This New Jersey Costume Shop Feels Like Halloween All Year Long

Somewhere along Park Avenue in Rutherford, there's a place where a pirate hat, a Victorian gown, and a pair of vampire…

This New Jersey Costume Shop Feels Like Halloween All Year Long

Somewhere along Park Avenue in Rutherford, there’s a place where a pirate hat, a Victorian gown, and a pair of vampire fangs could all be part of the same shopping trip. The Fun-Ghoul Costume Company isn’t your typical seasonal Halloween store.

It’s a longtime North Jersey specialty shop known for theatrical costumes, unusual accessories, professional makeup, and an impressive collection of props. Whether you’re preparing for a themed birthday party, putting together a school production, or simply searching for something wonderfully ridiculous to wear, this is the kind of place that understands the assignment.

Its history stretches back to the 1980s, when costume shopping meant visiting a real store and getting advice from someone who knew the difference between a convincing character and a cheap disguise. Even after decades of changing shopping habits, Fun-Ghoul’s story remains a reminder that dressing up can be serious business, even when the results are wonderfully silly.

A Rutherford Costume Shop That Keeps the Halloween Spirit Alive All Year

A Rutherford Costume Shop That Keeps the Halloween Spirit Alive All Year
© The Fun-Ghoul Costume Company

Most Halloween stores have a predictable life cycle. They appear in vacant storefronts around September, fill their shelves with plastic skeletons and superhero outfits, and disappear shortly after the last trick-or-treater heads home.

The Fun-Ghoul Costume Company built its reputation by doing things differently. Located at 155 Park Avenue in downtown Rutherford, this specialty business became known for supplying costumes and theatrical accessories throughout the year, rather than limiting its offerings to October.

That year-round approach made perfect sense for a business serving more than neighborhood Halloween parties. School plays need costumes in February.

Community theater productions happen in June. Corporate theme nights, historical reenactments, and birthday celebrations don’t wait for autumn to roll around.

Having a dedicated costume resource in Bergen County gave customers somewhere to turn when ordinary clothing stores couldn’t provide what they needed. The location was another part of its charm.

Rutherford’s Park Avenue is a recognizable downtown shopping corridor, with independent businesses and restaurants providing a welcome alternative to the sprawling shopping centers found elsewhere in North Jersey. Fun-Ghoul fit that independent-business tradition while offering something considerably more theatrical than the usual retail experience.

Its specialty was never simply selling a packaged outfit featuring a recognizable movie character. The business dealt in theatrical clothing, accessories, makeup, and custom costume needs, giving customers the opportunity to create looks with considerably more personality.

There is something appealing about a shop where dressing like a medieval knight or a 1920s socialite is treated as a perfectly reasonable request. Fun-Ghoul made room for that kind of imagination, whether the occasion called for elaborate theatrical clothing or one unmistakable accessory.

The shop also had something seasonal pop-ups rarely achieve: a history that connected generations of local customers through school productions, celebrations, and memorable costumes. Halloween might have been its busiest season, but it was never the only reason people needed a little theatrical transformation.

Inside Fun-Ghoul Costume Company’s Impressive Collection of Costumes

Inside Fun-Ghoul Costume Company's Impressive Collection of Costumes

Six thousand costumes is not the kind of inventory you expect to find behind an ordinary storefront. Yet that was the approximate size of Fun-Ghoul’s theatrical and period costume rental collection, according to descriptions of the business.

It was an unusually substantial wardrobe for a neighborhood specialty shop, with choices extending far beyond the standard witches, vampires, and superheroes. The emphasis on period clothing was particularly interesting.

Historical costume themes can be surprisingly difficult to get right, especially when an event calls for something more convincing than a polyester outfit with a vaguely old-fashioned silhouette. A Roaring Twenties party, for instance, might require a flapper-style dress, a period-inspired suit, gloves, or a distinctive hat.

A Renaissance-themed celebration could call for entirely different fabrics, shapes, and accessories. Fun-Ghoul’s assortment historically covered everything from medieval and Egyptian-inspired outfits to pirates, Gothic characters, historical figures, and theatrical fantasy.

Promotional materials also highlighted costumes representing different decades, including fashions associated with the 1920s through the 1970s. That breadth made the collection useful for people who had a specific appearance in mind rather than simply wanting something funny to wear.

Consider a theater group staging a period production. Finding costumes that work together visually is a different challenge from choosing one outfit for a party.

Colors, silhouettes, accessories, and character roles all matter. A specialty costume supplier can help a production achieve a consistent look without requiring every piece to be created from scratch.

