A fine dining chef opened a smash burger shack next to a tackle shop. Yes, really.
And the house burger comes loaded with grilled onions, which feels like a very smart chef move.
The idea is simple and kind of brilliant. The owner calls it smashed, but gourmet, built for folks grabbing lunch on the way to the beach. I like how honest that pitch sounds.
The spot sits on an island in Massachusetts, where summer days fill up fast. There are only four tables inside, so most orders head straight out the door. I believe that tiny setup is part of the charm.
Onion rings, tater tots, and milkshakes add a little extra comfort to the menu. Sometimes, all it takes is good food, familiar favorites, and a laid-back atmosphere to turn a simple takeout stop into a place you keep coming back to.
Those Grilled Onions Are Doing Some Serious Work
Grilled onions sit right at the heart of Wicked Burger. The namesake Wicked Burger features them, and so does the Wicked Bacon Burger.
That choice tells you a lot about the kitchen. Onions bring sweetness and depth, and they turn a plain patty into something with real personality.
The burgers here are smash burgers, pressed onto the grill for that classic style. Pair that method with grilled onions, and you’ve got a combo burger fans have loved for generations.
Want the full package? The Wicked Burger Combo also includes grilled onions, so you can grab sides without losing the star ingredient.
I like that the menu doesn’t hide its best idea. The onions show up front and center, right on the signature burger.
It’s a smart move for a shop in Massachusetts beach country. A burger with grilled onions feels hearty enough for a long day outside, yet simple enough to eat in a hurry.
If you only order one thing, start with the house burger. It carries the name for a reason, and the onions make that reason pretty clear.
A Fine Dining Chef Went Casual, And It Worked
Here’s a fun twist. Wicked Burger is owned by Chris Stam, the chef-owner behind Alchemy, a fine dining restaurant in Edgartown.
So the same mind behind upscale plates decided to tackle burgers. That’s a little like a concert pianist starting a garage band, and honestly, it sounds like a great time.
The concept is described as smashed, but gourmet. In plain words, you get a fast, casual burger with a chef’s attention behind it.
Stam wanted a straightforward, delicious, grab-it-on-your-way-to-the-beach restaurant. That’s a clear goal, and the whole place seems built around it.
I can’t imagine many fancy chefs wanting to work this hard on a quick lunch. Yet a chef’s background often shows in small choices, like the grilled onions on the signature burger.
This also explains the menu’s focus. Instead of trying to be everything, the shop keeps things tight and fun.
For you, that means less guessing and more eating. Pick a burger, add a side, and head out into the island sunshine with something made by people who clearly care about food.
Not A Beef Fan? The Menu Still Has Your Back
Every group has that one person who doesn’t want beef. Good news, nobody gets left out at Wicked Burger.
Beef burgers lead the menu, of course. But you’ll also find crispy chicken, veggie, and fish burgers, plus hot dogs for anyone craving a classic.
The fish option feels especially right for Martha’s Vineyard. You’re on an island surrounded by ocean, after all, so a fish burger fits the setting nicely.
The veggie burger is a handy choice for plant-leaning eaters. It means a mixed crowd can order from one counter without a long debate in the car.
Hot dogs are a quiet win for kids. Some young eaters want something simple, and a hot dog keeps lunch drama to a minimum.
I believe a short menu with smart variety is the sweet spot. You don’t get lost in choices, yet everyone finds something.
So bring the burger lovers, the chicken fans, and the fish folks. The whole crew can grab lunch in one stop and still make it to the beach on time.
Onion Rings Or Tater Tots? Prepare For A Tough Choice
Sides can make or break a burger run. At Wicked Burger, the side list reads like a greatest hits album.
You can pick french fries, onion rings, tater tots, chicken fries, or coleslaw. That’s five ways to round out your meal, and every one fits a beach lunch.
Onion lovers, take note. If the grilled onions on your burger aren’t enough, onion rings let you double down on the theme.
Tater tots bring a little childhood nostalgia to the table. They’re bite-sized, easy to share, and perfect for passing around in the car.
Chicken fries are a playful pick too. They work as a side or a snack for someone who isn’t super hungry.
Coleslaw adds something cool and crunchy. It’s a nice balance next to a hot, savory burger.
My advice? Order more than one side if you’re with a group.
