This New York German Butcher Has Been Smoking Sausage The Same Way Since 1937

New York used to have entire neighborhoods where German butchers lined the blocks, and most of them are long gone.

This New York German Butcher Has Been Smoking Sausage The Same Way Since 1937
This New York German Butcher Has Been Smoking Sausage The Same Way Since 1937

New York used to have entire neighborhoods where German butchers lined the blocks, and most of them are long gone. One family-owned shop on the Upper East Side never got the memo to close up and modernize.

It traces its roots back to 1937, and its sausage counter still draws people from as far away as Brooklyn. Here is the story of a butcher shop that refused to become a chain, and why it still matters to New Yorkers today.

1. A Butcher Shop on Second Avenue

A Butcher Shop on Second Avenue
© Schaller & Weber, NY

Schaller & Weber sits at 1654 2nd Ave #1, New York, NY 10028, in the Yorkville section of Manhattan’s Upper East Side. It is a German grocer, butcher and sausage maker, all packed into one storefront.

The shop is described as an old-school German market with a wide variety of wieners and imported goods. It is not a fancy food hall or a trendy concept shop.

Instead, it is a working butcher counter with shelves of German items you rarely spot in a regular supermarket. Cold cuts, cheeses, condiments and snacks share space with the sausage case.

Right next door, a small sausage stand serves hot food to people who want a quick bite. Regulars like the combination of the two, since you can grab lunch and then shop for dinner in a few steps.

The address matters for one more reason. Yorkville was once the heart of German New York, and this shop is one of the few businesses still carrying that name forward.

So the first stop on this tour is simple. It is a single storefront on a busy avenue, and it has been holding its ground for a very long time.

2. Yorkville’s Last German Holdout

Yorkville's Last German Holdout

Back in the day, Yorkville was full of German, Hungarian and Czech families. The neighborhood had its own restaurants, bakeries and bookstores that served those communities.

Most of those places have closed over the decades. Generic chains moved in, and the old European storefronts slowly faded from the map.

Schaller & Weber is one of the handful that remains. It is family-owned and reportedly dates back to 1937, which puts it among the oldest working butcher shops in the area.

Longtime locals feel this loss deeply. Some remember when several German butchers operated nearby, and they note that the last few have shut down in recent years.

That history gives this shop extra weight. People who stop in often describe it as a piece of living New York history worth supporting.

There is real pride in that idea. In a city that changes fast, a sausage shop that has stayed on the same avenue for generations feels like proof that not every good thing has been swapped out for a self-checkout kiosk.

And that is exactly why so many New Yorkers keep coming back.

3. The Sausage Case That Started It All

The Sausage Case That Started It All

Sausage is the reason this shop exists, and it is still the main event. The counter holds a long lineup of wursts, wieners and smoked links.

Fans call it the best sausage in the area. The cheddar bratwurst has a loyal following, and some shoppers stock up on several kinds at once.

The smoked sausage and the kasekrainer with Jarlsberg also get plenty of praise. One popular move is pairing them with a sweet honey mustard sold right in the store.

How long has the smoking tradition stayed the same? The shop’s roots reportedly go back to 1937, and its old-school approach is a big part of why people trust it.

Not everyone leaves happy, though. A few shoppers have said certain items did not seem fresh, so it is smart to ask the staff what came in most recently.

That small step pays off. The counter team knows the products well and will steer you toward what is best that day.

For sausage lovers, this case is the headline act, and it has been for decades.

4. Counter Staff Who Hand Out Samples

Counter Staff Who Hand Out Samples

Ask around about this place, and the first thing people bring up is often the staff, not the meat. Friendly service is one of the most common themes from shoppers.

Deli counter workers are known for patience and generosity. They happily explain products and guide newcomers toward the best items in the store.

Samples are part of the experience. Some shoppers have walked out after tasting roasted pork, ribs and other items, and a few ended up buying everything they tried.

One counter worker named Matt gets special credit for being kind and generous with samples. Shoppers say the team as a whole is accommodating and efficient.

