Some of the best bargains in St. Paul hide behind a plain storefront and a big parking lot. Vintage collectors, crafters, and eBay resellers in the Twin Cities have a weekly ritual here, and some have kept it going for more than a decade.
The secret weapon is a set of colored tags that can cut a price by as much as 75 percent on any given day. Shelves hold puzzles, pet supplies, office goods, jewelry, electronics you can test before buying, and even working musical instruments.
Not every corner is a steal, and the clothing racks spark plenty of debate. Keep reading to learn which tags to chase, which aisles deliver the most value, when to go, and what to know before you load up a basket.
The hunt is half the fun, and this guide helps you hunt smarter.
A Rice Street Address Worth Knowing

Bargain hunters on the north side of St. Paul already know the spot. MyThriftStores St Paul sits at 1657 Rice St, St Paul, MN 55117, in the United States.
From the outside, it does not look like much. The building shares a strip with a Thai market, a laundry place on one corner, and a pizza place on the other.
That modest setting is part of the appeal. Nothing about the exterior hints that the aisles inside hold everything from weighted blankets to designer perfume.
The store is a full thrift operation rather than a tiny consignment boutique. Shoppers find clothing for kids and all genders, household goods, electronics, shoes, jewelry, and a long list of odds and ends.
Plenty of locals call it their favorite thrift store in the area. Some shop monthly, some weekly, and a few treat it as a regular stop on specific days of the week.
For Minnesota collectors and crafters, the location is convenient for a quick detour. Rice Street is an easy route for anyone already moving around St. Paul.
The first lesson of thrifting applies here perfectly. Never judge a store by its parking lot.
Roots of a Neighborhood Favorite

Eleven years of monthly visits says something about a store. At least one longtime shopper has been coming that long and now calls the staff friends.
That kind of loyalty shapes the place. MyThrift has become known as a community thrift store, the type of spot where regulars recognize each other between the aisles.
Newcomers notice it too. One family that relocated from New York found it soon after arriving in Minnesota and compared it fondly to the Unique stores they used to shop.
The store is part of the MyThriftStores group, which keeps a website at mythriftstores.com for anyone who wants to learn more before heading over.
Not every chapter has been smooth. Some longtime shoppers feel the store was stronger in its early days, especially on clothing prices.
Still, the overall picture is of a store with deep local roots. People keep coming back, and many bring their kids along for the ride.
A thrift shop earns its reputation one find at a time. This one has had years to stack them up.
The Color Tag Code

Blue, pink, yellow, green. At MyThrift, the color of a tag can matter more than the number printed on it.
The store runs a daily color tag deal. Each day, three colors are selected for 25 percent, 50 percent, or 75 percent off.
Regulars treat this as the heart of the strategy. An item that looks pricey at first glance can drop to a much friendlier number if its tag matches the day.
Many shoppers check the posted colors right away before browsing. It saves time and points you toward the deepest savings.
The system also rewards repeat visits. A piece that is full price today could carry a discounted color tomorrow or later in the week.
Clothing is where the tags matter most. Shoppers who skip the racks entirely still recommend looking for the discounted colors if you do shop for apparel.
The color code is simple to learn and fun to play. Crack it once, and every trip turns into a small treasure map.
Holiday Sales That Halve Everything

Patience pays at this store. Beyond the daily color deals, MyThrift runs holiday sales with 50 percent off everything.
That is a big deal for shoppers who have their eye on higher-priced items. Pieces that seem a little steep on an ordinary day come down to a reasonable level during these events.
Resellers and collectors find these sales especially useful. A half-off day across the board can make a slow week of hunting suddenly very productive.
Families stocking up on kids’ clothing, towels, or bedding can also stretch a budget further. The savings apply across categories rather than just a lucky color.
Exact dates are not listed in the store data, so checking the website or asking staff is the smart move before planning around a sale.
Holiday sales tend to draw crowds, so arriving near opening is a reasonable plan. The store opens at 10 a.m. most days.
Half off everything is a phrase thrifters rarely ignore. Mark the calendar and let the store do the math.
Knick-Knacks, Puzzles, and Office Odds

