Grilled cheese is a childhood favorite, but one truck in Pataskala, Ohio, has turned it into something wild. Grilled Cheese Gangsters piles pulled pork, buffalo chicken, and more between thick slices of crispy toast.
Fans say they cannot stop thinking about the food days later. Here are ten things that keep people lining up at this rolling kitchen.
1. The Kingpin Sandwich

Ask five fans what to order, and at least two will shout, “The Kingpin!” One guest called it heavenly, and another said it was the best grilled cheese she had ever tasted. It sits at the top of the menu for good reason.
The bread comes out buttery and crisp, while the pork inside is tender and full of flavor. Each bite has crunch first, then a soft, cheesy center that holds everything together.
One bride-to-be even said she might hire the truck for her wedding after trying it. That is a big compliment for a sandwich.
If you only get one item on your first visit, this is a smart pick. Pair it with a friend and share something extra on the side, because the sandwich is filling enough to be the star of the whole meal.
2. Gangster Tots

Golden, crunchy, and not one bit greasy, these tots have fans acting like they discovered buried treasure. One visitor said the truck has frying tots down to a science.
Another admitted she does not even like tater tots, yet she loved these.
They come topped with green onions and a tangy sauce that ties everything together. The crunch holds up even under all the toppings, which is tough to pull off.
Here is a tip from the reviews: the portion is huge. Some customers say the box is big enough for two people, so think about splitting one.
If you love the sauce, ask for a little extra, since a few guests wished for more. It is the side dish that often steals the show from the sandwich itself.
3. Mafia Sauce

Some sauces are just a topping. This one has its own fan club.
Several reviewers called it the best sauce they have ever had, and one said it was to die for.
It adds a tangy, creamy kick to the tots, and it works well with the sandwiches too. People mention it again and again, which tells you something about how memorable it is.
The only real complaint is that there never seems to be enough. One guest said she simply wanted more, and she was not shy about it.
If you feel the same way, it never hurts to ask the crew about an extra cup. Dipping crusty toast corners into leftover sauce might be the best way to finish a meal.
Bring napkins, because this is happily messy food.
4. Pulled Pork Tots

Picture a pile of crunchy tots wearing a blanket of smoky pulled pork. That is exactly what you get, and customers are thrilled about it.
One happy guest said, “You order pulled pork tots and you get exactly what you ordered!”
The pork is juicy and packed with flavor. It is a five ounce portion, according to the owners, so it is a real serving and not just a sprinkle.
Some fans take it further by adding mac and cheese on top. That turns a snack into a full comfort food feast.
Another customer pairs the tots with a Don Vito sandwich and wishes she could eat the combo every day. Come hungry, because this dish is hearty and satisfying from the first bite to the last crispy crumb at the bottom of the container.
5. The Don Vito

Named after a famous movie boss, the Don Vito has a loyal following. A fan who has visited many events says the Don Vito with pulled pork tots makes him mad that he cannot eat it daily.
That is some serious love.
The sandwich features an egg along with the melty cheese, making it a bit different from a plain grilled cheese. It feels like breakfast and lunch had a delicious meeting.
Like any busy truck, results can vary. One festival visitor reported burned bread and an overcooked egg on a crowded day.
If your sandwich is not how you like it, speak up politely and the crew may be able to help. Most guests, though, walk away happy and plan their next visit right away.
6. The Tony Soprano

“Every time I see their truck, I eat.” That is how one regular describes her habit, and the Tony Soprano is her favorite order. It gets mentioned in reviews often enough to count as a crowd favorite.
Like the rest of the menu, it takes its name from famous crime stories. The playful names make ordering fun, especially when you are with a group trying to pick.
Expect thick, buttery toast and a gooey center that pulls apart in long, cheesy strings. Friendly service makes it better, since the crew is glad to explain what is in each sandwich.
If you are stuck choosing, tell them what flavors you like and let them guide you. Most customers say the staff gives great recommendations, so trust the experts behind the window.
7. Buffalo Chicken and Godfather Flavors

Love a little heat? The buffalo options bring tangy zing to a classic comfort meal.
One guest said she had two amazing sandwiches, the buffalo chicken and the Sicilian, and loved the bread most of all.
Another tried the Godfather and added green onions. She said it had a nice buffalo flavor while still tasting like true grilled cheese, toasted just right.
That is the trick here: bold flavors without losing the cozy cheesy base. Green onions add a fresh crunch that cuts through the richness.
If spicy food is your thing, try adding them too. Buffalo chicken tots are also a popular mention, so you can carry the flavor theme all the way through your meal if you like.
8. The Pacino and Al Capone

Two sandwiches, two personalities. The Pacino earned a bold review from one fan, who called it the best grilled cheese sandwich she has ever had.
That is a big claim, and it came with a 10 out of 10.
The Al Capone brings pulled pork to the party. A first-time customer found it tasty, though he noted the base was simple American cheese on white bread.
He also felt the price of eleven dollars was a bit high.
Prices do run higher than a homemade sandwich, but you are paying for loaded fillings and food made fresh to order. Think of it as a festival treat.
If you are curious, order one of each with a friend and trade halves. Comparing them is half the fun.
9. Friendly Crew and Fast Service

Great food is nice, but kind people make people return. Reviewers keep naming the crew, from Caleb, who helped a first-timer choose, to Jared, who got praise for being fantastic.
Another fan cheers for the boss lady, Ashleigh, for her hard work.
Guests say food comes out hot and fresh, and some say the truck feels like a family. One customer even said she will follow them everywhere.
Busy days can mean waits, and one guest reported about twenty minutes for a sandwich. That is normal for made-to-order food at a crowded event.
Use the time to chat with the crew or scout a good seat. Not every visit is perfect, and a few recent reviews were unhappy.
Still, the overall rating of 4.5 stars shows most visitors leave smiling.
10. Where to Find the Truck

The home base is 2508 Hazelton-Etna Rd SW in Pataskala, Ohio. Google lists hours of 11 AM to 11 PM every day of the week, though a food truck can change plans, so call ahead at 614-353-4853 to be safe.
The truck also pops up at events around central Ohio. Fans have spotted it at Forth Friday in Westerville, the Westerville Pumpkin Show, and food truck festivals.
One guest said it was their go-to truck at any event.
Check the website at grilledcheesegangsters.com for updates. Show up a little early, since lines can grow quickly at festivals.
Bring cash or a card, a friend to share tots, and plenty of napkins. With a 4.5 star rating from 181 reviews, the truck has clearly won over a lot of hungry Ohioans.
Share this story
