Prime Time Restaurant in Hickory Hills looks ready for a casual night of sports, drinks, and wings—until the serious cuts of meat start arriving. Behind its laid-back 95th Street exterior, the kitchen serves prime rib, thick steaks, lamb chops, and other hearty plates that feel more chophouse than neighborhood sports bar.
TVs and a patio keep the atmosphere relaxed, while the substantial menu gives diners plenty of reasons to arrive with a serious appetite. It is exactly the kind of contrast that makes an unassuming restaurant memorable. Come expecting an easygoing meal, and that prime rib might completely steal the show.
A Sports Bar Hiding a Chophouse Menu
Picture a strip of 95th Street in Hickory Hills, lined with shops, traffic lights, and cars heading home from work. Prime Time Restaurant sits right in that everyday scene. From the road, it reads as a neighborhood sports bar, the kind of spot where you expect a basket of fries and a game on the screen.
Step inside and the menu tells a bigger story. Alongside burgers and wings, you will find prime rib, New York strip steak, lamb chops, and thick pork chops. The place calls itself an upscale sports bar with chophouse food, and that mix is the whole surprise.
Why does that combo work? A classic steakhouse can feel stiff, with hushed rooms and dress codes. Here, a family can split a steak dinner while the kids watch the Bears or the Sox on one of the big screens.
Nobody needs a jacket, and nobody will look twice if you show up in a team jersey. The building itself is clean and roomy, with a long bar, plenty of booths, and a patio for warmer months.
Booths near the middle of the room tend to offer the best view of the TVs. Ask the host if you want a spot facing a particular game.
A dining room this flexible serves lots of different crowds in one night. You might see a couple on a date, a table of coworkers after a shift, and a group of grandparents celebrating a birthday, all within a few feet of each other.
That easy blend of casual and serious is rare in the south suburbs. So the first lesson is simple. Judge Prime Time by its kitchen, not by its sports bar sign out front.
The Prime Rib Worth Planning a Drive Around
Order the prime rib, and the table usually goes quiet for a minute. A thick, rosy slice arrives with its edges browned and its center tender enough to cut without much effort. It is the dish that turns a casual night out into a small event.
Prime rib comes from the rib section of the cow, the same area that gives you ribeye steaks. Slow roasting is key, because it lets the fat melt into the meat and keeps each bite juicy. Fun fact: the word “prime” in prime rib often just refers to the cut, not always to a beef grade.
At Prime Time, the portions lean generous, which fits the kitchen’s reputation for big plates. Come hungry, or plan on a take-home box. Leftover prime rib makes an excellent sandwich the next day.
Here are a few smart ordering tips. Ask for medium rare if you want the classic pink center with the most flavor and tenderness. If you prefer less pink, medium is a safe middle ground, while well done can dry out a cut like this.
Sides matter too. A baked potato or a plate of Greek fries soaks up the juices nicely, and a simple salad cuts through the richness. Warm bread comes to the table first, so pace yourself before the main event lands.
Timing can help as well. Popular cuts can sell out on busy nights, especially weekends, since prime rib is roasted in batches instead of cooked one at a time.
Arriving for an earlier dinner gives you the best shot at getting a slice before the kitchen runs low. If steak is your weakness, the New York strip is a strong backup, with a firmer bite and a bold, beefy taste.
Flaming Saganaki and the Greek Side of the Menu
Opa! That shout, followed by a burst of flame at your table, is how saganaki makes its entrance. The cheese is fried until golden, splashed with liquor, lit on fire, and then put out with a squeeze of lemon. It is part appetizer and part show.
The Greek touch runs deep at Prime Time. The menu includes Greek chicken, Greek style wings, Greek fries, and thick Greek style pork chops, usually seasoned with lemon, garlic, and oregano. These dishes connect the restaurant to a long Chicago tradition of Greek-run family restaurants.
Saganaki actually takes its name from the small two-handled pan it is cooked in. The flaming version is widely believed to have become famous in Chicago’s Greektown, not in Greece. So ordering it here is a very local move.
The Greek wings deserve their own spotlight. Instead of a sticky buffalo sauce, they get a bright, herby coating that feels lighter and lets the crisp skin shine. Pair them with Greek fries, dusted with seasoning and cheese, and you have a snack plate that beats standard bar food.
Planning a first visit? Try building your meal around this side of the kitchen. Start with saganaki for the whole table, share an order of Greek wings, and then move on to your steak or chops.
For a lighter plate, the Greek chicken is a good choice, with fair pricing and a hearty portion. It comes out juicy and flavorful without being heavy.
Kids especially love the flaming cheese moment, so let them sit where they can see the server light it. Just keep little hands back. The flames jump high for a second before the lemon settles them down.
Appetizers That Refuse to Play Second Fiddle
Frozen potato skins from a bag? Not here. The potato skins at Prime Time are made in-house, loaded with melted cheddar and crispy bacon, and they arrive with real crunch on the edges.
Appetizers at a steak-focused spot can feel like an afterthought. At this restaurant, they hold their own. The calamari shows up lightly fried and tender, with none of the rubbery chew that ruins cheaper versions.
