set the tone for the whole meal.
Stories about the restaurant’s past are part of the experience too. The staff are happy to share bits of history, and many diners say hearing those tales is a treat on its own.
That sense of continuity explains why so many people call it an institution. Grandparents who came as kids now bring their own grandchildren.
Longevity like this does not happen by accident. It comes from hard work, steady recipes, and a family that keeps showing up year after year.
And all of that history is right there on the walls, which brings us to the dining room itself.
Murals, Photos, and Old-School Charm
Forget sleek modern design. The dining room here leans proudly into the past.
Historical photos line the walls, showing many of the people connected to the restaurant over the years. Original paintings and Italian murals add color, including a well-known painting of the Colosseum.
Wooden decor and warm lighting round out the look. The result is genuine and comfortable rather than slick.
Many guests describe the visit as going back in time. It is a cozy, old-style space, exactly the kind of room people hope for in a family-owned Italian spot.
It is also low-key. This is not a candlelit fine-dining room, and nobody expects you to dress up.
Families settle in easily, couples find it relaxed for a date, and solo diners can enjoy lunch without fuss.
Cleanliness also comes up often, with tidy tables and a well-kept space.
For vintage-minded Minnesotans who enjoy places with a story on every wall, the decor alone makes for good browsing between bites. Just leave room for what is coming out of the kitchen.
The Spaghetti and Meatballs Everyone Talks About
Meatballs come up more than any other topic when people discuss this restaurant, with well over a hundred mentions.
The reason is simple. They are huge, often served as a single oversized meatball perched on top of the pasta.
Spaghetti and meatballs is considered the famous dish here, the one many first-timers order to see what the hype is about. Fans call it the kind of filling meal that feels like your mom made it.
Opinions are honestly mixed, and that is worth knowing. Some diners find the sauce lighter and simpler than they expected, while others say the food tastes just like they remember from years ago.
That loyalty speaks loudly. People who grew up eating this spaghetti keep coming back for exactly that familiar style.
The red sauce can also be ordered in a half-and-half style with other options, which lets diners mix things up.
Portions are generous enough that leftovers are common. One plate of pasta can easily turn into a second meal at home.
So is it the spaghetti that sticks in your mind for days? For many longtime fans, the answer is yes, especially when the meatball is the size of a small planet.
Beyond Spaghetti: Signature Pastas
Spaghetti may grab the headlines, but the rest of the pasta lineup has its own fan club.
Fettuccine alfredo is one of the most talked-about plates, often ordered with chicken. Some love its rich, thick sauce, while others prefer something lighter.
The pasta supreme, a signature dish, gets praise for arriving hot and fresh. It is big enough that one diner managed to stretch a single lunch into three meals.
Spaghetti supreme is another option for those who want extra on their plate.
Mostaccioli shows up in several forms, including baked and supreme versions. Ravioli is a frequent favorite too, available with cheese or meat and that half-and-half sauce choice.
Italian sausage with red sauce is another popular pick. Lasagna is on the menu as well.
Vegetarian diners can find meatless choices, though vegans may have a harder time.
The menu is simple and focused. No gimmicks, just classic Italian-American comfort dishes that have stayed on the board for generations.
With this many pasta paths, deciding might be the hardest part of the visit.
A St. Paul Classic Called the Hot Dago
Ask St. Paul locals about regional sandwiches, and one name keeps popping up on this menu.
The hot dago is a longtime local favorite built around Italian sausage. It earns frequent mentions, and fans call it amazing.
There is also a sloppy version that comes with peppers and mushrooms. Wednesday lunch regulars rave about it.
This sandwich has a special place in St. Paul’s East Side food history. Ordering it here connects diners to that local tradition.
It pairs well with a group meal too. Tables often share it alongside pasta, so everyone can try a bit.
For food-focused day-trippers looking for something they cannot easily find elsewhere, this is one item worth putting on the list.
It also makes a solid choice for those who want something hearty without committing to a full plate of pasta.
Spaghetti may be the star of the headline, but this sandwich is quietly stealing scenes at plenty of tables. Next up, the extras that start the meal.