Then everyone can try a little of everything, and nobody has to settle the great rings versus tots debate alone.
Save Room, Because The Milkshakes Are Calling
A burger without a shake feels a little unfinished. Wicked Burger seems to agree, since milkshakes sit right on the menu.
Shakes and burgers have been best friends for decades. It’s a pairing that works on a hot island afternoon, and frankly, on a cool one too.
A cold shake also travels well to the shore. Sip it on the drive, and you’ll arrive at the beach in a much better mood.
For families, a shake can double as dessert. That saves you a second stop for ice cream, which might just save your afternoon schedule.
I like how a shake balances a salty, savory meal. Sweet and cold next to hot and crispy is a combo that rarely misses.
Flavors can change, so check the menu board when you order. Specials sometimes pop up, which gives you a reason to look closely before deciding.
One tip: order your shake last if you’re dining in. That way it stays thick while you finish your burger and fries at one of the small tables.
Four Tables Inside Means Takeout Is The Real Move
Space is tight here, and that’s on purpose. Wicked Burger is mainly set up for takeout, with just four sit-down tables inside.
That small setup fits the mission perfectly. The shop wants you to grab your food and get on with your island day.
Still, those four tables are a nice option. If you want to eat your burger fresh and hot, you can grab a seat when one’s free.
Online ordering makes takeout even easier. Place your order ahead, and you can skip some of the waiting at the counter.
I think that’s the smartest way to visit during busy summer days. Plan ahead, pick up, and you’re back on the road quickly.
Hours are simple to remember too. The shop runs daily from 11:30 AM to 8 PM, covering both lunch and dinner.
That schedule works for early beach trips and late sunsets alike. So whether you need fuel at noon or supper after a long swim, the counter is ready for you.
Neighbors Include A Tackle Shop, Which Says A Lot
Location matters, and this one is wonderfully practical. You’ll find Wicked Burger at 258 Upper Main St, Edgartown, MA 02539.
The shop sits right next to Larry’s Tackle Shop. It’s also across the street from a Stop & Shop grocery store.
That lineup makes it a natural pit stop. Grab bait, grab snacks, grab burgers, and your beach or boat day is basically planned.
Upper Main Street is a handy route for many island travelers. You don’t have to squeeze into the busiest part of downtown Edgartown just to get lunch.
I love how unfussy that feels. It’s a burger stop for real island days, not a place you need to dress up for.
Anglers heading out can pick up food along with their gear. Beachgoers can stock up across the street and add hot burgers to the cooler bag.
Massachusetts has plenty of scenic drives, but this stretch is all about errands done right. One quick stop here might cover the whole afternoon.
The New Kid On Upper Main Street Moved In Fast
Wicked Burger is still pretty young. It opened its doors in early May 2024, just in time for the island’s busy season.
The groundwork started months earlier. In January 2024, the Edgartown select board approved a common victualler’s license for the eatery.
That license is the town’s okay to serve food to the public. It’s a small piece of paperwork, but nobody gets a burger without it.
The shop also took over a familiar spot. It now fills the space that once held R&B’s Eatery.
So the building kept its food-loving tradition going. A new name moved in, and the grill stayed busy.
I find it fun when a fresh business gives an old space new life. It keeps the neighborhood feeling lively instead of empty.
For a shop this new, the quick start is impressive. In just a short time, it has become a go-to burger stop on Martha’s Vineyard, and that’s no small feat on an island with plenty of food choices.
A Silver Award Proves These Burgers Have Range
Shiny hardware never hurts. Wicked Burger earned a Silver award for burgers as a Best of Cape Cod winner in 2026.
That’s a big deal in this part of Massachusetts. The Cape and Islands have no shortage of burger stops, so standing out takes real effort.
For a shop that opened in 2024, the timing is impressive. It went from new kid to award winner in about two years.
I believe awards like this matter most to first-timers. If you’re unsure where to eat on the island, a regional honor helps narrow the list.
The win also backs up the shop’s whole idea. Smashed, but gourmet, turns out to be more than a catchy phrase.
So how should you celebrate? Order the signature Wicked Burger with its grilled onions, add some onion rings, and toast with a milkshake.
Then take it all to the beach and enjoy the view. Award-winning food tastes even better with sand between your toes and a breeze rolling off the water.
Share this story
