5 Plain-Storefront Amish Bakeries Across Oklahoma Where Warm Fried Pies Justify The Long Drive

Some of the best fried pies in Oklahoma come from buildings you could easily drive right past.

5 Plain-Storefront Amish Bakeries Across Oklahoma Where Warm Fried Pies Justify The Long Drive
5 Plain-Storefront Amish Bakeries Across Oklahoma Where Warm Fried Pies Justify The Long Drive

Some of the best fried pies in Oklahoma come from buildings you could easily drive right past. No neon, no fancy signs, just a simple storefront, a bakery case, and a stack of fruit-filled half-moons waiting by the register.

The five stops below stretch from Route 66 near Tulsa to a county road outside Coalgate, and each one sells fried pies alongside Amish breads, cheeses, fudge, and home-style meals. Pack a cooler, bring a little cash for extras, and plan your route before the Sunday closures catch you.

1. Amish Country Store & Restaurant, Muskogee, OK

Amish Country Store & Restaurant, Muskogee, OK
© Amish Country Store & Restaurant, Muskogee, OK

Breakfast served all day is a strong opening argument, and this Muskogee stop backs it up with biscuits and gravy, pancakes, and omelettes. The building on North 32nd Street keeps things simple, with a casual dining room and a small store tucked inside.

The food is made on site from Amish recipes. Sandwiches arrive on homemade Amish bread, with chicken salad and jalapeno burgers among the favorites.

The real reason to linger near the register is the store. Shelves carry homemade fudge, butter, cheese, whole pies, and fruit-filled fried pies that are known for their generous size.

I would grab lunch first, then buy a few fried pies for the ride home. Most meals land in the $10 to $20 range per person.

Hours run 8 AM to 3:30 PM Monday through Thursday and 8 AM to 4:30 PM Friday and Saturday, closed Sunday. Saturdays get busy, so a weekday visit is calmer, and hours may change, so call ahead at 918-686-0243.

2. Sweetie Pies Amish Bakery & Cafe, Tulsa, OK

Sweetie Pies Amish Bakery & Cafe, Tulsa, OK
© Sweetie Pies Amish Bakery & Cafe, Tulsa, OK

Route 66 travelers have plenty of reasons to stop in Tulsa, and a fresh fried pie on East 11th Street is a pretty convincing one. Sweetie Pies sits in a modest storefront right along the historic highway.

Fried pies here are made fresh, so a short wait at the counter is part of the deal. The friendly staff makes that wait go quickly.

It also works as a full cafe. Hearty breakfasts, Amish chicken and noodles, and meatloaf fill out the menu, and frozen homemade meals are available to take home.

The 6 AM opening makes it an easy early start for a Route 66 day trip. It runs Monday through Saturday until 5 PM and stays closed Sunday.

Families get a kids’ menu and high chairs, plus free Wi-Fi and outdoor seating. Reservations are not accepted, Wednesdays tend to be quietest, and expect most meals around $10 to $20 per person.

3. Front Porch Bakery, Claremore, OK

Front Porch Bakery, Claremore, OK
© My Family Travels

Smoked meats and fried pies under one roof is not a combo you see every day. Front Porch Bakery, on Route 66 just outside Claremore, offers both from a plain standalone building with a porch out front.

The bakery case covers a lot of ground. Fresh fried pies and bread lead the way, joined by cakes, cookies, coconut pie, and sugar-free pies for anyone watching their sugar.

Butter from the shop’s affiliate Amish partners is another reason to bring a cooler. Deli foods and smoked vegetables round things out.

Keep in mind there is no dine-in seating. This is a grab-and-go stop, so plan to eat that fried pie in the car or save it for later.

Hours are 7 AM to 6 PM Monday through Saturday, closed Sunday, with a free parking lot. Mornings are usually quieter, and it is smart to confirm hours at 918-341-7505 before heading out.

4. Troyer’s Discount Grocery, Coalgate, OK

Troyer’s Discount Grocery, Coalgate, OK
© Travelmag

Getting here takes some intention. Troyer’s sits on County Road 1730 in the farm country outside Coalgate, in a plain metal building near the Clarita Amish community.

The drive pays off in the bakery section. Hand-made fried pies come in several flavors, so buying more than one is the reasonable move.

Amish baked bread, Amish-made cheese, and fresh farm eggs fill out the shelves, along with strong produce. Discount grocery prices keep the cart affordable.

Staff are known for being helpful and polite, which fits the small-town pace of rural southeastern Oklahoma.

The store is open 9 AM to 5:30 PM Monday through Saturday and closed Sunday. Saturdays bring the biggest crowds, so a weekday trip is easier, and a quick call to 580-258-8686 can confirm hours.

5. Amish Cheese House, Chouteau, OK

Amish Cheese House, Chouteau, OK
© Amish Cheese House, Chouteau, OK

Chouteau is home to one of Oklahoma’s best-known Amish communities, and many of the town’s bakeries and restaurants are Amish-run. The Amish Cheese House on South Chouteau Avenue makes a handy first stop.

Specialty cheeses give the store its name, but the bakery counter earns its share of attention. Fried pies are a regular purchase here.

The shelves go well beyond sweets. Homemade ice cream, dried soup mixes, and a wide range of goods made by the Amish community make it easy to leave with a full bag.

I like this stop for families since one visit covers dessert, cheese, and pantry staples. It also sits in Mayes County, an easy drive east of Tulsa.

Hours run 9 AM to 6 PM weekdays and 9 AM to 5 PM Saturday, closed Sunday. Hours may change, so check at 918-476-4811 before driving.

Share this story

Leave a response

Your email address stays private. Required fields are marked with an asterisk.