Chicken tenders also get plenty of love, with a crisp coating and a juicy inside. Mozzarella sticks, mini burgers, and onion rings round out the classic bar lineup. For something with a little kick, the Mexican tequila shrimp adds a spicy twist.
Groups should look at the Prime Time platter. It bundles ribs, wings, onion rings, mozzarella sticks, and potato skins onto one big shareable spread. It is a smart way to sample several favorites without ordering five separate plates.
One practical tip about leftovers: the cheese on potato skins can dry out if it sits overnight. When taking a platter home, ask for the cheese on the side and melt it fresh in the oven the next day. Your reheated skins will taste much closer to the original.
Soups also come with many meals, and the seafood chowder is a hearty option with a peppery bite. If you are sensitive to spice, give it a small taste first. Salads and soups make a good balance before a heavy steak.
Here is a simple strategy for a group of four. Order one platter and one plate of calamari, then pick your mains. You will leave room for dinner while still getting a tour of the kitchen’s best starters.
Game Night on 95th Street, Illinois Style
Big screens glow from nearly every wall. When a Chicago team scores, the whole room reacts at once, and the bar turns into a cheering section. That is the everyday rhythm of Prime Time on a game night.
The number of high quality TVs makes it easy to follow more than one game at a time. A football fan and a baseball fan can sit at the same table and both stay happy. For big matchups, arrive early, because the best booths and bar stools fill quickly.
Tall draft beers are a signature here, poured cold into glasses that stand well above the usual pint. A Miller Lite on special is a common sight at the bar. There is also a full lineup of cocktails and other drinks for anyone skipping beer.
Happy hour adds another reason to show up. Deals have included 50 percent off select appetizers, which makes mozzarella sticks, sliders, and chicken bites an easy call. Check with your server about current specials, since offers can change.
The patio gives the room a second personality in warm weather. Outdoor seating works well for groups that want to talk without shouting over the crowd. Inside, weekend nights can get loud, with music turned up and plenty of energy.
That energy is great for fans, but it may not suit a quiet dinner. If you want calm, aim for an afternoon lunch or a weekday meal. If you want noise and team spirit, come on a Friday or Saturday night.
Friendly managers will often help find a booth with a clear view of your game. Just ask when you arrive, and mention which team you are rooting for.
Late Hours, Party Rooms, and Busy Parking Lots
Hungry at midnight on a Tuesday? The kitchen here is used to that. Prime Time opens at 11 AM most days and stays open late, which is a big deal in a suburb where many places close early.
Here is the weekly schedule. Monday runs from 11 AM to midnight. Tuesday through Thursday go until 1 AM, and Friday and Saturday stretch to 1:30 AM. Sunday is shorter, from noon to 11 PM.
Those late hours make it a good choice after a concert, a long work shift, or a youth sports tournament nearby. Instead of settling for fast food, you can sit down to a real meal with a server. That option is harder to find than it should be.
Planning a celebration? The restaurant has a party room for birthdays, showers, team dinners, and family gatherings. The staff has a record of handling groups smoothly, even when plans come together at the last minute. Still, call ahead for larger parties so the kitchen can prepare.
Parking deserves a quick heads up. On busy nights, the lot can get very full, though more parking has been added over time. Give yourself a few extra minutes to find a spot, especially on weekends.
Families will find booths, a kids-friendly menu feel, and dessert options like ice cream. The large menu means picky eaters usually find something they like. Pizza, pasta, sandwiches, and salads sit right next to the steaks.
A final practical note involves takeout. Some extras, like pizza boxes on busy nights, may carry a small charge. Ask about it before ordering to avoid any surprise on the bill, and review your receipt before you head out.
Why Regulars Keep Their Booth Warm
Fifteen years is a long time to keep eating at the same place. Some families in the area have been visiting Prime Time for that long, and a few show up every single Sunday. Loyalty like that in a crowded suburb says a lot.
Consistency is a big reason. The steaks, wings, and chops tend to taste the same visit after visit, which matters when you are bringing picky relatives or out-of-town guests. You know roughly what you will get.
Staff play a large role too. Servers get called out by name, managers stop by tables, and owners are often on site keeping watch. That personal touch turns a chain-style experience into something closer to a neighborhood hangout.
No restaurant is perfect, and honesty helps you plan. Service can slow down when the room is packed, and some dishes outside the steak and Greek specialties hit less consistently. Stick with the kitchen’s strengths, like prime rib, saganaki, Greek wings, and potato skins, for the best odds.
If anything goes wrong, speak up right away. Point out the problem to your server or a manager while you are still seated. It is easier to fix a dish at the table than after you leave.
Value is another draw. Big portions and regular specials mean you often get more food than the price suggests. Many plates come with bread and soup, so a single entree can feel like a full dinner.
So what earns Prime Time its reputation? A sports bar that roasts a serious prime rib, lights cheese on fire, and stays open past midnight. On 95th Street in Hickory Hills, that combination is tough to beat.
Share this story