Here is where the real bargains live. The bric-a-brac aisles are the section even critics of the store tend to praise.
Puzzles, pet supplies, knick-knacks, and office goods are described as very cheap or at least reasonable. Shoppers who never touch the clothing racks leave happy from these shelves alone.
Crafters can find raw material for projects here. Odd decorative pieces, containers, and supplies often cost less than starting from scratch at a retail craft store.
Vintage collectors appreciate the rotating mix. Unique and fun items show up regularly, and some are quirky enough to spark a conversation in the checkout line.
Even shoppers frustrated with apparel prices note that the bric-a-brac stayed decent. That consistency makes this section the safest bet for value.
The best approach is slow browsing. Small treasures hide on lower shelves and behind bigger pieces.
Budget hunters, consider this your home base. Start here and work outward from there.
Electronics You Can Test First

Buying used electronics can feel like a coin toss. At MyThrift, shoppers can test tech in the store before paying.
That detail matters. Electronics are the most talked-about category at this location, and the ability to check that something works removes a lot of risk.
Kitchen appliances turn up regularly alongside other gadgets. The selection is often praised as one of the best around.
Prices here run a little higher than other departments. Some fans admit electronics can be pricey at times, though they feel friendly service makes up for it.
The color tags help here too. A tested appliance with a matching discount color can become a genuinely good deal.
Resellers often scan this section closely. Working electronics are among the easier items to flip online.
Plug it in, check it out, and then decide. It is a refreshingly honest way to shop secondhand tech.
Perfume, Purses, and the Jewelry Counter

Designer fragrance for ten dollars is not a typical thrift store line. Yet perfumes such as Versace and Marc Jacobs Daisy have shown up here at that price.
Bath and Body Works scents also appear for a fraction of retail. For gift shoppers, this corner can be a quiet win.
Purses come up often in conversations about the store. The mix shifts constantly, so the selection on one visit may look very different a week later.
A dedicated jewelry counter rounds out the accessory area. Collectors of costume pieces and vintage styles will want to linger here.
Because inventory moves quickly, a promising item is worth grabbing on the spot. Staff have been known to hold an item while a shopper keeps browsing.
Accessories also pair nicely with the color tag system. A discounted purse or brooch can be a strong value.
Small items, big potential. This is the corner that turns a routine trip into a story.
Music Gear and Home Goods Galore

Guitars and keyboards next to bedsheets is a very thrift store combination. MyThrift carries working musical instruments at usually reasonable prices.
Budding musicians and parents of beginners can find a way to start playing without a big retail bill.
Home goods take up a generous share of the floor. Towels, sheets, and blankets are on hand, including weighted blankets that can be costly new.
Shoes are another highlight. Shoppers mention finding pairs that actually fit, which anyone with hard-to-fit feet will appreciate.
Crafters may look at this section differently. Linens and fabrics can become quilts, upholstery, or sewing projects with a little imagination and effort.
The variety is the point. One cart can hold a blanket, a pair of boots, and an instrument without anyone blinking.
Furnishing a home or a hobby gets easier here. The trick is to leave a little room in the trunk.
The Great Clothing Price Debate

Every store has its sore spot, and here it is the clothing rack. The selection is huge, but prices draw strong opinions.
Fans point to a big variety for kids and all genders, plus a strong lineup of t-shirts. Some favorite all-time finds came off these racks.
Critics feel differently. Women’s dresses at $25 or more, recognizable brands near $30, and a J.
Jill sweater at $20 have left some shoppers disappointed.
A few also note that clothing prices seem higher than at Goodwill. Others say MyThrift is cheaper than both Goodwill and Savers overall.
The middle ground is the color tags. Regulars strongly advise sticking to discounted colors when shopping apparel.
Bargains still happen. One shopper scored a cute pair of boots for $3.
Fashion fans, shop with the tag of the day in mind. That simple habit separates a pricey rack from a great haul.
A Reseller’s Hunting Ground

