Some Old Town errands end with a quick coffee. Others end two hours later at a wooden table with a board of cheeses you could not pronounce when you sat down. Fort Collins has a spot that turns a casual walk downtown into a slow European-style afternoon, without a passport, a long flight, or a reservation scramble.
Exposed brick, warm wood, and a counter stacked with wheels from Spain, France, Italy, and right here in the States set the stage. The shop is run by a Colorado State University alum and staffed in part by students, which gives it a hometown heart. Families have swapped crowded brunch lines for it, and local clubs have leaned on it when plans fell apart.
Keep reading to learn where it is, how ordering works, what to expect on the bill, and why so many Northern Colorado residents keep coming back.
1. A Cheese Counter on Walnut Street
Old Town Fort Collins hides plenty of good stops, and one of the most beloved sits at 200B Walnut St, Fort Collins, CO 80524, in the United States. The name on the door is The Welsh Rabbit Cheese Shop.
Part cheese shop, part bistro, and part wine bar, it resists a single label. Guests can buy cheese to take home, sit down for a board, or settle in for lunch or dinner.
The address puts it right in the walkable heart of downtown. That makes it an easy add-on to a shopping trip, a stroll, or an evening out with friends.
The owner himself calls it a little corner of Old Town. Plenty of locals would say it feels more like a little corner of Europe that happens to have a Colorado zip code.
With a 4.8-star standing across more than 600 public opinions, the place has earned a loyal following. That is a lot of satisfied cheese lovers for one modest storefront.
Residents who have walked past it for years often say the same thing afterward. They wish they had stopped in sooner.
2. Brick, Wood, and an Unhurried Mood
Exposed brick meets wood-clad walls inside, and the effect is relaxed rather than fancy. Small details sit tucked into corners all over the room.
The space is cozy without feeling pretentious. Guests describe it as the kind of room where slowing down comes naturally.
That unhurried mood is a big part of the Old World comparison. Nobody seems to rush a cheese board here, and the staff does not push anyone out the door.
Crowds tend to stay manageable too. One Mother’s Day, a family facing a 45-minute brunch wait nearby wandered in and found a calm table instead.
Window seats are a quiet favorite. Regulars like to sit by the glass with bread, cheese, and a bottle, watching Fort Collins go about its day.
It is the rare downtown spot where an hour can pass without anyone checking a phone. For a busy week, that alone may be worth the trip.
3. Roots in Rams Country
Local pride runs deep at this counter. The business is alumni-owned, with ties to Colorado State University, and it employs students on its team.
The owner has spoken openly about how much CSU support means to the shop. That support comes from colleges and offices across campus, not just one department.
The CSU Management Department, for example, has worked with the shop for years. Staff there have relied on it for catering and curated gift bags at events with faculty, alumni, and business partners.
For a town shaped so strongly by its university, the connection fits. Money spent here tends to stay close to home and help students earn a paycheck.
The owner also takes feedback personally. When a rough Tuesday visit drew complaints, he responded directly, used the notes for training, and invited the guest back.
Two weeks later, that same guest returned and found the team back to its usual standard. Small businesses rarely get a cleaner example of listening and fixing things.
4. Wheels From Across the Map
Cheese is the star, and the lineup travels far. Wedges from Spain, France, Italy, Canada, Wisconsin, and California can share a single case.
Past selections have included Queso de Oveja Trufado, a Spanish sheep cheese with truffle, and Royal Napoleon, a French sheep cheese. Midnight Moon, a California goat cheese, shows up often in conversations.
Honey Chevre from Canada, Port Wine Derby, an Ashley, a goat brie, and burrata from Wisconsin have also earned fans. Blue cheese lovers find options too.
The selection rotates, so the case may look a little different each visit. That variety is the reason cheese selection comes up more than any other topic among fans.
Free samples help with the guesswork. Staff are known for offering tastes so guests can choose with confidence instead of crossing their fingers.
For a curious eater, the counter works like a passport stamp collection. Each visit can add a new country to the list.
5. Building a Board Your Way
Here is the fun part. Guests can build their own board, picking cheeses, meats, fruit, and sides from the counter.
A typical spread might include five cheeses, two meats, bread, oil and vinegar, butter, wine jam, and olives. Peruvian peppers and honey have also appeared on boards.
Staff walk first-timers through the process. They help with how much to order, which is useful because everything is priced by the ounce.
For reference, one group of four found that four cheeses and two meats made a comfortable lunch. A couple on a date night went bigger, with seven cheeses, three meats, two sides, and a salad.
The pleasure lies in trying combinations. Duck with blue cheese, truffle cheese with black pepper salami, and other pairings turn the meal into a small tasting adventure.
Nobody ends up with a board they did not choose. That makes every plate a little bit personal.
6. The Meat Side of the Menu
Cheese gets the headline, but the meat counter pulls plenty of weight. Meat selection is the second most talked-about feature among regulars.
Napoli salami and an Italian black pepper Bellentani salami have both made appearances. Duck is a recurring favorite, and the kitchen has offered house-smoked duck breast.
House-made smoked salmon has also shown up on the menu. Those in-house touches give the charcuterie a homemade edge alongside imported options.
Like the cheese, meats come by the ounce. That lets guests try a little of several kinds instead of committing to one big portion.
Pairing advice is part of the deal. Staff can point toward a meat that plays well with a sharp blue or a mild goat cheese.
