Creative plans have a way of multiplying inside Palette & Paper in Indianapolis. Housed in a charming 1920s home, this specialty craft shop fills room after room with stamps, inks, dies, stickers, paper, ephemera, and other supplies that can spark an entirely new project before the first one is finished.
Card makers, scrapbookers, and junk journal fans can browse materials in person rather than guessing from an online photo, while the homey setting makes the hunt feel especially inviting. Every room seems to hold another possibility. For Indiana crafters, this cozy shop makes leaving empty-handed a serious challenge.
A 1920s House Where Every Room Holds Supplies
Picture a porch, a front door, and a century-old home that hides a whole craft store inside. Palette & Paper sits in a 1920s house on Oaklandon Road, on the northeast side of Indianapolis. Instead of one wide sales floor, the shop spreads out across room after room.
That layout changes how shopping works. You do not push a cart down long aisles under bright ceiling lights. You wander from one space to the next, turning corners and peeking into doorways to see what waits inside.
Each room has its own personality. One might be heavy on stamps and inks, while another leans toward patterned paper or tiny decorative pieces. The old house frame, with its original charm and warm details, gives the shelves a cozy backdrop that a strip mall could never copy.
The owners have kept the home feeling lived in and inviting. Antique items appear here and there, blending into the displays so that supplies and history sit side by side. Some of those pieces come with stories about the house, and asking about them is a fun way to learn more.
Space is snug, though, so plan to move slowly. Shelves reach into nearly every nook, and walkways can be tight when a few shoppers are browsing at once. Anyone carrying a big bag or coat may want to leave it in the car.
Kids tend to love the explore-the-house feeling, since every doorway seems to open onto a new surprise. Families can split up, cover different rooms, and then meet back up to compare finds.
Take a moment on the way out to glance back at the house from the street. From the outside, it looks like a regular older home. Few passersby would guess it holds thousands of crafting goodies packed wall to wall.
Tim Holtz Fans, Your Shelf Has Arrived
Big chain stores rarely carry the newest Tim Holtz releases, and serious crafters know the frustration. At Palette & Paper, that hunt ends in a single stop. The shop is known for stocking hard to find Tim Holtz items, including the newer oxide inks that seldom show up at larger retailers.
For anyone new to the name, Tim Holtz is a designer whose tools and supplies are loved by mixed media artists. His products include ink pads, stencils, dies, embossing folders, and vintage-style ephemera. They help crafters create layered, weathered, old-fashioned looks on cards, tags, and journals.
Finding a full range of his line in person is a treat. Online photos cannot always show the true color of an ink or the texture of a stencil. Here, you can see colors side by side and compare sizes before deciding what fits your project.
That hands-on shopping is especially useful for building a collection. Oxide inks come in many shades, and picking a set that blends well is much easier when the pads are right in front of you. Grouping warm tones or cool tones together takes seconds instead of guesswork.
Beyond Tim Holtz, the shelves mix newer, unusual products with the basic items every paper crafter keeps running out of. Adhesives, cardstock, and everyday tools sit near the trendier pieces. That means one trip can cover both the exciting new release and the boring refill you forgot you needed.
A smart tip is to bring a list of what you already own. With so many tempting options, it is easy to accidentally buy a color already sitting on your desk at home. Snap a quick photo of your ink collection before you leave the house, and your wallet will thank you.
Tiny Treasures Tucked Into Every Nook
Stickers in one basket, vintage-style ephemera in another, and stacks of decorative paper leaning against the wall. The small stuff is where Palette & Paper really shows off. Crafters who love details will find plenty to sort through.
Ephemera, if the word is new to you, means paper bits that look old or collectible. Think ticket stubs, tags, labels, and printed scraps. Junk journal makers use them to add a story-filled, layered look to their pages.
Dies and embossing folders are another big draw. Dies are metal shapes that cut paper into designs using a machine, while embossing folders press raised patterns into cardstock. Both turn plain paper into something that looks professionally made.
Card makers can build a full project from what is on hand here. Pick a patterned paper, cut a shape with a die, add texture with a folder, and finish with a sticker or two. Ink ties the colors together.
Because the items are spread across different rooms, it helps to take a full lap first. Glance at everything before grabbing anything. Many shoppers end up finding a perfect match for a project two rooms away from where they started.
Budget is worth thinking about too. Small items feel cheap one at a time, but a handful of sticker sheets and paper pads adds up fast. Setting a spending limit before walking in keeps the fun from turning into sticker shock.
Even crafters with overflowing supply closets tend to leave with a bag of new goodies. Unusual products you have never seen online pop up on the shelves, and holding them in your hand makes them hard to resist. Look low and high, since some of the best finds hide on bottom shelves.
Meet Mare and Bill, the Indiana Couple Behind the Counter
Mare and Bill turned their house into a shop, and their names come up again and again among loyal crafters. Running a store out of a historic home takes a special kind of dedication. This Indiana couple has made it look easy for years.
Their approach is personal. Instead of a quick scan at the register, shoppers get real conversation, product advice, and sometimes a little history lesson. Bill has been known to invite curious visitors into the back workroom to show how it is set up.