Some shoppers come for themselves. Others come with a business plan.
MyThrift is a favorite with eBay resellers who regularly find items to sell at good prices, and sometimes fantastic ones. One longtime seller even calls the store a partner in business.
The appeal is the steady flow of unique, fun pieces. Combined with the color tag discounts, margins can work out well.
Tuesdays and Thursdays are routine days for at least one dedicated reseller. Weekly visits help catch new stock before it disappears.
Parents also mention reselling some finds to recover what they spend. It turns a family shopping trip into a small side hustle.
The regulars share knowledge too. Experienced hunters swap tips on which items sell, a free education for anyone new to flipping.
For resellers, consistency beats luck. Show up often, and the shelves start paying you back.
Friendly Faces Behind the Register

Names matter at this store. Fish, John, and Renae come up again and again among the staff shoppers appreciate.
Cashiers are often described as very nice, and many regulars are greeted with a smile and a wave. Some families say the team makes a point of chatting with their kids.
John once held an item for a shopper so nobody else would grab it. His humor and personality made that trip memorable.
In another case, staff checked on a shopper who felt unwell and brought a large bottle of water. Moments like that build loyalty.
Not every experience is so warm. Some shoppers, especially younger ones, feel watched closely or have items checked at the register due to concerns about tag switching.
A few have had uncomfortable run-ins over pricing disputes. Keeping receipts and tags intact helps avoid confusion.
Overall, the staff leaves a strong impression on many. For a lot of regulars, the people are the reason they return.
The Social Side of the Hunt

Thrifting is often solo work. At MyThrift, it can turn into a social outing.
Regulars strike up friendly and educational conversations in the aisles. Shoppers compliment each other’s finds instead of feeling competitive.
That atmosphere suits a wide range of people. Vintage collectors, crafters, resellers, and families all share the same floor.
Some say the store feels like a place of belonging. One shopper loved it so much they stayed from open to close.
The sheer amount to look at keeps people browsing. There is always another shelf to check.
Newcomers can learn a lot by listening. Seasoned hunters often explain what an unusual item is or why it holds value.
Plenty of stores sell secondhand goods. Fewer manage to build a crowd that cheers for each other.
Hours, Parking, and Practical Tips

Timing a trip is easy. The store is open Monday through Saturday from 10 a.m. to 8 p.m., and Sunday from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Those long weekday hours make evening hunts possible after work. Sunday is the shortest day, so plan accordingly.
Parking is plentiful. The huge lot is shared with the Thai market, the laundry place, and the pizza place in the same strip.
Traditional carts are gone. The store now uses red rolling baskets you pull or push, which some shoppers find less convenient.
Check the daily colors first. It shapes the whole trip and keeps your budget in check.
Leave tags attached and keep your receipt handy. With staff watchful for tag switching, clean paperwork makes checkout smoother.
Bring patience and a plan. A little preparation goes a long way on a big floor.
Is the Trip Worth It

A 3.8-star average across nearly 900 opinions tells a mixed but busy story. This is a store people care about, for better or worse.
The strongest case is for bric-a-brac lovers, collectors, crafters, and resellers. Puzzles, home goods, accessories, and testable electronics deliver steady value.
Clothing shoppers should approach with a strategy. Stick to the color tags, and watch for 50 percent off holiday sales.
Families will likely enjoy the kids’ selection and the friendly greetings. Many regulars bring children along every week.
Those sensitive to close staff attention may want to know that ahead of time. Being prepared makes for a calmer visit.
For many St. Paul shoppers, the balance tips firmly positive. They keep coming back for the selection, the deals, and the people.
The unassuming storefront on Rice Street keeps its promise in its own way. Go in curious, shop the colors, and see what turns up.
Share this story