Individual shoppers had plenty of reasons to appreciate that variety, too. Someone planning a themed celebration could explore several versions of an idea rather than committing to the first outfit that appeared in an online search.

Perhaps the most interesting thing about a collection this extensive is the unexpected inspiration it can provide. You might begin searching for a specific historical character and discover that another period offers a much more entertaining possibility.

The shop’s inventory reflected decades of experience in theatrical costuming, a field where imagination matters, but the right clothing makes all the difference.

Why Renting a Costume Here Might Be Better Than Buying One

Why Renting a Costume Here Might Be Better Than Buying One

A full Renaissance costume looks terrific at a themed wedding. Finding somewhere to store it afterward is another matter entirely.

That’s one of the strongest arguments for renting instead of buying, particularly when an event requires an elaborate outfit that probably won’t see much use afterward. Fun-Ghoul developed a substantial rental operation precisely because theatrical clothing often makes more sense as a temporary wardrobe addition than a permanent purchase.

A good costume involves more than the main garment. There may be matching pieces, period-specific details, unusual shapes, or decorative elements that would be difficult to reproduce with ordinary clothes.

Buying everything separately can become expensive, especially when the final result only needs to survive one evening. Renting allows customers to consider more elaborate possibilities without committing to owning the complete ensemble.

There are practical advantages beyond storage. Properly maintained theatrical clothing is designed to be worn for performances and special occasions.

Many pieces have more convincing proportions and details than inexpensive novelty costumes, helping the wearer look like an actual character rather than someone who grabbed an outfit during a last-minute shopping run. Of course, renting requires a different kind of preparation.

Sizing is especially important, since theatrical garments may fit differently from everyday clothing. Availability matters as well.

A popular character or historical period could be in demand around Halloween, during school production seasons, or before major themed celebrations. Customers should also understand the complete rental agreement before committing.

That includes pickup and return dates, any security deposit, cleaning requirements, and potential charges for damage or late returns. Fun-Ghoul’s historical rental operation was extensive, but current inventory, pricing, and rental arrangements should always be confirmed directly.

The rental option also made particular sense for school groups, theatrical productions, and organizations arranging events that required several coordinated costumes. Purchasing an entire wardrobe for a short production can be difficult to justify, especially when those outfits are unlikely to be used again.

For individual customers, the appeal was refreshingly simple. Rather than choosing the cheapest costume available and hoping for the best, they could explore clothing designed to make an occasion feel genuinely special.

A costume doesn’t have to become a permanent closet resident to deliver an excellent night out.

From Vintage Accessories to Theatrical Makeup and Unusual Props

From Vintage Accessories to Theatrical Makeup and Unusual Props

Sometimes the difference between an average costume and a memorable one comes down to a single detail. A carefully chosen hat can establish an entire historical period.

A pair of long gloves can transform a simple black dress. The right makeup can make someone almost unrecognizable without requiring an elaborate outfit.

Fun-Ghoul understood that accessories were not an afterthought. They were a major part of the costume-building process.

The store became known for carrying masks, wigs, gloves, theatrical makeup, and other specialty accessories that helped customers complete their looks. Its offerings included professional-grade makeup supplies, prosthetics, and special-effects materials, which placed it in a different category from stores selling inexpensive prepackaged Halloween outfits.

Those products can make a considerable difference when someone is preparing for a performance. Stage makeup, for example, is designed to create visible effects under lighting conditions that can wash out ordinary cosmetics.

Character makeup may exaggerate facial features, establish age, or help transform a performer into something entirely fictional. Prosthetics can take things further, adding physical details that ordinary makeup cannot easily reproduce.

Fun-Ghoul’s theatrical background made these products a natural fit for its business. The accessory selection also offered a practical solution for customers who already owned most of what they needed.

Instead of renting or purchasing a complete costume, someone attending a masquerade party might only need an eye mask. A 1920s-themed outfit could come together with appropriate gloves, jewelry, and a headpiece.

Then there were the props. The business was associated with an extensive prop collection serving different themes, including medieval settings, tropical parties, holiday celebrations, and haunted attractions.

Such pieces could help transform an ordinary event space into something more convincing. Imagine the difference between a Halloween party with a few paper decorations and a themed gathering built around theatrical props, coordinated costumes, and carefully considered lighting.

The latter starts to feel more like a production. Fun-Ghoul’s connection to professional entertainment and special events made that larger-scale approach part of its identity.

Its parent operation, Cliffhanger Productions, has worked with themed attractions, festivals, and elaborate event concepts. Not every customer needed an entire haunted house, of course.

