Big Slices and Pinball Make This Olympia, Washington Pizza Joint Feel Like the ’80s

A fish tank glows under a disco ball inside this pizza joint. Meanwhile, the walls wear so many retro posters…

Big Slices and Pinball Make This Olympia, Washington Pizza Joint Feel Like the ’80s
Big Slices and Pinball Make This Olympia, Washington Pizza Joint Feel Like the ’80s

A fish tank glows under a disco ball inside this pizza joint. Meanwhile, the walls wear so many retro posters that the paint barely gets a word in.

The slices here are big, thin, and New York-style. Pinball machines and old arcade games wait in the back, and yes, quarters still matter.

Hair-band rock plays overhead, so the whole room hums like a mixtape from 1986.

I like how this Washington spot skips the polished chain look entirely. It leans into posters, rock music, and red plastic cups without a hint of embarrassment.

I can’t imagine a better place to fold a slice while trying to beat a high score.

So how does a pizza counter turn into a time machine? The answer starts with the crust and ends somewhere near the flippers.

Fold-Worthy New York Slices Lead the Whole Show

Fold-Worthy New York Slices Lead the Whole Show
© Old School Pizzeria, 108 Franklin St NE, Olympia, WA 98501

Thin crust is the main event at Old School Pizzeria in Olympia. The kitchen builds its menu around New York-style pies with a crisp edge and a chewy middle.

You can grab a whole pie for the group or keep it simple with a single slice. That choice matters when one friend wants pepperoni and another wants something wild.

Ordering by the slice keeps the peace at the table.

Those slices aren’t shy, either. Plenty of folks find one hanging over the edge of the plate, so plan your appetite accordingly.

Two slices can feel like a serious commitment.

Pepperoni stays a classic pick for good reason. A pepperoni slice with onions added is a popular move, and it gives the bite a little extra kick.

Simple toppings let that thin crust shine.

The folding trick works best here. Bend the slice down the middle, and it holds its shape while you walk toward the arcade.

It’s practical, tidy, and very East Coast.

Want a tip for first-timers? Start with one slice, then decide on round two.

Your stomach will appreciate the strategy, and you’ll have room to try a different topping.

Pinball Flippers and Arcade Cabinets Are Waiting in the Back

Pinball Flippers and Arcade Cabinets Are Waiting in the Back
© Old School Pizzeria

Quarters suddenly feel valuable again once you spot the game area. Old School Pizzeria keeps pinball machines and classic arcade games in the back of the restaurant.

That setup turns waiting for your pizza into a mini tournament. Kids can test their reflexes, and grown-ups can relive their glory days.

Someone at your table will claim they used to be a champion.

The games run on quarters, which adds to the throwback charm. Tuck a few coins into your pocket before you head over.

Nothing slows a winning streak like an empty pocket.

Pinball rewards patience and quick hands at the same time. It’s loud, bright, and wonderfully dramatic when the ball slips past both flippers.

Good luck staying calm about that.

A large booth sits near the arcade section, too. That makes it a handy base for families who want to eat and play in shifts.

Parents can watch the action while finishing their crust.

Don’t treat the games as a side note. They’re a big part of why the place feels like a trip back to the 1980s.

Pizza in one hand, flipper button in the other, and suddenly it’s 1985.

Every Inch of Wall Space Tells a Retro Story

Every Inch of Wall Space Tells a Retro Story
© Old School Pizzeria, 108 Franklin St NE, Olympia, WA 98501

Posters cover the walls like a teenage bedroom from 1987. The retro decor at this Washington pizza spot is bold, busy, and totally committed to the bit.

Look up, and you’ll see a disco ball spinning above a fish tank. That pairing makes zero sense on paper and complete sense in person.

It’s the kind of detail you’ll describe to friends later.

Some folks call the decor a sensory overload. That’s fair, but it’s the fun kind of overload.

Your eyes keep finding something new while you eat.

Even the drinkware joins the nostalgia party. Classic red plastic cups show up on the tables, the same style many people remember from childhood pizza nights.

Small touch, big memory trigger.

The mood lands somewhere between cozy, punk, and nostalgic. It feels lived-in rather than staged, which helps it seem genuine.

Nobody hired a theme-park designer for this one.

Bring someone who grew up in the ’80s or ’90s. They’ll point at posters and explain each one, whether you asked or not.

Younger guests might just enjoy the color and chaos. Either way, the walls give everyone something to talk about between bites.

Turn Up the Hair-Band Soundtrack and Order at the Counter

Turn Up the Hair-Band Soundtrack and Order at the Counter

Rock music sets the tempo here. Old School Pizzeria plays hair-band hits and other loud, fun tunes that match the decor perfectly.

The ordering system is simple and counter-based. You place your order, find a seat, and listen for your name when the food is ready.

There’s no table server bringing menus around.

That name call is part of the charm. It’s quick, loud, and a little theatrical, much like an East Coast pizza counter.

Keep one ear open while you play pinball.

Busy times can stretch the wait for fresh pies. Weekends tend to fill up fast, and seating is limited to a handful of booths plus some bar-style stools and tables.

Showing up a bit early is a smart move.

Want to skip the scramble for seats? Takeout is an easy option when the room is packed.

Your pizza travels well, especially if you grab foil for the leftovers.

The staff fits the vibe, too. Expect a crew that enjoys the punk and metal spirit of the place.

It all adds up to a pizza joint that feels more like a hangout than a formal dinner spot.

