Sugar cream pie, pecan pie, and a double-crusted apple pie, all with zero gluten in the building. That is the kind of Thanksgiving lineup that makes celiac folks sit up straight.
The list keeps going, too. Pumpkin, sweet potato, and cherry pies have all shown up on the holiday pre-order menu. There’s even a pumpkin roll with a dairy-free option.
For families navigating gluten-free diets, having an entire selection of pies made without gluten-containing ingredients can make holiday dessert planning much easier. It’s a welcome change from having only one option at the table.
Located inside a former post office in Columbus, Bake Me Happy specializes in gluten-free treats that bring back the flavors of childhood favorites. Its past Thanksgiving menus show just how much variety a dedicated gluten-free bakery can bring to the holiday table.
1. Six Pies, Zero Gluten, And One Very Happy Holiday Table

Bake Me Happy’s Thanksgiving pre-order page features an impressive selection of gluten-free desserts, including pumpkin, sweet potato, pecan, cherry, sugar cream, and double-crusted apple pies. Availability can change, so check the current ordering page before choosing your holiday favorites.
That is a serious spread for a bakery that never lets gluten through the door. Most gluten-free shoppers settle for one sad option. Here, the hard part is choosing.
Pumpkin and sweet potato cover the classic crowd. Pecan brings the sticky, nutty crowd to the table. Cherry and apple make the fruit fans happy without any extra begging.
Then there’s sugar cream pie, a dessert with deep roots in the Midwest. Seeing it on a gluten-free menu feels like a small Ohio-sized gift. It’s simple, sweet, and rarely offered without wheat.
The menu can shift from year to year, so check before you plan around one flavor. Still, the range has stayed impressively wide. You can easily grab two pies and call it balance.
My advice is simple. Pick one classic and one surprise. Your relatives will remember the pie, not the fact that it was gluten-free.
2. Order Early Or Watch Someone Else Take Your Pecan Pie

Thanksgiving pies here run on pre-orders, and that matters more than you might think. Holiday baking at a dedicated gluten-free shop is not a walk-in, grab-and-go situation.
Online ordering for pickup is available through the bakery’s website. That makes planning easy, even if your week is packed with grocery runs and cousin texts. Lock in your pies, then move on to the turkey drama.
The pickup spot for the main shop is 500 E Whittier St, Columbus, OH 43206. It’s on the South Side, inside a former post office building. Fitting, since you’re basically picking up a very important package.
Thanksgiving pre-orders are available through the bakery’s website, but popular desserts may sell out as the holiday approaches. Check the ordering page for current availability, pickup dates, and deadlines rather than waiting until the last minute.
Also, think about how many people you’re feeding before you click. A second pie is cheap insurance against an uncle who “just wants a sliver.” Slivers multiply quickly.
Once your order is placed, you can relax a little. Dessert is handled. Now you only have to worry about who brings the green bean casserole.
3. The Pumpkin Roll Deserves Its Own Spot On Your Plate

Pie gets the headlines, but the pumpkin roll quietly steals attention. Bake Me Happy has offered this spiral treat as part of its Thanksgiving menu.
A pumpkin roll is a soft cake rolled up around a creamy filling. Slice it, and you get that pretty swirl everybody wants to photograph. It looks fancy without asking you to do any work.
Here’s a helpful bonus. The bakery has offered a dairy-free option for the pumpkin roll. That’s huge for families juggling more than one food need at the table.
Gluten-free and dairy-free together can feel like a tough puzzle. Finding both in a holiday dessert is a real relief. One order, two worries off the list.
A pumpkin roll also works well for smaller gatherings. It slices thin and serves a crowd neatly. It’s also great for a Friday breakfast if you’re the leftover type.
Consider it your sidekick dessert. Put it next to a pie and watch which one disappears first. I’d quietly bet on the swirl.
4. Bake At Home Without The Flour Mess

Some people want to make their own grandma’s pie recipe. Bake Me Happy has helped them out by offering unbaked, frozen gluten-free pie crusts for the holidays.
That’s a smart shortcut. Gluten-free crust is famously tricky at home. It can crack, crumble, or refuse to cooperate right when guests arrive.
With a ready crust, you get to focus on the filling. Your family recipe stays in charge. The bakery just handles the part that usually causes the most stress.
Store them in the freezer until you’re ready. Thaw according to the directions, add your filling, and bake. Even a nervous baker can pull this off.
Thanksgiving also brought dinner rolls to the menu, sourced from Gluten Free Sonny Marie’s. That means bread for the table, not just dessert. Gravy finally has a gluten-free partner.
This is a great choice if you love traditions. Keep your secret pecan filling a secret. Nobody needs to know the crust came from Ohio’s busiest gluten-free kitchen in November.
5. A Strict No-Gluten Rule Means Nobody Has To Interrogate The Crust