For the salami-curious, this counter offers a low-risk way to experiment. A few ounces at a time keeps the stakes small and the options wide.
7. Bread, Oil, and a Balsamic Bunny
Small touches matter here, and the bread service proves it. House-made sourdough comes out to anchor the board.
Olive oil arrives with a playful detail. The balsamic is poured into the shape of a little bunny, a nod to the shop’s rabbit name.
It is a tiny flourish, yet guests remember it. The owner says the team tries to be intentional even in small things, and this is a clear example.
Butter and wine jam often round out the spread. Fruit, honey, and olives give the cheese some company too.
The kitchen also creates seasonal dishes. One standout was bruschetta with olive tapenade and fermented lemon, a joint effort by two of the shop’s cooks.
Details like these separate a cheese plate from an experience. A rabbit made of vinegar is hardly essential, but it sure makes people smile.
8. Salads and Sandwiches for Bigger Appetites
A cheese board is a treat, but it is not a buffet. Hungry guests have learned that ounces add up slowly when it comes to filling a stomach.
That is where salads and sandwiches come in. The menu offers both, and they lean happily on cheese.
A burrata salad has drawn praise and was large enough for two people to share. Soups also appear on the menu, giving vegetarians and lighter eaters more choices.
Couples who build a board often add a salad. It breaks up the richness of cheese and meat and helps make a full dinner.
The practical advice is simple. Come with a moderate appetite for a board alone, or order a sandwich if hunger is serious.
Mixing a board with a salad may be the sweet spot. It keeps the tasting fun while making sure nobody leaves hunting for a second dinner.
9. Flights, Pairings, and Friendly Guidance
Choosing a drink to go with a board can feel intimidating. The team here makes it easy by suggesting pairings based on what is on the plate.
The shop carries a large selection that regulars call approachable and good value. Some options are hard to find elsewhere around town.
Flights let guests compare a few choices side by side. One recent red flight featured selections from Italy, France, and Portugal, and the owner even admits to having a favorite.
Cider and local beer options exist too. That variety gives everyone at the table something to enjoy.
Staff knowledge is a theme guests return to again and again. Servers guide people through selections instead of just taking orders.
Manager Marybeth has been singled out by name for great service, and the owner calls her the hub of the team. Good guidance turns a confusing menu into a pleasant conversation.
10. Boards That Travel to Your Party
Not every board stays on Walnut Street. The shop runs a catering service that sends spreads to weddings, campus functions, and private events.
One couple used it for a short wedding cocktail hour. Working with the team, they landed on a board that fit both the guest count and the budget.
The shop has even created cheese wedding cakes. That is stacked wheels of cheese standing in for a traditional cake.
Campus offices trust it for high-visibility events, and the team has pulled off last-minute requests without cutting corners. Curated gift bags are another option.
Flexibility extends to hosting groups. When a Fort Collins Rotary Club’s progressive dinner lost its first stop to a furnace problem, the shop welcomed the whole group on short notice.
For anyone planning a gathering in Northern Colorado, that track record offers peace of mind. A good board can save a party.
11. Gifts, Shipping, and Take-Home Treats
Plenty of guests leave with a bag in hand. The shop sells cheeses, gourmet items, and bottles to take home.
Cheese boxes make popular holiday gifts. Locals order them at Christmas to share with friends and family.
Out-of-towners have another option too. The shop ships, so a favorite wedge does not have to stay behind in Fort Collins.
That shipping service is handy for residents with relatives across the country. A box of Colorado-selected cheese makes a thoughtful surprise.
Group visits often turn into shopping trips as well. After the Rotary dinner, many members bought cheese before heading home.
A small local shop offering the kind of personal help big box stores rarely match is part of the appeal. Gifting gets a lot easier when someone behind the counter knows the product well.
12. Hours, Costs, and Smart Timing
Planning a visit is refreshingly simple. The shop is open every day of the week from 10 AM to 8 PM.
Those consistent hours make it a reliable lunch spot and an easy early dinner. A happy hour is also offered.
On cost, expect to pay by the ounce for cheese and meat. Guests describe it as a little pricey but a worthwhile treat, and the owner has noted that quality cheese and meat cost the shop a lot too.
Budget-minded diners can control the bill by choosing fewer items. Sharing a board plus a salad tends to stretch dollars further.
Outdoor seating is available when the weather cooperates. Inside, window seats are prime for people-watching.
Slow weekdays can be a calm time to drop in, and the place has been a welcome escape from crowded holiday brunch lines. A little timing goes a long way.
13. A Worthy Stop for Front Range Locals
Some places are destinations, and some become habits. This shop manages to be both for many Northern Colorado residents.
Date nights fit naturally here, and so do birthdays with friends. Parents looking for grown-up time without fuss will find a relaxed table.
Families celebrating holidays, coworkers grabbing lunch, and friends catching up on a slow afternoon all seem at home. The common thread is a desire to slow down.
It works best for curious eaters who enjoy tasting a little of many things. Guests craving one giant plate may want to add a sandwich.
For Denver-area residents, a trip up to Old Town can pair nicely with this stop. It makes an easy day outing close to home.
The shop delivers a small slice of Old World charm without the cost of a trip overseas. For that kind of escape, a few ounces of cheese seem like a fair trade.
Share this story