Why does that matter? Crafting can be confusing, especially for beginners. Knowing which ink works on glossy paper or which die fits which machine can save money and frustration, and friendly owners make those questions feel welcome.
That warmth has built something bigger than a store. Regulars chat in the checkout line, share tips, and cheer on each other’s projects. A small creative community has grown around the house, which is rare in an age of online ordering.
The couple also shares stories about the antique items scattered through the rooms. Those pieces add character and give the shop a sense of place. They connect the old home to the people who fill it with color today.
Families visiting with children will find patient hosts who do not mind a few extra questions. Kids can ask what a stamp does or how embossing works. Some young shoppers leave with a new hobby in addition to a new sticker sheet.
If you have a tricky project in mind, bring a sample or a photo. Describing a card or journal page out loud is harder than showing it. With a picture in hand, the owners can point you straight toward the right supplies.
Classes in the Garage Workshop
Out back, the garage has a second life. Mare turned it into a workshop where she hosts events and classes. It gives crafters a place to create together instead of just shopping.
Classes add a whole new layer to a visit. Watching someone demonstrate a technique is often faster than learning from a video. You can ask questions in real time, try the steps yourself, and get feedback on the spot.
Over the years, the shop has welcomed well known artists to teach. For hobbyists, learning from a recognized name is a big deal. These sessions let local crafters pick up pro-level tricks without traveling across the country.
Workshops usually focus on paper crafting skills like stamping, card making, and mixed media. A beginner might learn how to blend ink smoothly. Someone more advanced could tackle layered backgrounds or detailed die cutting.
There is a social side too. Sitting at a table with other crafters sparks ideas, friendly chatter, and new friendships. Many people enjoy the shared excitement of finishing a project at the same time as everyone else.
Here is a practical bonus. After class, the supplies you just used are only steps away inside the house. If a certain stencil or ink worked beautifully, you can grab it before heading home and keep practicing that same week.
Class schedules change, so check the shop’s current listings before planning around an event. Popular sessions can fill up, especially when a guest artist is teaching. Signing up early is the safest bet.
Bring a small bag or box for carrying your finished piece. Wet ink and delicate layers do not travel well tossed on a car seat. A flat folder keeps your new creation safe for the ride home.
Timing Your Trip to Oaklandon Road
Hours matter here more than at most stores. Palette & Paper is a small, owner-run shop, so it does not keep the long, every-day schedule of a chain. Always check the current hours before driving over.
At times, the owners have offered appointment-only shopping during the week. That option is a great fit for anyone who wants the rooms nearly to themselves. It also helps shoppers with mobility needs, since the walkways in the old house are narrow.
Think about it this way. A walker, stroller, or wheelchair can be tough to steer through packed rooms on a busy afternoon. With a private time slot, there is space to move slowly and look at everything without feeling rushed.
Weekend visits bring a livelier crowd. The shop has joined community events such as a Sunday Shop Hop, when crafters travel between stores to discover new favorites. Those days are fun and social, but expect more people squeezed into the rooms.
The location is handy for anyone on the northeast side of Indianapolis, near Lawrence and the Geist area. The road is easy to reach from nearby neighborhoods. Out-of-town crafters can pair a visit with other stops around the city.
Give yourself plenty of time. Rushing through a house full of rooms means missing the good stuff tucked on lower shelves and in corners. An hour is a comfortable minimum for a first visit, and serious crafters may want longer.
Following the shop on social media is a simple way to stay updated. New arrivals, class announcements, and schedule changes often show up there first.
A quick look before leaving home can save a wasted trip. Eat a snack before arriving, too. Browsing burns more time than expected.
Why Local Crafters Choose It Over Big Box Stores
Three giant chains dominate American craft shopping, yet many serious paper crafters drive past them to reach a house on Oaklandon Road. The reason comes down to selection, service, and setting. Palette & Paper delivers all three in a way large stores struggle to match.
Start with inventory. Big retailers often carry only a slice of specialty lines and may skip newer releases completely. This shop fills that gap with hard to find products alongside everyday basics.
Then there is expertise. At a huge store, finding someone who knows the difference between dye ink and pigment ink can be tricky. Here, the people behind the counter live and breathe paper crafting, and they are happy to explain.
The setting seals the deal. A historic home with themed rooms turns a supply run into a small adventure. Parents bringing kids, friends on a craft day out, and solo shoppers hunting a specific stamp all find something to enjoy.
Supporting a local business also keeps creative options alive in the community. Independent shops host classes, run events, and connect hobbyists who might never meet otherwise. Every purchase helps that network keep going.
The shop has held a perfect five-star rating across its Google reviews, which says a lot about consistency. Pleasing crafters year after year is no small feat. Picky hobbyists know exactly what they want.
Even longtime online shoppers find reasons to come in person. Touching paper, testing colors, and discovering products you did not know existed simply works better face to face. A screen cannot replace that.
So pack a tote, check the hours, and head to northeast Indianapolis. Scrapbookers, stampers, junk journalers, and mixed media artists will all find a room calling their name.
Share this story
