The 12 Remote Adirondack, New York Restaurants Worth Every Mile Of Two-Lane Road

Out in the Adirondacks, the next real meal can be 30 miles of pine trees away.

The 12 Remote Adirondack, New York Restaurants Worth Every Mile Of Two-Lane Road
The 12 Remote Adirondack, New York Restaurants Worth Every Mile Of Two-Lane Road

Out in the Adirondacks, the next real meal can be 30 miles of pine trees away. That is exactly why the restaurants on this list matter so much to the folks who live up here and the drivers who pass through.

These are places where the plates come piled high, the pies are baked in-house, and the menu still tastes like somebody cares. Pack a full tank, pick a route, and plan your stops around these 12 small-town spots.

1. Long Lake Diner & Owl’s Head Pub, Long Lake, NY

Long Lake Diner & Owl’s Head Pub, Long Lake, NY
© Long Lake Diner & Owl’s Head Pub, Long Lake, NY

Long Lake has fewer than 800 year-round residents, so the diner on Main Street does a lot of heavy lifting. It handles breakfast, lunch, and dinner for a big stretch of the central Adirondacks along NY-30.

Portions run large here, and the kitchen leans into comfort food like meatloaf and pizza made with homemade dough. There is also a full vegetarian menu, a kids’ menu, and high chairs for the little ones.

The patio comes with a lakeside view, and dogs are welcome both inside and out. Prices typically land in the $10 to $20 per person range.

Check the calendar before you go. It closes Tuesday and Wednesday, serves until 8 PM on Thursday, until 10 PM on Friday and Saturday, and wraps up at 2 PM on Sunday and Monday.

Sunday mornings are the busiest stretch, and reservations are accepted.

2. Noon Mark Diner, Keene Valley, NY

Noon Mark Diner, Keene Valley, NY
© Noon Mark Diner, Keene Valley, NY

Hikers coming off the High Peaks have a pretty clear idea of where they want to eat, and it usually involves pie. Noon Mark Diner sits right on NY-73 in Keene Valley, and its homemade pies are the reason a lot of people slow down.

The kitchen also turns out its own jams and breads, plus all-day breakfast. Club sandwiches and turkey vegetable soup cover the lunch crowd without fuss.

Grab a table outside if the weather cooperates. The mountain views from the outdoor seating area are a big part of the appeal.

Plates come piled high, and most meals run about $10 to $20 per person. Weekend mornings get crowded with trail traffic, so an early start helps.

Dogs are allowed outside, which matters to the many hikers who bring a four-legged partner.

3. Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner, Blue Mountain Lake, NY

Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner, Blue Mountain Lake, NY
© Chef Darrell’s Mountain Diner, Blue Mountain Lake, NY

A restored vintage diner car in the middle of the Adirondacks is a sight that makes road trippers hit the brakes. Chef Darrell’s sits along NY-30 in Blue Mountain Lake, right on the way to several of the region’s best-known lakes.

The chef greets diners himself, which gives the place a personal touch you rarely find anymore. The biscuits and gravy are the dish to know about, and the breakfast and lunch specials keep things hearty.

Vegan and vegetarian diners have full menus too, which is a nice surprise this deep in the woods. Kids have their own menu as well.

Hours are simple: 8 AM to 3 PM, seven days a week. Saturday and Sunday afternoons draw the biggest crowds, while weekday mornings stay quieter.

4. The Little Fox Restaurant, Eagle Bay, NY

The Little Fox Restaurant, Eagle Bay, NY
© The Little Fox Restaurant, Eagle Bay, NY

Big Moose Road is the kind of drive where you start wondering if you missed a turn. Then The Little Fox shows up, serving scratch-made cooking in the western Adirondack backcountry.

The menu mixes creative dishes with crowd-pleasers like wings and burgers. Desserts are made from scratch too, and there is a full vegetarian menu.

It is a small, quiet room with a dinner-only schedule. Doors open Thursday through Saturday from 5 to 9 PM.

With so few nights to choose from, reservations are a smart move. Expect to spend roughly $30 to $40 per person.

5. Oxbow Inn, Lake Pleasant, NY

Oxbow Inn, Lake Pleasant, NY
© Oxbow Inn, Lake Pleasant, NY

Sunset from the back deck is the unofficial specialty at the Oxbow Inn. The restaurant sits on NY-8 in Hamilton County, the least densely populated county in New York.

Pizza is a big part of the identity here, and the pickle pizza is the one that gets people talking. Fish and chips and wings round out the comfort lineup.

Portions are generous, with most meals running $10 to $20 per person. The crowd tends to be a friendly mix of locals and summer visitors.

There is a fireplace for cooler nights and outdoor seating for warm ones. It is open Wednesday through Saturday from 11 AM to 9 PM and Sunday until 8 PM.

6. The Deer’s Head Inn, Elizabethtown, NY

The Deer's Head Inn, Elizabethtown, NY
© The Deer’s Head Inn, Elizabethtown, NY

History buffs and food lovers both get something out of a stop in Elizabethtown. The Deer’s Head Inn operates in a historic building in this small town of about 1,200 people, between the High Peaks and Lake Champlain.

