These 9 Buffalo, New York Italian Restaurants Still Serve Sunday Sauce The Way Nonna Taught Them

In Buffalo, a good red sauce is practically a family heirloom. Some kitchens here have been ladling it over spaghetti…

These 9 Buffalo, New York Italian Restaurants Still Serve Sunday Sauce The Way Nonna Taught Them
These 9 Buffalo, New York Italian Restaurants Still Serve Sunday Sauce The Way Nonna Taught Them

In Buffalo, a good red sauce is practically a family heirloom. Some kitchens here have been ladling it over spaghetti for a century, while newer spots are keeping the same old habits alive with homemade pasta and slow-cooked meat sauces.

This list covers nine Italian restaurants across the city, from Seneca Street to Hertel Avenue, where the sauce still tastes like somebody cared. Save it for your next Sunday craving, or send it to the cousin who swears their grandma made it best.

1. Chef’s Restaurant, Buffalo, NY

Chef's Restaurant, Buffalo, NY
© Chef’s Restaurant, Buffalo, NY

Since 1923, one Seneca Street dining room has been proving that a great red sauce never goes out of style. Chef’s is the kind of Buffalo institution that grandparents bring grandkids to, and then those grandkids grow up and do the same.

The house specialty is spaghetti parm, a Buffalo classic of pasta baked under melted mozzarella. Chicken parm, stuffed shells and fettuccine Alfredo round out the menu, and portions run large.

The marinara leans sweet and smooth, which is a big part of why fans call it Sunday sauce style.

You can even order extra sauce on the side, and the restaurant sells its tomato sauce to take home. Save room for the large homemade cannoli or the peanut butter pie.

Plan ahead, because current hours are limited to Wednesday and Thursday, 11 AM to 8 PM. Prices sit around $20 to $30 per person, and there is free parking nearby.

2. Santasiero’s Italian Restaurant, Buffalo, NY

Santasiero's Italian Restaurant, Buffalo, NY
© Santasiero’s Italian Restaurant, Buffalo, NY

Ask a West Side old-timer where to get pasta fagioli, and Santasiero’s on Niagara Street will probably come up first. The restaurant has served simple Italian comfort food in humble, 1920s-era digs for generations.

The signature soup appears on the menu as Pasta Fasoola, and it remains the dish people return for. Stuffed shells under melted cheese and red sauce, meatball sandwiches, veal parmigiana and spaghetti parm keep the lineup firmly old school.

The linguine and clams also has a strong local following.

Value is a big draw here. Most meals land between $10 and $20 per person, a rare price point for a sit-down Italian dinner these days.

The sauce is the real star, often compared to the kind a grandmother would make. Hours run Tuesday through Saturday from 11:30 AM to 8:30 PM, and Sunday from 4 to 8:30 PM.

3. Tappo Restaurant, Buffalo, NY

Tappo Restaurant, Buffalo, NY
© Tappo Restaurant, Buffalo, NY

Old brick, new energy, and a serious pork ragu. Tappo sits inside a restored industrial space on Ellicott Street, proving that Sunday sauce can live comfortably in a modern downtown setting.

The pork ragu over rigatoni is the dish to know, rich and hearty in the best grandma sense. Meatball entrees, a meatball bomber, chicken Milanese and alla vodka pasta with sausage give red sauce fans plenty of options.

The stuffed banana peppers are a nod to a true Buffalo favorite.

Warmer months bring rooftop seating, and weekends can include DJs and live music. Dinner runs nightly starting at 4:30 PM, so it works well before a downtown event.

Reservations are recommended, especially Friday through Sunday evenings.

4. Frankie Primo’s +39, Buffalo, NY

Frankie Primo's +39, Buffalo, NY
© Frankie Primo’s +39, Buffalo, NY

Chippewa Street is better known for late nights than slow-simmered sauce, but Frankie Primo’s +39 holds its own. The “+39” in the name is Italy’s country calling code, a small hint about where the menu’s heart lives.

Homemade gnocchi and a spicy arrabbiata show the kitchen’s red sauce side. The Tortellini Bistecca, pairing pasta with steak, is a house standout, and arancini make a smart starter.

Pizzas round things out for groups who like to share.