No gluten is allowed in the bakery at all. That single rule is why Bake Me Happy feels like a safe zone for people with celiac disease.
Shared kitchens can be risky. A little flour dust can cause big trouble for some people. A dedicated space removes that guessing game.
A dedicated gluten-free kitchen makes dessert planning easier for people who avoid gluten. However, guests with other food allergies should still review the ingredients and ask bakery staff about potential allergens before choosing a dessert.
The goal here isn’t just safe food. The owners work hard to make treats that everyone wants, gluten-free or not. That’s why the pies often vanish before anyone checks a label.
Quality ingredients help too. The bakery uses Bob’s Red Mill flours, Snowville Creamery cream, and local Ohio maple syrup. Those choices support great flavor and local farms.
For hosts serving guests who avoid gluten, these desserts can make the holiday table more inclusive without sacrificing familiar flavors. Just remember to check for other dietary restrictions, since gluten-free treats may still contain ingredients such as dairy, eggs, or nuts.
6. A Love Story Started This Whole Sweet Operation

Wendy Miller Pugh developed a gluten intolerance about 20 years ago. She and Letha Pugh started experimenting with recipes, and that kitchen curiosity grew into a business.
The Pughs began crafting gluten-free treats around 2014. Their attention to detail became a calling card. They wanted baked goods that tasted great to everyone, not just good “for gluten-free.”
That mission shows in the pie lineup. A strong crust takes testing, failing, and testing again. You can’t fake a good double-crusted apple pie.
Late in 2017, they expanded into a full coffee shop. Then in October 2022, they moved into the old post office on Whittier Street. Growth like that comes from people coming back.
The owners also give back across Columbus. Letha co-owns Preston’s Burger Joint, which offers gluten-free options. They helped start Service!, which supports financial security for hospitality workers.
I like knowing my pie money goes to people who care about their city. It makes the dessert taste even better. Generosity is a pretty great ingredient.
7. Snack Cakes Named King Dong Are Waiting Beside The Pies

King Dong. Zebra Cake. Oatmeal Cream Clouds.
The everyday menu at Bake Me Happy reads like a lunchbox from the past, minus the gluten.
These nostalgic treats are a big part of the bakery’s personality. Many gluten-free eaters thought snack cakes were gone forever. Here, they come back with homemade style.
While you grab your pies, glance at the case. Spicy peanut butter cookies, donut muffins, and quinoa flake monster cookies often show up. Unicorn bars sound fun because they are.
There are also scones, lemon bars, brownies, cupcakes, and Rice Krispie treats. Selection changes, so check what’s available that day. A small box makes a great hostess gift.
Think about the long holiday weekend, too. Pie is for Thursday. A zebra cake on Saturday morning is just good planning.
Kids especially love these familiar shapes. Adults sneak them too, usually while saying they’re for the kids. Nobody believes them, but everyone understands.
8. Coffee And Groceries Make Pie Pickup Way More Fun

Few bakeries let you grab espresso, a pie, and frozen groceries in one stop. The Whittier Street shop is a spacious, brightly colored coffee spot with an expanded freezer section.
That freezer can save your holiday week. Gluten-free grocery items can be hard to find in regular stores. Here, they sit right near the dessert.
Need a warm drink while you wait? Espresso drinks are part of the menu. A latte makes standing in a holiday pickup line feel like a treat.
Hours run Tuesday through Friday from 7 a.m. to 4 p.m. Weekends open at 9 a.m. and close at 4 p.m. Monday is closed, so don’t plan a Monday pie run.
Arriving early in the day is smart around busy seasons. It gives you more choices beyond your pre-order. Afternoon visits may find thinner cases.
Treat your pickup like a mini outing. Get coffee, scan the shelves, and stock up for the weekend. Your pie will wait patiently in its box.
9. Thanksgiving Is Only The Start Of Your Cake Plans

After the pies are gone, birthdays and celebrations keep rolling in. Bake Me Happy makes custom cakes and cupcakes for special occasions.
That’s welcome news for families who usually skip the cake. A gluten-free kid at a party deserves the big slice too. Custom orders make that possible.
Ordering ahead is the way to go. Popular dates fill up, especially around holidays. A little planning keeps your celebration smooth.
Can’t make it out? Delivery through DoorDash is available from the Whittier Street location. Same-day pre-orders for pickup are offered at the South Side shop too.
There’s also a second location at North Market Bridge Park in Dublin. Still, the Columbus shop is the home base with the freezer and coffee bar. It’s worth the trip across town.
Bake Me Happy proves gluten-free baking in Ohio can be joyful, not limiting. Start with the Thanksgiving pies. Then come back for cake, because one good holiday deserves a sequel.
Share this story