The kitchen calls itself farm to tavern, cooking with locally sourced ingredients. Trout and pulled pork are two dishes that show off that local angle.

Vegan and vegetarian menus are available, and dogs are allowed inside. A fireplace adds to the old-inn charm.

Want to stay the night? There are six boutique rooms upstairs, each with a queen bed, private bathroom, and a record player.

Dinner runs Wednesday through Sunday from 5 to 9 PM. Reservations are recommended.

7. Screamen Eagle / Matts Draft House, Inlet, NY

Screamen Eagle / Matts Draft House, Inlet, NY
© Screamen Eagle / Matts Draft House, Inlet, NY

Peanut butter panic wings. That name alone earns Screamen Eagle a spot on any Adirondack road trip list.

The pizza shop sits on NY-28 in Inlet, a lakeside hamlet with a year-round population of around 300. Signature wings and pizza, including a pesto pie, are what keep people coming back.

It is a casual, family-friendly room with a kids’ menu and outdoor seating. Dogs are welcome outside.

Plan for no reservations, since it runs first come, first served. Hours are 3 to 9 PM Tuesday through Friday and noon to 9 PM on weekends, closed Mondays.

Most meals stay in the $10 to $20 range.

8. Indian Lake Restaurant, Tavern and Liquor Store, Indian Lake, NY

Indian Lake Restaurant, Tavern and Liquor Store, Indian Lake, NY
© Indian Lake Restaurant, Tavern and Liquor Store, Indian Lake, NY

Motorcycle groups, families, and fishing crews all seem to find their way here. Indian Lake Restaurant sits right on NY-30 along the Adirondack Trail, making it an easy lunch break mid-ride.

The menu is big, which is handy when a large group pulls in at once. Chicken black bean egg rolls are a fun twist alongside the comfort food standards.

Vegan and vegetarian menus are available, and a fireplace helps on chilly days. Prices fall around $10 to $30 per person.

It is open Wednesday through Sunday, starting at 11:30 AM most days and noon on Sunday. Closing times run a bit before 8 PM, or before 9 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.

9. Summit & Spice at NewVida Preserve, Jay, NY

Summit & Spice at NewVida Preserve, Jay, NY
© Summit & Spice at NewVida Preserve, Jay, NY

Dinner with a pond, a lawn, trails, and a fire pit is not a typical Adirondack evening. Summit & Spice is the restaurant at NewVida Preserve, a wooded estate along NY-86 in the rural town of Jay.

The menu takes a fresh, globally inspired approach, which makes it stand out among the comfort food stops on this list. Vegan and vegetarian menus are part of the lineup.

Mountain views come with the meal. On Friday and Saturday nights, there is live music too.

It is open Wednesday through Sunday from 5 to 9 PM. Reservations are encouraged and can be made online.

10. Mountainside Smokehouse & Grill, Old Forge, NY

Mountainside Smokehouse & Grill, Old Forge, NY
© Mountainside Smokehouse & Grill, Old Forge, NY

Between Old Forge and Eagle Bay, NY-28 runs through a lot of forest and not much else. Mountainside Smokehouse & Grill fills that gap with smokehouse cooking and hearty plates.

Huge portions are the standard here. The specials are fairly priced, and meatloaf is one that shows up and gets attention.

A fireplace and outdoor seating cover both seasons. Kids have their own menu.

Hours start at 4 PM Monday, Wednesday, and Thursday, with later closing on Fridays and Saturdays. Sunday opens at noon, and Tuesday is the day off.

Reservations are accepted.

11. Adirondack Mountain Coffee Cafe, Upper Jay, NY

Adirondack Mountain Coffee Cafe, Upper Jay, NY
© Adirondack Mountain Coffee Cafe, Upper Jay, NY

House-roasted coffee in a tiny AuSable River valley hamlet is a good reason to set the alarm early. Adirondack Mountain Coffee Cafe sits off Route 9N in Upper Jay.

Corned beef hash is a signature dish, and the blueberry pancakes are a strong argument for ordering sweet. Omelettes, trout, and biscuits with gravy also make the menu.

The space is roomy, with outdoor seating and a vegetarian menu. Meals usually cost about $10 to $20 per person.

Breakfast and lunch run Wednesday through Sunday from 7 AM to 2 PM. Sunday mornings are the busiest, so weekday visits are calmer.

12. The Woodshed on Park, Tupper Lake, NY

The Woodshed on Park, Tupper Lake, NY
© The Woodshed on Park, Tupper Lake, NY

Save this one for a special weekend night. The Woodshed on Park sits in Tupper Lake, a lake and lumber town reached across miles of forest on Routes 3 and 30.

The menu is small on purpose, focused on elevated comfort food built with many house-made ingredients. Small and large plates let you graze or settle into a full dinner.

It makes sense for a date night or a nicer family dinner, and people do drive in from surrounding towns for it. Expect about $30 to $60 per person.

Hours are tight, Friday and Saturday from 4 to 9 PM only. Reservations are accepted and worth making.

Share this story

Leave a response

Your email address stays private. Required fields are marked with an asterisk.