A statue of the Virgin Mary, found sealed inside a restaurant wall, reportedly kept turning itself to face the wall. I read that sentence twice. Then I went looking for more stories like it.
It turns out Texas has a whole menu of them. One dining room supposedly fills with the scent of an old owner’s rose perfume. Another spot claims a former president still lingers in the room where he once recruited soldiers.
I love that these stories come with real history attached. We’re talking buildings from the 1850s, 1870s, and 1920s, with secret cellars and walled-off rooms. The food gets top billing, but the backstories are just as filling.
Halloween weekend feels like the right time to test the rumors yourself. Grab a friend who scares easily. Order something good, keep one eye on the hallway, and see who blinks first.
1. The Phoenix Saloon
Chili powder was invented in this building, so the place already has a habit of making history. William Gebhardt created it here in 1894, and the kitchen still leans into that spicy legacy.
The Phoenix Saloon first opened in 1871 in downtown New Braunfels. It also claims to be the first spot in Texas to serve women, though they had to sit in a separate garden and ring a bell for service.
Yes, a bell. Manners were very different back then.
Today the menu is a burger lover’s playground. You’ll find big double cheeseburgers and hot dogs smothered in the house Texas Red Chili.
Chili fans should treat this as a pilgrimage. Ordering chili here is a bit like eating cake at the actual birthday party.
Look around while you wait for your food. An exposed original 1871 brick wall and salvaged beadboard paneling let the old building show its age in the best way.
Now for the spooky part. Staff and guests have reported doors and windows opening and closing on their own.
Others mention footsteps on the upper floors late at night, when nobody should be up there. Some describe a shadowy figure drifting down the second-floor hallway, often with a sudden chill.
Many people connect that figure to John Sippel, the man who built the place. Apparently, he never fully checked out.
Want the best shot at a story worth telling? Go a little later in the evening and ask about the building’s past if the staff has a free moment.
Halloween weekend adds an extra layer of fun. Few things beat a chili dog with a side of creaking floorboards.
Pair your visit with a stroll through downtown New Braunfels. The town’s German roots make the whole trip feel like a step back in time, ghosts optional.
Address: 193 W San Antonio St, New Braunfels, TX 78130
2. The Grey Moss Inn
A restaurant that relights its own candles sounds like a fire hazard, but here the staff blames a lady named Mary. Mary Howell opened this Helotes inn as a dinner restaurant back in 1929.
The inn sits among old oak trees off Scenic Loop Road. That shaded setting gives it a rustic, romantic look that suits a ghost story perfectly.
After closing during the pandemic, it reopened in 2023 with a fresh direction. Siblings Martha Valadez, Marisol Mendoza, and Zeke Martinez brought in a Northern Mexican-inspired menu.
That menu is worth the drive on its own. Look for milanesa made with filet mignon, chicken and beef fajitas, and ribeye tacos on homemade tortillas.
So, about Mary. Many people believe she still keeps an eye on her beloved inn.
Guests have claimed to see her figure moving through the dining room. Others say they’ve caught the scent of her rose perfume out of nowhere.
Staff have reported tables rearranging themselves and candles relighting after being blown out. Honestly, that’s better housekeeping than most of us manage at home.
The stories get even stranger. A security camera reportedly caught a glass flying off a shelf, and faucets left open during a remodel were later found closed.
Maybe Mary just can’t stand a wasted drop of water. Most innkeepers have standards.
Make a reservation for an evening meal if you can. Darkness under those oak trees adds a delicious bit of suspense to the drive in.
Wear something nice, too. A place this old deserves a little effort, and Mary might be watching.
Helotes sits just northwest of San Antonio. It’s an easy Halloween weekend escape from city noise into Hill Country quiet.
Address: 19010 Scenic Loop Rd, Helotes, TX 78023
3. The Tavern Bar & Grill
Austin got one of its first air-conditioned hangouts in 1933, and it may have come with a permanent guest. The Tavern started out in 1916 as the Enfield Grocery Store.
The building was modeled after traditional German public houses. During Prohibition, rumors claimed the upstairs hid a casino and other secret business.
When Prohibition ended, it officially became The Tavern in 1933. Customers got a rare luxury that year: cool, conditioned air in a Texas summer.
These days, the food is classic pub-style comfort. Burgers and wings lead the way, served in a room with dark wood and floor-to-ceiling windows.
There’s also a deck outside. On a crisp October evening, that’s a great perch for people-watching on West 12th Street.
Emily is the building’s resident ghost, and she reportedly prefers the upstairs. Staff and guests have blamed her for a long list of pranks.
Local legend ties her to the building’s rowdy 1920s past. The details shift depending on who tells the story, which only adds to the mystery.
Look for the shoes on display inside. They’re reportedly linked to Emily, and they make the legend feel oddly real.