The kindness even extends to four-legged customers. One dog owner had a large smoked bone cut into small pieces for a little pup, and the staff handled it without a fuss.

Service is not perfect every time. A few people have mentioned slow waits for sandwiches or a cool welcome at the outdoor stand.

Still, the overall picture is of a crew that cares about the people on the other side of the glass.

5. Shelves Packed With German Imports

Shelves Packed With German Imports

For such a small shop, the selection is surprisingly big. Shelves hold German condiments, snacks and packaged goods that are hard to track down elsewhere in the city.

Cold cuts and cheeses fill the cases. Pâtés are a favorite with regulars, and the truffle version has its own fan club.

Aged beef is another surprise. Some shoppers say their usual butcher does not carry it, which makes this counter a special trip.

There are even dog treats on hand. Pet owners like having a homemade option instead of something from a big brand.

The store is described as clean and well organized. That matters in a place with this many products crammed into a modest footprint.

Online customers say the in-person selection is even larger than what the website offers. One longtime web buyer finally visited and found far more than expected.

The takeaway is simple. Bring a list, but leave room for something you did not plan to buy.

6. Lunch at the Sausage Stand

Lunch at the Sausage Stand

Not every trip has to end with a bag of groceries. The sausage stand next to the shop serves hot food for a quick lunch.

There is some seating in both the stand and the shop. Many people also carry their food a short walk to sit outside nearby.

The stand’s Berlin Wall order has been listed at $18.50. Sausages there are often called a highlight of the neighborhood.

The shop also makes sandwiches, which are served until 6 pm. One butt chop sandwich was priced at $10, a number that earns plenty of praise.

Sandwich fans speak highly of tightly packed fillings and neatly sliced meat. A roast beef sandwich has been listed at $20, though one longtime fan felt a recent version fell short.

Winter can be tricky, since the stand has an open window facing the street. A cold-day order may not stay hot for long.

For a fast bite on the Upper East Side, though, this window gives a real taste of old Yorkville without any fuss.

7. Who Makes the Trip Uptown

Who Makes the Trip Uptown

Some shoppers bike all the way from DUMBO in Brooklyn every month or so. That kind of loyalty says a lot about the place.

The atmosphere is often called nostalgic and cozy. People with German roots, or with memories of old Germantown, feel right at home here.

It also suits anyone planning a party. The shop has catered events, including a birthday picnic in Central Park that left the hosts even bigger fans.

Sandwich lovers, pâté fans and sausage collectors all find something to enjoy. Dog owners get a bonus with treats and smoked bones.

Prices are a common sticking point. Many people call the quality excellent but the cost high, making it more of an occasional treat than a weekly stop.

Some who grew up with cheaper neighborhood butchers find the prices hard to accept. Others feel the quality justifies every dollar.

Overall, it fits best for people who value tradition and do not mind paying a bit more to keep it alive.

8. Hours, Timing and a Fair Verdict

Hours, Timing and a Fair Verdict

Good news for busy schedules: the shop keeps long hours. Monday through Saturday, it is open from 10 am to 8 pm.

Sunday hours run shorter, from 11 am to 6 pm. Plan ahead if a weekend sausage run is on the agenda.

Sandwich seekers should arrive before 6 pm, since that is when sandwich service wraps up. Late lunches can get tight.

Waits for made-to-order food can stretch at times. Give yourself a little extra time rather than rushing in on a short break.

Budget for higher-than-average prices. Sandwiches have ranged from about $10 to $20 based on recent orders.

So is it worth it? For many New Yorkers, the answer is yes, especially for the sausage, the samples and the friendly counter team.

It is not flawless, and a few shoppers have left disappointed. Still, a family-owned butcher that has reportedly been smoking sausage in Yorkville since 1937 is something the city cannot easily replace.

Stop by, ask what is fresh, and help keep a little bit of old New York on the map.

Share this story

Leave a response

Your email address stays private. Required fields are marked with an asterisk.