Thick pizza crust deserves better than being left on the plate, and The Steel Penny in Hatboro, Pennsylvania, gives pizza lovers plenty of reasons to appreciate every bite. Diners praise its Detroit-style pizza, known for its crispy, caramelized edges, soft and airy center, and generous layers of flavorful toppings. The contrast between the crunchy crust and the tender dough helps make this style a favorite among those who enjoy a heartier slice.
Tucked into an industrial area, The Steel Penny offers a distinctive destination for anyone willing to venture beyond the usual main street restaurants in search of a memorable meal. Whether you’re a longtime fan of Detroit-style pizza or trying it for the first time, this spot deserves a place on your radar. Here is what makes its pizza stand out, along with a few tips to help you plan your visit.
1. A Crunchy Edge Worth Saving
The last bite might be the one you look forward to most.
Several Steel Penny reviewers praise the pizza’s crunchy crust, describing an outside that gives way to a softer middle.
That contrast is a big reason its thick slices earn so much attention.
Instead of treating the edge as a handle, take a bite that includes both the crust and the center.
You get a better sense of how the textures work together.
One guest summed it up simply: crunchy outside, soft inside.
For your first order, ask the staff which current pizza best shows off that crust.
A topping choice you already enjoy can make it easier to focus on the dough without guessing about unfamiliar flavors.
Give the slice a moment to cool before digging in.
Then try the edge while it is still warm, when that crisp texture is easiest to appreciate alongside the cheese and sauce.
2. Thick Dough That Still Feels Light
Big crust does not have to mean a heavy block of bread.
Guests at The Steel Penny repeatedly describe the Detroit-style pizza as fluffy, light, and pleasantly chewy.
One reviewer compared the dough to focaccia, a helpful clue if you enjoy bread with an airy middle.
Those descriptions explain why the pizza can appeal even to someone who usually orders thinner slices.
The thickness brings texture, while the softer inside keeps each bite from feeling like nothing but crust.
Sauce and cheese still have room to shine.
Look at the cut side of your slice before taking a bite.
That view helps you notice the bread’s structure and the balance between dough and toppings.
Light texture does not mean a small meal, though.
Reviewers also call the pizza filling, so order with your appetite in mind rather than assuming fluffy dough makes the portions easy to finish all by yourself.
3. Sauces That Share the Spotlight
Crust may draw you in, but the sauce gets plenty of applause.
Steel Penny guests have singled out its vodka sauce and praised the rich sauces on its Detroit-style pies.
For anyone who thinks thick pizza is mostly bread, those comments offer a different picture.
Reviewers mention orders called Rosa and Rose Gold, along with a pizza featuring three sauces.
Because names and choices can change, check the current menu instead of assuming every past order is still available.
If sauce is your favorite part of pizza, ask the staff to explain the differences between the current options.
That quick conversation can help you choose between a familiar flavor and something a little richer.
Keep your first order simple enough to taste what makes the sauce special.
You can always explore more toppings on another visit, once you know which combination of bread, cheese, and sauce suits your own taste best.
4. Sweet and Spicy Choices With Personality
A little heat can turn pizza night into something less ordinary.
One Steel Penny guest ordered the Crusher and the Sweet and Spicy, praising both and describing the spice as hot but manageable.
That is one person’s experience, not a promise about everyone’s heat tolerance.
Still, it gives adventurous eaters a useful starting point.
If you enjoy some kick, ask whether those pizzas remain on the menu and how the staff would describe their current flavors.
Do not guess about ingredients based on a pizza’s name.
Request the topping list, especially if you have allergies, avoid certain foods, or prefer a milder meal.
Reviews give clues, but the restaurant can explain what is actually being served.
When sharing with someone who dislikes heat, agree on the order before paying.
A bold pizza is more fun when everyone knows what to expect, and nobody spends dinner wishing they had chosen something gentler.
5. Filling Slices Made for Thoughtful Sharing
Your eyes may order faster than your stomach can keep up.
