This Cult-Favorite New York Pizza Chain Is Coming To Nashville In Early 2026

Nashville, get ready for a crispy, cheesy arrival. Prince Street Pizza is bringing its cult favorite square slices and classic pies to Fifth + Broadway in early 2026. You have probably seen those pepperoni cups glistening online, and soon you can grab them right in the heart of downtown.

Here is everything you need to know before the first slice hits your plate.

1. The Big Announcement: Fifth + Broadway Launch

Prince Street Pizza is officially landing at Fifth + Broadway in early 2026, and the hype is real. This location puts you steps from the Ryman, Bridgestone Arena, and Broadway’s honky tonks, which means a pre show square slice becomes your new tradition. Picture grabbing a hot box and wandering to the pedestrian plaza with that unmistakable pepperoni cup aroma.

The space will balance fast counter service with quick seating, perfect for lunch breaks and late night cravings. Expect a sleek look with New York grit, bold red accents, and plenty of square pie photos. If you love convenience, this corner is the sweet spot.

You will be able to slide in, order, and head out without missing a beat.

2. Why Nashville Is the Perfect Fit

Nashville loves a good food story, and Prince Street Pizza brings a strong one. Music City thrives on late nights, live shows, and quick, memorable bites, which matches square slice culture perfectly. After a concert or Preds game, you will want those crispy edges and charred pepperoni cups with a cold drink.

Tourists chase bucket list eats, and locals demand quality and consistency. Prince Street’s cult status gives visitors a must try destination while giving residents dependable weeknight takeout. The brand’s bold flavors fit right alongside hot chicken and barbecue, but it fills a pizza gap downtown.

You get New York confidence with Southern accessibility. That cross current is why this shop will feel like it has always belonged on Broadway.

3. Signature Sicilian Spicy Pepperoni Squares

This is the slice that made believers out of skeptics. Thick yet airy dough, a caramelized cheese edge, and cup and char pepperoni that pools spicy oil like liquid gold. One bite and you get crunch, chew, and a hit of heat that lingers without overpowering.

If you are a fold your slice person, you will switch teams for this square. It is designed to be devoured as a corner or center piece depending on your mood. Ask for extra crisp if you love a deep crunch.

Pair it with a classic soda or a local beer nearby. Honestly, this is the reason lines form. Bring friends, order a full tray, and conquer a corner each.

4. Neapolitan Pies for Classic Purists

If thinner crust is your love language, the Neapolitan pies will speak fluently. Expect leopard spotting on the cornicione, bright tomato sauce, and creamy mozzarella that melts into picture perfect pools. The balance leans clean and satisfying, never greasy, with a chew that keeps each bite interesting.

Order a margherita to taste the fundamentals, then branch into pepperoni or veggie with fresh basil and olive oil. You will appreciate how the crust supports toppings without sagging. It is shareable, light enough for lunch, and totally date night approved.

Ask for red pepper flakes or a drizzle of hot honey to dial up contrast. Nashville, your thin crust cravings are about to be handled with serious finesse.

5. What To Expect On Opening Week

Opening week will be a sprint, so plan your visit. Lines will likely start before lunch and swell again pre show evenings. The team usually moves fast, but popular trays sell out at peak times, so earlier is safer if you are set on a specific pie.

Watch socials for soft opening hours, giveaways, and maybe a limited slice collaboration. Expect a tight menu focused on greatest hits, plus beverages that keep the rush flowing. You will probably see local musicians and visiting fans in the same line.

Patience helps, and the payoff is delicious. Grab napkins, snag a plaza seat, and enjoy your first Nashville bite of those legendary squares.

6. Menu Highlights Beyond the Squares

Yes, the spicy squares headline, but do not sleep on the rest. Garlic knots with a glossy butter sheen, simple salads that cut through richness, and rotating specialty pies keep things fresh. A drizzle of hot honey over pepperoni adds sweet heat that works wonders.

You will likely find classic cheese, vodka sauce variations, and a white pie that is creamy without being heavy. Sauces matter here, so grab an extra marinara or ranch for dipping crusts. If you are sharing, mix a tray of squares with a Neapolitan for contrast.

It becomes a choose your adventure meal that satisfies everyone in the group.

7. Price Point, Portions, and Value

Downtown prices can sting, but Prince Street’s value rests in portion size and crave factor. A single square slice eats like a meal, especially with pepperoni cups and that caramelized edge. Split a tray with friends and you will see the math work in your favor.

Neapolitan pies land in the shareable zone too, perfect for two with a side. You get quality ingredients and careful bakes, which justifies a couple extra dollars on Broadway. If you need a budget move, grab one slice now and another later.

Either way, you leave full and happy, and that is the goal. The best value is the one you cannot stop thinking about tomorrow.

8. How to Make the Most of Your Visit

Beat the rush by arriving right at open for lunch or between post work and pre show waves. Order online if available, then pick up and head to the plaza for people watching. Ask for well done if you love extra crisp corners, and do not forget chili flakes or hot honey.

Bringing a crew Before you arrive, tally what everyone wants and order a mixed tray plus a Neapolitan. That keeps the group fed without overthinking. Wear comfortable shoes because lines move, but you will stand a bit.

Snap your slice for the memory, then eat it while it is hot. That first crunchy bite is the moment you came for.