Thick-Crust Fans Get a Sicilian Square of Their Own

Thick-Crust Fans Get a Sicilian Square of Their Own

Not everyone wants a skinny crust, and the menu gets that. Alongside its thin pies, Old School Pizzeria serves Sicilian pizza with a thicker, square-cut style.

It’s a nice balance for mixed groups. One person can chase the classic fold, while another grabs a sturdier slice.

Everyone wins, and nobody sulks.

Ordering a Sicilian slice along with a regular slice is a popular combo. It lets you compare both styles side by side.

Call it a delicious science experiment.

Sicilian pizza traces its roots to Sicily, where thick, bread-like pies have a long tradition. Italian immigrants carried versions of it to New York.

That’s why it often appears on East Coast-style menus.

The square shape changes how you eat it, too. You’ll probably want both hands, or at least a napkin on standby.

Folding is not really an option here.

If you’re feeding hungry teenagers, this is worth remembering. A thicker slice can go a long way toward filling them up.

Pair it with a thin slice for variety, and the meal feels complete without overthinking the order.

Garlic Knots and Ranch Deserve a Spot on Your Tray

Garlic Knots and Ranch Deserve a Spot on Your Tray

Sides can steal the spotlight if you let them. Garlic knots are a favorite add-on at Old School Pizzeria, and they make a great warm-up before the pizza arrives.

Twisted dough and garlic are hard to resist. Share a batch with the table, or guard it closely.

Both strategies are valid.

Then there’s the ranch. It earns a surprising amount of praise for a dipping sauce.

Many fans call it the best they’ve tried.

Dunking crust into ranch is a classic move for good reason. It turns the leftover edge into a second snack.

Thin crust plus creamy dip is a strong combo.

Salads are on the menu, too, including a garden salad. That’s handy if you want something fresh beside all that cheese.

It also makes the meal feel a little more balanced.

The spice shelf adds extra fun. You’ll find more than just basic pepper flakes, with seasonings to level up your slice.

Experiment a little and find your favorite shake.

Small extras like these make a casual pizza run feel like a real outing. Don’t skip them just because the slices are big.

Gluten-Free Eaters Can Join the Party Too

Gluten-Free Eaters Can Join the Party Too

Food restrictions don’t have to mean sitting out pizza night. Old School Pizzeria offers gluten-free pizza, which opens the door for more of your crew.

That’s a big deal in a group outing. Nobody wants to watch friends eat while nibbling on a sad side salad.

Here, everyone can grab a pie.

Vegan-friendly choices show up as well. One creative option uses a vegetable medley with cashews.

It’s not your average topping plan, and that’s part of the appeal.

Dairy-free options are offered too, though choices can vary. Asking at the counter is the best way to know what’s available that day.

A quick question saves a lot of guesswork.

A long list of toppings helps you build what works for you. Mix vegetables, meats, or a little of both.

Custom pizzas make picky eaters surprisingly happy.

Here’s a practical tip for gluten-free diners. Mention your needs clearly when you order, especially on busy nights.

Clear communication keeps everyone comfortable.

It’s refreshing when a retro-themed spot still keeps up with modern diets. The vibe says 1985, but the menu thinking feels current.

The Fountain Soda Lineup Is Weirder Than You’d Expect

The Fountain Soda Lineup Is Weirder Than You'd Expect

The fountain soda selection might be an unexpected highlight of the visit. The fountain lineup at this Olympia pizza joint goes beyond the usual cola-and-lemon-lime routine.

Uncommon soda flavors fit the retro theme nicely. They feel like something from an old corner shop or a roller rink snack bar.

Picking one becomes part of the fun.

There are also beer and soda options to go.

Pour your choice into one of those red plastic cups, and the nostalgia meter jumps again. The cup alone could start a conversation about birthday parties in 1992.

It’s basically a time capsule you can drink from.

Kids will love testing flavors. Adults might find themselves doing the same thing, just with more dignity.

Or not.

A fizzy, fruity soda also pairs well with salty pepperoni. The sweetness cuts through the richness, so each bite feels fresh.

It’s a small detail that makes the meal better.

Next time you order, skip the default choice. Try something you’ve never heard of.

The worst outcome is a fun story.

Downtown Olympia Makes It an Easy Stop Any Day of the Week

Downtown Olympia Makes It an Easy Stop Any Day of the Week
© Old School Pizzeria

Finding the place is the easy part. Old School Pizzeria sits at 108 Franklin St NE, Olympia, WA 98501, right in the downtown area of Washington’s capital city.

The hours are generous. The doors open at 11 AM every day, closing at 10 PM Sunday through Thursday.

Friday and Saturday nights stretch to 11 PM.

That schedule works for lunch breaks, family dinners, and late-night cravings. Few things beat a big slice after an evening downtown.

Arcade games make the late hours even more tempting.

Street parking is available nearby, though busy times can take some patience. Give yourself a few extra minutes.

Circling the block is easier with good music on.

Accessibility gets attention, too, with a wheelchair-accessible restroom. Ask staff for the restroom door code when you need it.

It’s a quick step that keeps things running smoothly.

Road-trippers passing through on Interstate 5 can make a quick detour here. It’s a fun break from chain stops along the highway.

Plus, you’ll leave with a story about pinball and a fish tank.

Plan your visit, bring some quarters, and save room for a second slice. The ’80s are waiting downtown.

Share this story

Leave a response

Your email address stays private. Required fields are marked with an asterisk.