Diners with family roots in Sicily and Rome have praised the sauce as some of the most authentic in the city. That is high praise in a town full of Italian kitchens.

Doors open daily for lunch, with weekend hours starting at 11 AM. Expect around $30 to $40 per person.

5. Bella Ciao, Buffalo, NY

Bella Ciao, Buffalo, NY
© Bella Ciao, Buffalo, NY

Big meatballs make a big first impression. At Bella Ciao on Delaware Avenue, the meatballs come huge and swimming in marinara, which is exactly what this list ordered.

The kitchen makes its pasta in house and pairs it with a range of sauces, from tomato cream to vodka. Vodka rigatoni, eggplant parmigiana and a classic rigatoni stay close to tradition.

Seafood fans can branch out with lobster mafalde or shrimp scampi.

The setting leans upscale and romantic, so this is a good pick for a date night that still delivers grandma-style comfort. Prices range widely, from about $20 to $70 per person.

Dinner starts at 4 PM on weekdays and 3 PM Friday through Sunday. Valet parking is available.

6. JT’s Urban Italian, Buffalo, NY

JT’s Urban Italian, Buffalo, NY
© JT’s Urban Italian, Buffalo, NY

Elmwood Avenue strollers know the patio at 905 Elmwood well. JT’s Urban Italian brings a polished, cosmopolitan feel to the strip while keeping the comfort classics close.

The bolognese here is hearty and plentiful, the kind of meat sauce that sticks with you. Cutlet alla vodka, eggplant napoleon and pizzas with rich tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella keep things familiar.

For something different, the black spaghetti with rock shrimp is a signature.

Sunday is a bonus day, with a late-morning service from 11 AM to 3 PM before dinner from 4 to 9 PM. Finish with tiramisu.

Street parking on Elmwood can be tricky, so give yourself a few extra minutes. Reservations are recommended for brunch and dinner.

7. INIZIO, Buffalo, NY

INIZIO, Buffalo, NY
© INIZIO, Buffalo, NY

Small dining room, big pasta ambitions. INIZIO on Elmwood Avenue builds its menu around high-quality homemade pasta, and it shows.

Cacio e pepe is the signature, but red sauce lovers have reasons to visit too. The bolognese is a standout, and a dish called nonna’s pasta fits this list perfectly.

Gnocchi, ravioli and sweet pea agnolotti add variety, while desserts use local farmers cheese.

I would save this one for an anniversary or a quiet night out. The space is cozy and romantic, with prices around $30 to $80 per person.

Hours run Tuesday through Saturday, 5 to 9 PM, and reservations are strongly recommended.

8. Marco’s Italian Restaurant, Buffalo, NY

Marco's Italian Restaurant, Buffalo, NY
© Marco’s Italian Restaurant, Buffalo, NY

Bring an appetite, or bring containers. Marco’s on Niagara Street is known for hefty portions of classic Italian fare served in simple, homey surroundings.

Spaghetti with meatballs is the obvious order for a Sunday sauce fix. Bolognese topped with extra meatballs is a popular move, along with veal parmigiana, chicken Marsala and pasta fagioli soup.

A homemade-tasting cannoli makes a fine finish.

The vibe is casual and quiet, with a kids’ menu and high chairs for family dinners. Most meals land around $20 to $30 per person.

Hours are Wednesday 4 to 9 PM, Thursday noon to 9 PM, and Friday and Saturday 4 to 9 PM. Free street parking is available.

9. Lombardo, Buffalo, NY

Lombardo, Buffalo, NY
© Lombardo, Buffalo, NY

Look up when you walk into Lombardo on Hertel Avenue, because the copper ceiling is part of the charm. The Lombardo family has reportedly run this North Buffalo staple since 1975.

Old-world Italian cooking is the focus, with homemade pasta leading the way. Tagliatelle bolognese is the pick for traditional meat sauce, and hot banana peppers bring a Buffalo touch.

Linguini carbonara, crispy octopus and day boat scallops show the menu’s range.

This is a special-occasion spot, with prices around $50 to $100 per person and gelato for dessert. Valet parking and a patio add to the experience.

Reservations are required. Hours run Monday through Friday from 5 PM and Saturday from 4:30 PM, closed Sunday.

Share this story

Leave a response

Your email address stays private. Required fields are marked with an asterisk.