Starters and a Sweet Finish
Good meals often begin before the main plate lands, and the appetizer list here helps with that.
Garlic cheese bread is a crowd favorite, praised for being nicely garlicky. Cheese sticks and spicy fried ravioli also show up on many tables.
Calamari and bruschetta are on the menu for those who want something different. Pizza is available too, and the cheese pizza is described as massive.
Bread arrives at the table with butter packets. Some guests love it, while others find it plain, so expectations should stay simple.
Salads come with meals, though the dressing gets mixed opinions.
Then there is dessert. The tiramisu is a real standout and is often called the highlight of the visit, even by guests who were lukewarm about other dishes.
That says a lot about how well it lands.
Saving room is a smart move. Between the big meatballs and large portions, it takes some planning to make it to the end.
A to-go box for the pasta might be the secret to getting that tiramisu in.
Careful Gluten-Free Cooking
Few old-school Italian spots put this much thought into gluten-free diners.
The restaurant offers gluten-free pasta that is described as celiac safe. Fred Yarusso led a detailed training protocol to make it work.
Pans, colanders, and utensils for gluten-free cooking are kept in a separate area. That reduces the risk of cross-contamination.
Gluten-free dishes are also served on plates with a red ring around the edge. The visual cue helps prevent mix-ups between the kitchen and the table.
Staff are trained on why these steps matter. That attention gives families with celiac needs more confidence when ordering.
Red sauce with Italian sausage is one gluten-free combination that gets strong praise.
For families where one member usually has to sit out of pasta night, this is a meaningful detail. Everyone can share the same table and enjoy the meal together.
It is a thoughtful touch from a kitchen that could easily rest on tradition. Instead, it chose to make room for more guests.
Birthdays, Buffets, and Big Celebrations
Some families do not just eat here. They celebrate here.
Birthday dinners are a common tradition, and the restaurant has a side room that can seat a large group. Surprise parties have been pulled off there with plenty of food for everyone.
Catering is another big part of the business. Couples have booked the team for weddings and praised how stress free the night felt.
New Year’s Eve parties have been catered too, with easy pickup and helpful staff.
On weekdays, the lunch buffet offers a quick way to sample the classics. It is popular with workers and anyone wanting a midday pasta fix.
The staff get frequent credit for being kind, friendly, and hardworking. Servers make guests feel valued, which matters at a big gathering.
Even late arrivals have been welcomed warmly. One group showed up ten minutes before closing and still got a full meal.
All of that makes this spot a natural choice for milestones. The food fills the plates, and the people make the memories.
Hours and Planning Tips
Timing is everything here, because the doors close earlier than many restaurants.
Hours run from 11 am to 7 pm Tuesday through Sunday. The restaurant is closed on Mondays.
Those shorter hours are one of the few common complaints. Early dinner plans work best, especially for groups.
The weekday lunch buffet is a good fit for anyone visiting midweek.
Prices are generally described as affordable, though a few guests feel some dishes run high for what arrives. Big portions help balance that out, since leftovers are typical.
Dress is casual, and the mood is relaxed. Families with kids fit right in.
Those with dietary needs should mention them when ordering. The gluten-free system is well established, and vegetarian options are available.
For more details, the restaurant’s website is yarussos.com.
A little planning goes a long way, and an early arrival means more time to linger over dessert.
A Table Worth Returning To
Not every plate will win over every diner, and that is fine.
Opinions on the sauce and certain dishes vary. Some first-timers leave wishing for bolder flavors, while longtime regulars say the food tastes exactly as it should.
What rarely gets questioned is the heart of the place. A family has kept this kitchen running since 1933, and it shows in every friendly greeting.
The giant meatballs, the hot dago, the tiramisu, and the careful gluten-free setup all give food-focused day-trippers solid reasons to visit.
The old photos and murals add a dose of history that newer restaurants simply cannot copy.
It works well for families, birthday crowds, casual dates, and anyone curious about St. Paul’s East Side traditions.
Go early, bring an appetite, and plan for leftovers.
That spaghetti might just stay on your mind for days, and the people serving it will likely stay there even longer.
Share this story
