Halloween ends on November 1 for most of Colorado, but one Fort Collins storefront never got the memo. Here, undead-themed drinks share space with shelves of board games, a dice claw machine and a classic fortune teller. Teens gather after school, tabletop groups claim weekly tables, and new collectors get patient help instead of side-eye.
The best part for budget-minded locals is that it does not take a pricey road trip to find something this offbeat. Table rentals stay fairly cheap, the snacks are affordable, and the shelves are fun to browse even with an empty wallet. Keep reading to learn where this spooky spot hides along College Avenue, what makes it different from a typical game shop, and how to plan a visit that fits a busy week or a quiet weekend.
1. A Haunt Hiding on South College

Every town needs one address where the spooky season simply never closes. In Fort Collins, that address belongs to The Haunted Game Cafe at 3307 S College Ave #107, Fort Collins, CO 80525.
The business wears two hats at once. Half of it is a game store stocked for nerds of all types, and the other half is a quirky coffee bar where locals can sip drinks while playing with some of the products.
That combination sets it apart from a standard hobby shop. Shoppers can grab a new card pack, settle at a table and order snacks without ever leaving the building.
The location also suits Front Range residents who would rather skip the I-70 crush on a weekend. South College is an easy stretch for anyone in Fort Collins, Loveland or the surrounding towns.
The store sits near its sister shop, Medusa Gothic, which gives the area an extra dose of dark charm. Pairing the two makes for a fun, low-key outing.
Locals call the place a nerd paradise, and the nickname fits. The spooky theme is only the front door, and there is plenty more waiting inside.
2. Fifteen Years of Building a Community

Some businesses sell products, and some quietly become a second home. The team behind this cafe points to a community that has grown around the shop over roughly 15 years.
That history shows in how people use the space. One tabletop roleplaying group has met here at least once a week for two years, treating it as their regular spot from the very start.
Regulars mention that staff turnover appears low. Familiar faces behind the counter help explain why so many people keep returning week after week.
The shop has also earned a reputation as a queer and neurodivergent safe space. For many players, that sense of belonging matters as much as the game on the table.
Families notice the welcome too. Parents bring teens who need a place to hang out and talk, and kids who love Dungeons and Dragons ask to return with their buddies.
Long-running local businesses carry real weight in Colorado towns. This one has done it by making people feel at home rather than chasing trends, and that loyalty keeps the lights on in this haunt.
3. Undead Drinks and a Snack-Ready Café

Coffee with a side of the undead is not something most Fort Collins cafes offer. Here, the drink menu leans into fun undead themes that match the haunted name.
The cafe side carries an affordable lineup of snacks built for game night. Players can refuel during long sessions without packing a cooler or leaving mid-campaign.
The food is described as comforting and consistent, and dishes come out clean. That reliability matters when a group plans to stay for hours.
Prices on the cafe menu are considered reasonable. The quality of the food and drinks has been known to exceed expectations, which is a nice surprise at a game store.
Teens can grab snacks while their table is in play, and adults can order coffee before browsing the shelves. The setup keeps everyone fueled without a separate stop.
Some folks come mainly for the shop and leave the cafe for next time. That is fine, since the spooky drinks will be waiting whenever the craving rises from the grave.
4. Fortune Tellers, Claw Machines and Gothic Touches

Few game shops come with a fortune teller standing guard. This one has a classic fortune teller machine, plus a dice claw machine that turns a quick stop into a small adventure.
The walls carry thematic decorations that create a cool, slightly spooky mood. The effect blends a relaxed gaming space with a touch of mystical charm.
The decor earns frequent praise and often comes up as a reason people describe the place as unique. It manages to feel playful rather than scary.
Many guests say the whole space feels nostalgic. That throwback appeal draws people who grew up on board games as well as those discovering them now.
Keep an eye out for Oscar too. Newcomers are encouraged to check him out, and he seems to leave quite an impression.
The overall effect is a store that rewards wandering. Each corner holds another quirky detail, so plan a few extra minutes to look around before the dice start rolling.
5. Shelves Packed for Every Kind of Nerd

Walking out with only one set of dice is harder than it sounds. One shopper planned a simple dice run and ended up spending more than $400 over three trips after spotting the roleplaying supplies and books.
The retail side covers a lot of ground. Expect board games, Magic: The Gathering products, Pokémon cards, tabletop RPGs, miniatures, paints, comics, stickers and wargame terrain.
Dice get special attention. There is a large dice chest to dig through, and the overall selection is a common highlight.
Pokémon fans can pick up bulk cards, and Magic players come for both products and events. Some say they no longer visit any other local game store.
Board game shelves lean toward entry-level and moderate-weight titles. Fans of heavy strategy games may find fewer options, and new releases can be limited.
Prices are generally reasonable, and a clearance rack offers extra savings. Browsing costs nothing, so even a window-shopping trip can turn into a fun afternoon.
6. Rent a Table, Borrow a Game

Game night at home usually means clearing the dining table first. At this cafe, groups can rent a table instead and let someone else handle the setup.
Table rentals come with access to an Open Game Library. An entire shelf holds games guests can borrow, and there is a variety of demo games to try.
One detail trips up first-timers. A table rental is required to play, so calling ahead to check availability is a smart move.
A four-hour rental is considered fairly cheap for what it includes. Families, friends and couples on a date night all use the setup.
Staff walk newcomers to their tables and explain how everything works. They also suggest games that a whole family can learn quickly.
Some regulars feel the play library used to be larger, so the selection may rotate. Many groups simply bring their own favorites to a rented table, which works just as well.
7. A Staff That Makes Beginners Welcome

Starting a new hobby can feel intimidating in a room full of experts. Here, the people behind the counter are the main reason newcomers relax.
Friendly staff is the single most mentioned theme tied to this business. New Pokémon collectors describe employees who patiently explained the basics, even on a busy day.
Team members offer game suggestions that land well. One shopper left with a game called Things in Rings and was hooked right away.
Employees also answer endless questions from curious parents while their teens play. That patience makes family outings smoother.
The owner is described as attentive and friendly. That warmth sets the tone for the whole space and keeps first visits from being the last.
The gaming area can feel cramped when it gets busy, which is worth knowing for big groups. Still, a crowded room filled with kind people beats a roomy one with cold service any day.
8. Hours and Tips Before You Haunt the Place

Timing a trip well can mean the difference between a cozy session and a full room. The cafe opens at 11 a.m. and closes at 7 p.m. on Sunday, Monday and Tuesday.
From Wednesday through Saturday, doors open at 10 a.m. and stay open until 10 p.m. Those longer evenings suit game nights and after-work meetups.
Reserve a table ahead, especially for larger groups. Arriving an hour before close still works if a table is available.
Plan time for the sister shop, Medusa Gothic, nearby. Some people even pop in after appointments at the neighboring La Rosa Tattoo.
Online, the shop sits at hauntedgamecafe.com for current details. Checking it before heading out can save a wasted drive.
With a 4.8-star standing across more than 900 opinions, the cafe has clearly found its audience. For Northern Colorado residents craving an affordable, offbeat outing close to home, this haunt is worth a visit any month of the year.
Share this story