Sometimes a distinctive mask or an unusual accessory was enough to give an otherwise ordinary outfit its personality.

A Local Favorite That Has Been Helping New Jersey Residents Dress Up for Decades

A Local Favorite That Has Been Helping New Jersey Residents Dress Up for Decades

The story behind Fun-Ghoul is almost as colorful as the clothing it became known for selling. The business was established in the 1980s by Cliff Witmyer and his mother, Caesarine, also known as Cis.

Its beginnings were rooted in a family operation that grew into a recognizable name in North Jersey’s costume and entertainment industry. Over the following decades, the shop developed connections that extended well beyond Rutherford.

Witmyer’s work in costume design included creating outfits for musicians associated with major rock acts, including Aerosmith, Bon Jovi, Deep Purple, Twisted Sister, and Pat Benatar. That’s quite an impressive collection of names for a business associated with a downtown New Jersey storefront.

The connection to rock music is particularly fitting. Stage costumes have always been part of how performers establish their identities, especially in genres where theatricality is practically a requirement.

Elaborate fabrics, exaggerated silhouettes, and carefully chosen accessories can become nearly as recognizable as the musicians wearing them. That professional experience gave Fun-Ghoul a distinctive background.

It was not simply a place where someone could purchase a pirate costume for a neighborhood party. The business operated within a larger world of theatrical design, entertainment production, and elaborate themed events.

Through Cliffhanger Productions, the operation was also connected to festivals, haunted attractions, and other entertainment experiences that required far more than a few ordinary decorations. This background helped explain the shop’s assortment of costumes, specialty makeup, and props.

The inventory reflected the demands of productions where visual details matter and where convincing transformations are part of the entertainment. It also made Fun-Ghoul an interesting example of a local business whose influence reached beyond its immediate community.

There was, however, a difficult chapter in its history. In October 2022, Witmyer publicly announced plans to close the retail shop after 37 years, pointing to the growing popularity of online costume shopping.

Subsequent customer accounts and business listings indicate that Fun-Ghoul continued operating after that announcement, although its current arrangements deserve verification. The fact that the business developed such a long history says something about the relationships specialty shops can build.

Customers remember the person who helped find an unusual costume, the outfit that made a school production successful, or the accessory that completed a memorable party look. Those experiences are difficult to duplicate with a cardboard box arriving on the doorstep.

What to Know Before Visiting This One-of-a-Kind Costume Shop

What to Know Before Visiting This One-of-a-Kind Costume Shop

A little planning goes a long way when you’re looking for something more complicated than a simple Halloween outfit. Fun-Ghoul’s longtime retail address is 155 Park Avenue in Rutherford, New Jersey, in Bergen County.

The shop’s listed telephone number is 201-460-1489, and business directories have historically shown regular weekday and Saturday hours, with Sundays closed. However, those published hours are not entirely consistent, and the business previously announced a closure.

Anyone considering a visit should confirm that the retail store is currently welcoming customers, along with the availability of its rental department and prop collection. That confirmation is especially worthwhile when you’re searching for a particular item.

A theatrical costume shop may have thousands of pieces in its collection, but that doesn’t guarantee that the exact costume you need will be available in your size on your preferred date. Some outfits may already be reserved, while others might require additional accessories or fitting adjustments.

Knowing your measurements can save considerable time. For historical costumes and theatrical clothing, ordinary dress or suit sizes don’t always tell the entire story.

Having basic measurements available makes it easier to discuss possible options. It also helps to think about the event itself.

A costume intended for an outdoor festival in summer has different practical requirements from one worn inside a theater or at a winter masquerade. Heavy layers, elaborate headpieces, and restrictive accessories can look fantastic while presenting challenges that become obvious after several hours.

For anyone interested in theatrical makeup, it’s sensible to ask about appropriate products, application methods, and removal. Special-effects makeup can involve adhesives, prosthetics, and ingredients that require more care than ordinary cosmetics.

And don’t overlook the surrounding neighborhood. Downtown Rutherford offers a traditional Main Street-style setting where a specialty shopping trip can fit naturally into an afternoon of exploring local businesses.

The lasting appeal of Fun-Ghoul’s concept is that costume shopping doesn’t have to begin and end with Halloween. A well-chosen outfit might be destined for a school play, a milestone birthday, a themed wedding, or an elaborate party that people remember years later.

For decades, this Rutherford business occupied an unusual corner of New Jersey retail, where historical clothing, theatrical expertise, rock-and-roll connections, and a healthy appreciation for the ridiculous could all exist under one roof.

Share this story

Leave a response

Your email address stays private. Required fields are marked with an asterisk.