Several reviewers say The Steel Penny’s Detroit-style pizza is very filling, with one describing a single slice as nearly a meal.
Another guest shared a pizza and salad with a family member.
That makes sharing a sensible option, especially on a first visit.
Ask about the current pizza size and slice count before deciding how much your group needs.
Past reviews mention specific portions, but those details should not replace today’s menu.
A salad can add a fresh break between bites of bread, cheese, and sauce.
Guests have praised the restaurant’s salads, including Caesar, although available choices and serving sizes may change.
Start with an order that matches your hunger rather than your excitement.
If you want to sample more than pizza, consider splitting another dish instead of giving every person a separate, full meal that may leave little room.
6. An Unexpected Address With Local Appeal
Follow the address, not your idea of where a pizza place should be.
The Steel Penny sits at 451 Oakdale Avenue in Hatboro, in surroundings that reviewers describe as industrial.
Guests mention nearby machine shops and a recycling or reclamation yard.
That setting is part of why people keep calling it a hidden gem.
It is not the main street backdrop some visitors expect, but many reviews praise the food and atmosphere once they arrive.
Enter the full street address into your map app before leaving.
Doing so is more useful than looking for a familiar restaurant strip or assuming the building will stand out from a distance.
If the surroundings seem unusual, check that you have reached the correct address before turning around.
The pizza is the reason for the trip, and the location offers a reminder that memorable meals do not always come with a postcard view outside.
7. Indoor Comfort and an Outdoor Option
Some pizza nights call for fresh air; others need a comfortable indoor table.
Reviews of The Steel Penny mention both indoor dining and outdoor seating, giving visitors more than one way to settle in.
One guest even enjoyed a takeout order in the outdoor area.
Do not assume an outdoor table will be open when you arrive.
A reviewer found most outside tables occupied during an afternoon visit, and weather can affect whether sitting outdoors feels comfortable.
For a group meal, contact the restaurant beforehand to discuss seating.
That is smarter than arriving with several friends and hoping nearby tables happen to be available.
Inside, guests describe a fun industrial atmosphere, though noise preferences vary.
If quiet conversation matters as much as the pizza, ask about a less busy time.
Choose your setting around the kind of evening you want, whether that means lively chatter or a slower shared meal together.
8. Helpful Staff and Honest Expectations
Not sure which pizza to pick?
Several Steel Penny guests credit the staff with explaining menu choices and helping them decide.
That guidance can be especially useful when your usual order is a thin slice and Detroit-style pizza feels unfamiliar.
The supplied listing shows a 4.8-star rating across 972 reviews, a strong sign of customer enthusiasm at that snapshot.
Ratings can change, and individual experiences still differ, so treat that number as context rather than a guarantee.
Feedback is not all identical.
Some visitors questioned prices, and one reported limits on menu changes, while another described customizable toast.
Ask about adjustments for your specific order rather than expecting one rule to cover everything.
Review the current prices before choosing, then ask any questions about ingredients or portions.
Clear expectations help you enjoy what the restaurant does well without surprises about the bill, the toppings, or whether an adjustment is possible today.
9. Plan Your Hatboro Pizza Stop
Getting the day right is the easiest part of a good pizza plan.
The supplied hours list The Steel Penny as closed Monday, open Tuesday through Saturday from 8 AM to 9 PM, and open Sunday from 8 AM to 8 PM.
Those are restaurant hours, not confirmed pizza service hours.
Before making a special trip, check steelpenny.com or call 215-346-7500 to confirm when Detroit-style pizza is available, along with any holiday changes.
The restaurant also draws praise for coffee, sandwiches, and breakfast items.
That range makes a return visit tempting, but an early opening does not mean every lunch or dinner dish is ready first thing.
For a focused first visit, confirm the menu, leave time for preparation, and arrive hungry.
Whether you share a pie or keep your order simple, the goal is the same: discover why so many guests think thick crust deserves a place at the table.
Share this story
