A cheese aged four months in a Texas cave took first place at the 2023 American Cheese Society competition. That alone made me sit up. The cheese is called Keystone, and it starts as raw milk from Jersey cows.
The woman behind it spent about 15 years selling books before she ever made a wheel. Then she trained in cheesemaking in California, Vermont, and the United Kingdom. I love a career pivot that ends with a cheese cave.
The best part is that you can go see it. On the first Sunday of each month, visitors can tour the creamery’s packing and shipping facility, see its cheese-aging caves, and enjoy a guided tasting. After that, you get to taste the cheeses right where they were made.
I can’t imagine a better way to spend a Sunday afternoon. Who knew award-winning cheese was hiding in a suburban business park?
An Award Winner Is Quietly Aging Behind This Business Park Door

Nobody expects world-class cheese next to office suites. Yet River Whey Creamery has been making small-batch, cave-aged cheese in Schertz since 2014.
Founder Susan Rigg started the creamery with a clear goal. She wanted to make world-class cheese from Texas milk, and the awards suggest she’s on the right track.
The focus here is raw milk cheese aged in carefully controlled caves. That’s a slow, patient craft, and it doesn’t happen in giant batches. Every wheel gets attention before it ever reaches a shop counter.
The creamery also leans on a small, dedicated team. Instructors and tour hosts share the process with real enthusiasm. That makes a visit feel more like a lesson from friends than a sales pitch.
Don’t show up expecting a classic cheese shop with open browsing hours. River Whey works as a production creamery first, with tours, classes, and order pickups set by schedule.
That small detail matters for planning. Check the calendar, book ahead, and you’ll avoid a disappointing drive. Trust me, a little homework is worth it when the reward is cheese this good.
Mark Your Calendar For The First Sunday Of Every Month

First Sundays are the magic days. That’s when River Whey Creamery hosts its Tour and Tasting Days, with two time slots to choose from.
The monthly tour takes visitors through the packing and shipping facility, including the caves where cheeses age, before ending with a tasting of River Whey’s cheeses. It’s a peek behind a curtain most people never get to lift.
Guides explain why certain cheeses get made the way they do. Acid, heat, salt, and time all play a role. Suddenly that wedge in your fridge looks a lot more impressive.
Spots can fill up, so booking early makes sense. Since tours only happen once a month, missing one means waiting weeks. Nobody wants to wait that long for cheese.
Bring your questions, too. Curious kids and grown-up cheese nerds alike will find plenty to wonder about here. The process has more science in it than most of us expect.
Wear comfortable shoes and plan to stay engaged the whole time. Production spaces are working areas, so follow your guide’s lead. A little respect for the craft goes a long way in a place like this.
The Cheese Caves Are The Real Showstopper

Rows of wheels resting quietly on shelves sounds simple. In reality, the aging caves at River Whey Creamery are where most of the flavor magic happens.
Cave aging gives cheese time to develop deeper taste and texture. Some River Whey cheeses rest for months before they’re ready. Indigo Ridge, for example, ages at least 10 months.
The caves are built to control conditions carefully. Cheesemakers manage the environment so each wheel matures the right way. It’s slow work, and patience is the main ingredient you can’t buy.
Seeing the caves helps explain why aged cheese costs more than the grocery store block. Months of care add up. Each wheel takes up space, time, and attention long after the milk arrives.
For many visitors, this stop becomes the highlight. It’s hard not to feel a little reverent standing near cheese that’s older than your last haircut.
Take a mental snapshot while you’re there. Later, when you unwrap a wedge at home, you’ll picture where it rested. That memory makes every bite taste a little more special, and honestly, a lot more earned.
Save Room Because The Tasting Comes Right After

Here’s the payoff for all that learning. The tour wraps up with a full tasting of River Whey Creamery’s aged and fresh cheeses.
Tasting cheese at its source feels different. You’ve just seen the vats and caves, so every sample comes with a backstory. Flavor makes more sense when you know the journey behind it.
Aged and fresh cheeses offer a fun contrast. Fresh styles tend to be bright and mild. Aged wheels bring deeper, more complex flavors built over many months.
Go slowly and compare as you taste. Notice how texture changes from one cheese to the next. Even a beginner can pick up big differences once they pay attention.
A simple trick helps, too. Taste the mildest cheese first and work toward the boldest. That way, strong flavors won’t overpower the gentle ones.
Jot down your favorites before you leave. With several cheeses in one sitting, names can blur together fast. A quick note on your phone will save you from guessing later when you’re ready to order more.
Future you will appreciate the effort.
Meet The Cheeses That Keep Collecting Ribbons

