This Dayton, Ohio Restaurant Has Been Serving Italian-American Classics Since 1971

Right on North Main Street in downtown Dayton, a small pizza shop has been feeding hungry crowds for more than fifty years…

This Dayton, Ohio Restaurant Has Been Serving Italian-American Classics Since 1971

Right on North Main Street in downtown Dayton, a small pizza shop has been feeding hungry crowds for more than fifty years. Flying Pizza is family owned, a bit old school, and loved for its hand-tossed New York style pies.

Locals, office workers, and visitors all stop in for a big, hot slice. Here are ten things that make this Dayton favorite worth a visit.

1. A Family Story Since 1971

A Family Story Since 1971
© Flying Pizza

Few restaurants can say they have been around since 1971, but Flying Pizza can. Opened over fifty years ago, it has stayed in the family and kept its small-business heart.

Reviewers often call it a historic pizza joint, and the name still carries weight in town.

Think about how much has changed in Dayton since then. Styles came and went, and big chains popped up on every corner.

Through all of it, this shop kept making pizza the same careful way.

That staying power says a lot. People return because they trust the food and the folks behind the counter.

One longtime customer even said he has been eating here since the 70s, and he still thinks you cannot go wrong. When a place earns that kind of loyalty, it is worth a try.

2. Where to Find It Downtown

Where to Find It Downtown

Flying Pizza sits at 223 N Main St, right in the middle of downtown Dayton. That makes it an easy stop for people working nearby, staying at a hotel, or heading to an event.

You can walk in, order, and be eating in minutes.

Parking downtown can be a headache, but the shop helps with that. Customers say they get a sticker to put on their parking garage ticket, which gives an hour of free parking.

One visitor from out of town called this a big win.

The space itself is simple and no-frills. You will not find fancy decorations, just a counter, a menu, and the smell of baking dough.

That plain setup keeps the focus where it belongs, on the pizza.

3. Hand-Tossed New York Style Pies

Hand-Tossed New York Style Pies

New York style is the star here, and it came up in sixty reviews. The dough is tossed by hand, stretched thin, and baked until the bottom has a nice crunch.

The top stays soft, so each bite has a good mix of textures.

Fans say the crust is not too thin and not too thick. One happy diner called it the best crust and flavor ever.

Another said the pizza reminded him of true New Jersey pies.

The sauce is balanced, and the cheese goes on generously. Nothing tastes heavy or rushed.

If you want to know what a classic East Coast pie tastes like in the Midwest, this is a great place to start.

4. Grab a Slice and Go

Grab a Slice and Go

Short on time? Pizza by the slice was mentioned in forty-one reviews, and it is perfect for a quick lunch.

The slices are big, hot, and loaded. Most people find that two slices will fill them up.

A popular combo is two slices and a drink. It is a fast meal that fits into a work break.

Staff move quickly, and customers say the food comes out without a long wait.

One note on price: a slice costs a few dollars more than fast-food options, and one reviewer felt a combo adds up. Still, many say the size and quality make it worthwhile.

Think of it as a treat that happens to be quick.

5. Sicilian Squares With a Crispy Bite

Sicilian Squares With a Crispy Bite

Hungry for something heavier? Try the Sicilian.

This thick, square-cut pizza has a crispy bottom and a fluffy middle, which makes it very different from the thin New York pie.

One customer loved hers with pepperoni, sausage, and ricotta. She praised the thick crispy crust and said her carry-out order was ready in just fifteen minutes.

Another longtime fan simply ordered a slice and a square and skipped the toppings.

Ricotta might sound unusual on pizza, but it adds a creamy, mild flavor that works well with salty meats. Ask the staff what they suggest.

They like talking about their food, and they can help you build a square that matches your taste.

6. Toppings, Meatballs, and Breadsticks

Toppings, Meatballs, and Breadsticks

Plain cheese is great, but the topping list gives you plenty of room to play. One customer ordered Italian sausage, sliced meatballs, bacon, green peppers, and banana peppers.

Another raved about the pepperoni, calling it perfection.

The homemade meatballs deserve special mention. They are sliced and laid across the pie, and a reviewer said they are to die for.

Breadsticks also earn praise, with one regular calling them amazing.

Here is a tip from a past visitor: order a side of garlic butter or cheese for dipping. He wished he had done it.

You can also sprinkle oregano, garlic powder, or crushed red pepper on your pizza once it arrives.

7. Plain Cheese Done Right

Plain Cheese Done Right

Sometimes the simplest order says the most. One fan said double cheese is perfect and that the dough, sauce, and cheese shine without any toppings.

Another described the cheese pull as the kind dreams are made of.

That stretch comes from a generous layer of cheese melted just right. It sits on a crust that stays crisp underneath, so the slice holds its shape when you lift it.

Folks also say the sauce is not too sweet or sharp.

If you are bringing kids or picky eaters, plain cheese is a safe bet. A parent said her son called it the best pizza he has ever had.

Start here, and add toppings on your next trip.

8. Friendly Faces Behind the Counter

Friendly Faces Behind the Counter
© Downtown Dayton Partnership

Ask regulars why they return, and many mention the people. The staff earned seventeen mentions for being welcoming.

Names like Tony, Frank, and Jackson pop up again and again in praise.

One visitor said customers chatted with workers as if they had known them forever. Another felt treated like a regular on a first visit, and like family on the second.

That warm feeling is rare in a busy downtown.

Owners also keep a sense of humor. A diner called the owner a funny guy who made lunch more fun.

Good service will not change how the crust tastes, but it makes the whole meal better, and it keeps people smiling as they walk out the door.

9. Carry-Out, Reheating, and Other Tips

Carry-Out, Reheating, and Other Tips
© Flying Pizza

Planning game night? Flying Pizza works well for takeout.

One customer called in an order and found the crew ready when he arrived. Another drove less than fifteen minutes and said the pizza was still warm.

Reheating is smart, too. A reviewer noticed the dough got a bit chewy as it cooled, but warming it in the oven made the quality better.

Use a hot oven or skillet instead of a microwave to bring back the crunch.

You can also dine in if you want a hot slice right away. Check the hours first.

The shop opens at 10 AM most days, 11 AM on Saturday, closes at 7 PM, and is shut on Sunday. The phone number is 937-222-8031.

10. What to Know About Price and Value

What to Know About Price and Value
© Another Food Critic – WordPress.com

Let’s be honest about cost. One reviewer noted that a slice runs five to six dollars, and two slices with a drink can pass fifteen dollars.

Compared with a cheap chain deal, that can feel high.

Yet the rating tells a bigger story. With 4.6 stars from more than 1,100 reviews, most guests feel the taste is worth it.

One longtime fan said the prices are not retro like the sign, but the meal is worth every penny.

If you want to save, order a whole pie and share it with friends. A few reviews mention a cleanly kept space and quick service, which adds value.

Treat it as a quality meal, not a bargain bite, and you will likely leave happy.

Share this story

Leave a response

Your email address stays private. Required fields are marked with an asterisk.