The Tavern even hosts improv nights and mystery dinners. Check the schedule before Halloween weekend, since a themed night could double the fun.
History buffs will enjoy its long run as a neighborhood gathering spot. More than a century later, it’s still serving guests, living and otherwise.
Sit near the stairs if you want to test your nerves. If your fries vanish, though, that’s probably just your friend.
Order the wings and keep your phone camera ready. You never know who might photobomb your plate.
Address: 922 W 12th St, Austin, TX 78703
4. Menger Hotel
Teddy Roosevelt recruited Rough Riders here, and some guests say he never really left. The Menger Hotel opened in 1859 right next to the Alamo in San Antonio.
William and Mary Menger founded it. It’s often called the oldest continuously operating hotel west of the Mississippi River.
For a meal, head to the Colonial Room Restaurant. It serves traditional and Southwestern dishes, plus a breakfast buffet and a popular Sunday brunch.
Save room for dessert. Menger Bread Pudding and the hotel’s famous mango ice cream have been on the menu for more than a century.
Mango ice cream with a side of ghosts? That’s a combo you won’t find at the mall food court.
The hotel’s spooky reputation is huge. It’s said to host as many as 32 spirits, which sounds like a very full guest list.
People have reported footsteps, whispers, and even floating utensils in the kitchen. Roosevelt’s figure is often linked to the room where he recruited his troops, sometimes with a whiff of tobacco.
Then there’s Sallie White, a Victorian-era chambermaid. Guests say she appears on the third floor, still wearing her maid’s uniform.
Captain Richard King, founder of the famous King Ranch, gets mentioned too. He’s said to pace in his former suite, now called the King Ranch Suite.
Plan some extra time before or after your meal. The Alamo sits right next door, so you can pack a lot of Texas history into one afternoon.
Brave visitors can even book a room overnight. Ask about the third floor if you’d like to say hello to Sallie.
Address: 204 Alamo Plaza, San Antonio, TX 78205
5. Moonshine Patio Bar & Grill
A cellar that once worked as a secret Prohibition hideout is now a lounge with a library. That’s just one layer of history at Moonshine Patio Bar & Grill in downtown Austin.
The restaurant sits inside the Waterloo Compound, a group of restored 19th-century limestone buildings. One of them once housed the Hofheintz-Reissig General Store, dating to the 1880s.
Moonshine opened in 2003 and focuses on scratch-made Southern comfort food. Homemade biscuits and mac and cheese are on the lineup, and the Sunday brunch buffet has won awards.
Brunch with a backstory? Sign us up.
Look for the Sunday House, built in 1854. It’s the last remaining building of its kind in Austin and now hosts private events.
The old cellar is called the Kinfolk Lounge & Library. Its original limestone walls are a direct link to the 1800s.
Now for the creepy stuff. Local legend claims the building once served as a mortuary, though that story is hard to pin down.
Some guests have reported hearing trays crash against the walls during ghost talk. Apparently, the spirits here don’t enjoy being gossiped about.
Others wonder whether people swept away in long-ago floods still wander the grounds. Downtown Austin has a long history of flooding, which keeps that theory alive.
Book brunch for Halloween weekend if you can. Daylight makes the ghost stories easier to handle with a biscuit in hand.
Bring up the legends quietly, though. You don’t want to be the reason a tray goes flying.
Address: 303 Red River St, Austin, TX 78701
6. Monteleone’s Ristorante
Few restaurants can say a gangster face and a giant 1930s car greet you outside. Monteleone’s Ristorante in El Paso leans into quirky in the best way.
Owner Gary Monteleone opened it in 2001. Inside, the main dining room is designed to feel like a European courtyard, packed with odd props and relics.
The food comes with family roots. Many recipes trace back to Gary’s grandmother, who came from Reggio Calabria, Italy.
Expect homemade pasta, sauces, and bread. Dishes like tortiglioni with sauteed zucchini and Italian wedding soup show up on the menu.
The real plot twist came during an expansion. Gary found a walled-off room holding funeral prayer cards, old photos, and a 1922 charter from the Texas Spiritualist Association.
In other words, the building once hosted a spiritualist church. That’s not a detail most Italian restaurants can put on the menu.
A Virgin Mary statue was also found hidden in the walls. According to the stories, it would turn itself to face the wall from time to time.
Other reports get stranger. Staff and guests have described an arm reaching from behind the front door and a man seen without feet.
Self-lighting candles and unexplained voices round out the list. The happenings were even featured on Syfy’s Paranormal Witness in 2013.
Grab a seat in the courtyard-style room and order a big plate of pasta. Comfort food helps when the candles start acting up.
El Paso sits at the far western tip of Texas, a long way from the other spots here. Still, this one earns the road trip.
Snap a photo of the car out front before you leave. It’s the rare haunted-restaurant souvenir that won’t follow you home.
Address: 3023 Gateway Blvd W, El Paso, TX
Share this story