Keystone grabbed first place at the 2023 American Cheese Society Judging and Competition. It’s an Italian tomme-style cheese made with raw cow’s milk and aged four months.
Then there’s Indigo Ridge, the creamery’s best-seller. This Gouda-Gruyere hybrid ages at least 10 months. The American Cheese Society certified it as an American Original, which is a pretty fancy title for a Texas cheese.
St. Clements brings a sunny twist. This seasonal cheese features organic oranges, lemons, and local Texas honey. It took first place in 2016 in the fresh-flavored cheese category.
That’s a lineup with range. You get a rustic tomme, a long-aged crowd-pleaser, and a bright, citrusy treat. Each one shows off a different side of the team’s skills.
Not sure where to start? Indigo Ridge is a smart first pick since it’s the top seller. Keystone makes a great follow-up for anyone curious about award winners.
Keep an eye out for St. Clements when it’s in season. Seasonal cheeses come and go, so grab it when you can. Waiting too long might mean another year of wishing.
A Bookseller Turned Cheesemaker Wrote A Great Second Chapter

Fifteen years in book retail is a long first act. Susan Rigg eventually closed that chapter and chased her love of food instead.
She studied at the Culinary Institute of America in San Antonio and New York. Then she zeroed in on cheese. Her training included artisan cheesemaking at Cal Poly San Luis Obispo and Sterling College.
She didn’t stop at classrooms, either. Rigg also interned at dairies in the United Kingdom. That hands-on time helped shape the old-world techniques behind River Whey Creamery’s cheeses.
I like how her story makes the cheese feel personal. Every wheel carries years of study, travel, and stubborn curiosity. That kind of path rarely happens by accident.
Her journey also offers a nice reminder for anyone dreaming of a career change. It’s never too late to start learning something new. Sometimes the best plot twist arrives in the middle of the book.
Tour guests often hear parts of this story along the way. Listening closely adds meaning to the tasting that follows. Knowing the person behind the cheese makes each bite feel like a page from her story.
Jersey Cows And Happy Hogs Both Play A Part

Great cheese starts with great milk. River Whey Creamery gets its fresh raw milk from Four E Dairy, a multi-generational Jersey cow farm in Moulton, Texas.
Jersey cows are known for rich milk. That richness gives cheesemakers a strong foundation. Starting with quality milk makes a big difference by the time a wheel finishes aging.
Working with a nearby family farm also keeps things local. The milk doesn’t travel across the country. It comes from Texas pastures straight to the Schertz make room.
Now for the clever part. Cheesemaking leaves behind a liquid called whey, and lots of it. Instead of wasting it, River Whey sends it to Pure Pastures, a farm that feeds it to hogs.
That’s a neat little loop. Cows feed the cheese, and the cheese leftovers feed the pigs. Nothing useful goes down the drain.
The creamery’s name even nods to that leftover liquid. It’s a fun detail to share at your next cheese board gathering. Your friends will be impressed, and the hogs at Pure Pastures would probably agree that sustainable thinking deserves a round of applause.
Roll Up Your Sleeves And Make Cheese Yourself

Watching is fun, but making is better. River Whey Creamery offers hands-on cheesemaking classes for beginners and experienced home cooks.
Newcomers can start with fresh cheeses. Ready for a challenge? Advanced classes tackle cheddar, gouda, and even blue cheese.
That’s a big leap from store-bought string cheese.
Classes take place at the creamery, 17361 Bell N Dr #115, Schertz, TX 78154. Learning in a real working facility adds a lot of excitement. You’re making cheese where award winners are born.
Groups can also book curated five-course sit-down tastings. These events explore cheese pairings and flavors in more depth. They work well for clubs, friends, or anyone celebrating something special.
A class makes a memorable gift, too. Think birthdays, anniversaries, or a date night with a tasty twist. Everyone leaves knowing more than they did when they arrived.
Spaces are limited, so check the schedule early. Pick a class that matches your comfort level. Then show up curious and ready to stir, because cheese takes some arm work.
Your kitchen at home may never look the same again.
You Can Still Grab A Wedge When Tour Day Is Weeks Away

Cravings don’t follow a monthly calendar. Luckily, River Whey Creamery cheeses show up in plenty of stores around Texas.
Look for them at H-E-B Central Market and Whole Foods Market locations across the state. Specialty shops carry them as well. Antonelli’s in Austin and Otto’s in New Braunfels both stock River Whey cheeses.
Prefer shopping from your couch? The online shop offers nationwide shipping. Friends in other states can finally see what Texas cheese is all about.
Local fans have another option. Online orders can be picked up curbside in Schertz, Tuesday through Friday. Remember, this isn’t a walk-in retail store, so order first and then pick up.
Indigo Ridge makes a great grilled cheese, and pairings with fruit work nicely too. Grapes, jams, and crusty bread are easy wins. Keep it simple and let the cheese lead.
Planning a party? Build a board with one fresh cheese and two aged ones. That mix keeps things interesting without overwhelming anyone.
Add some local Texas honey, and you’ve got a spread that feels fancy without much effort at all.
Share this story
