Tucked into the countryside of Smithville, Ohio, The Barn Restaurant is a real old barn that serves real country meals. People line up for the giant salad wagon, juicy roast beef, and warm bread.
Outside, a pond full of ducks and huge catfish waits for hungry visitors with a handful of quarters. Here is a look at the things that bring guests back again and again.
1. The Famous Salad Wagon

Ask anyone who has eaten here what they remember first, and the salad wagon wins by a mile. More than 500 reviewers mention the salad bar, which makes it the true star of the place.
It rolls like a farm wagon and holds more food than most people can fit on a plate.
Fresh greens, pasta salad, potato salad, fruit, pudding, and toppings sit in tidy rows. One guest said it was cleaner than the usual salad bars, and that is high praise.
Another found it better than the entrees from the kitchen.
A smart trick is to take a small first trip and look over everything. Then come back for a second plate with your favorites.
The wagon comes with menu meals upstairs, so you can build a light lunch or a full feast around it.
2. Juicy Roast Beef

Picture a Sunday dinner at grandma’s house, only the table is inside a barn. The roast beef here has earned a loyal following.
One visitor said it tasted like it had been marinating all day long.
The roast beef sandwich with mashed potatoes is a favorite order. A couple once paid about twenty-eight dollars for two meals, drinks included, and called it a great deal.
That kind of price keeps families returning.
If you like a hearty plate, ask for the roast beef dinner with gravy on the side. You can pour as much as you like and keep the potatoes fluffy.
Pair it with a trip to the salad wagon and you will leave happily full, maybe with a little pie box too.
3. An Old Barn Worth Seeing

Some restaurants have a theme. This one has a real barn, with beams, big windows, and wide open space.
Guests call it rustic, cozy, and simply beautiful.
One traveler said she could live there. Another compared it to Cracker Barrel but better.
The building is clean, well kept, and has plenty of seating, even during quiet afternoon hours.
Look up when you walk in and notice the tall ceiling and thick wood. Large windows bring in light and give views of the pond.
Parking is easy, and the staff greet you like neighbors.
Fun fact: the setting makes even a simple bowl of soup feel like a small getaway. Bring a camera, because every corner looks like a postcard from the country.
4. Feeding the Ducks and Fish

Grab a few quarters before you even sit down. The feed machines near the pond turn a meal into an outing.
Ducks waddle right up, and huge catfish swirl in the water.
Reviewers mention the ducks more than 200 times, and the pond has over 100 mentions. One diner saw some of the biggest catfish ever.
Kids squeal, and grown-ups smile just as wide.
The walk gives you time to wait for a table or burn off dessert. One family loves it so much that they want the shirt that says they cannot keep calm because they fed the ducks.
Tip: bring a small bag of coins and let the youngest child throw the feed. Stay a safe distance from the edge and enjoy the splashing show.
5. Soups and Fresh Bread

Steam rising from a warm bowl can make any gray day better. The soups here come with the salad wagon, and they get plenty of love.
Broccoli cheese is a standout, with noodles mixed in.
One guest enjoyed chicken noodle with what seemed like homemade noodles. Another loved a bean soup that tasted like her mother’s.
Chili gets praise too, especially with cheese on top.
Then there is the bread bar. You can choose a couple of breads and add butter, and the corn bread is a crowd pleaser.
It also works well for dipping in any soup.
Not every bowl pleases everyone. One reviewer thought the beef and vegetable soup missed the mark.
So sample a spoonful first, then fill your bowl with your best pick.
6. The Downstairs Buffet

Hungry crowds head downstairs for the buffet, especially on weekends. It is a big spread with chicken, ham, turkey, and meatloaf.
There are also sides, soups, fruit, and a huge salad bar.
Dessert is part of the fun, with ice cream, brownies, and no-bake cookies. A family of kids was thrilled with the number of choices.
Another couple paid about fifty dollars for two at Sunday lunch.
Opinions vary a little. Some say the food could use more seasoning, but salt and pepper sit right on the table.
Others said everything seemed hot and fresh.
Plan ahead by arriving a bit early, since a Thursday evening visit once meant a short wait. Check the posted hours, because Sunday closes earlier at three in the afternoon.
7. Pork Chops and Comfort Plates

Country cooking means big plates and familiar flavors. The pork chop dinner gets rave reviews, and one diner called it phenomenal.
Another said it melted in the mouth.
Green beans, mashed potatoes, and gravy round out the plate. One guest wished the gravy had a bit more punch, but still enjoyed the meal.
Meatloaf and pulled pork sandwiches also show up in happy reviews.
Fried pickles and the famous barn fries make good starters or shared snacks. Add ketchup to the fries and you are set.
Not every dish wins every heart. A few people found the sirloin or burgers plain.
If you want the best odds, stick with the classic homestyle dishes and let the salad wagon fill in the rest.
8. Pie for Dessert

Save room. That is the advice from more than one happy guest.
The pie selection is long, and each slice looks like it came from a farm kitchen.
The Dutch apple pie is a favorite. A reviewer said the filling had excellent flavor and the streusel on top was fresh and sweet.
It tasted like a treat made that very morning.
If your stomach is full, ask for a slice to go. It makes a fine snack for the car ride home.
You can also share one slice among the table and add a cup of coffee.
Fun idea: pick a pie you have never tried. With so many choices, you might find a new favorite worth the drive.
9. Friendly Service

Good food is nice, but kind people make a meal memorable. Reviewers often name their servers and praise them.
Connie and Terra both earned warm shout-outs.
One family said Terra remembered their orders, even after the mother spent a long time away in Florida. That sort of care is rare.
Another diner said they should have tipped triple.
Staff keep things moving even when a crowd shows up. Guests described them as friendly, attentive, and professional.
Waits of fifteen or twenty minutes on a busy night felt fine thanks to the cheerful welcome.
Tip: ask your server for favorites, since they know the menu well. A little kindness in return goes a long way, and it may earn you a new regular spot in the barn.
10. Shops and Treats Nearby

The fun does not stop when the plates are cleared. A toy store nearby has old world toys, and people of all ages play with them.
Kids and grandparents both find something to smile about.
Next door, the Oak Cupboard offers coffee and sweet goodies. One regular always walks over for a treat after dinner.
Another visitor is often too full for an ice cream cone, which is a nice problem to have.
Plan a slow afternoon. Eat first, stroll the grounds, feed the ducks, and then browse the shelves.
The Barn Restaurant sits at 877 W Main St, Smithville. It opens at 11 AM daily, closes at 8 or 9 PM, and shuts early on Sundays at 3 PM.
Call 330-669-2555 for details.
Share this story
