Somewhere in Pueblo, a man in his 90s still runs the register at a family shop that threw itself a 100th birthday party not long ago. In the back room, cookies are still made by hand, and kind staff have been known to invite curious guests in to watch. The shelves hold imported Italian goods, house-made spices and sausage made the old way, with a Pueblo twist.
This story covers where the shop is, how it has lasted a century, what to bring home, and the one timing detail that can make or break the drive.
1. A Century-Old Doorway on Elm Street
Some Colorado businesses chase trends, and some simply outlast them. The shop at the center of this story belongs firmly in the second group.
Gagliano’s Italian Market sits at 1220 Elm St, Pueblo, CO 81004, in southern Colorado. It is a compact neighborhood market with a deli counter in the back and shelves of Italian goods up front.
For Front Range residents, the location is part of the appeal. Pueblo is an easy drive south on I-25, and the market feels worlds away from the crowded chain stores of Denver and Colorado Springs.
Families have made the trip from Cañon City, from Denver and even from Santa Fe during road trips. Some regulars drive in mainly to stock up on imported meats for the Italian cooks in their own homes.
The building itself is small and unfussy. Nothing about the outside shouts for attention, which suits a place that has relied on word of mouth for generations.
Inside, the focus is on food, family and old habits that never went out of style. There is no seating, so this is a stop for shopping and ordering to go.
Keep the address handy, because the real story starts once the door swings open.
2. Roots That Reach Back 100 Years
A hundred years is a long time for any small business to keep its lights on. Gagliano’s crossed that line and marked it with a celebration on June 26 of its centennial year.
That party drew a crowd of loyal locals who had been waiting to cheer the milestone. For a family market, reaching triple digits is a rare feat in any state.
Pueblo has deep Italian immigrant roots, and this shop is one of the clearest living links to that heritage. It continues to stock the kinds of goods families once relied on to cook the dishes of the old country.
Many shoppers describe the experience as a trip back in time. The phrase “blast from the past” comes up often, and it fits a store that has kept its traditions intact.
Shoppers who grew up around Italian groceries in New York and the Northeast say the market holds its own with the places they remember. Others compare it to famous old delis in New Orleans.
That kind of praise is earned slowly. A century of steady work, one customer at a time, built the reputation that keeps people driving across the state.
And the people behind the counter are a big part of why the story keeps going.
3. The Family Behind the Register
Most retirees spend their 90s far from a cash register. Tony is not most retirees.
He is still in the shop, still running the register and still greeting people as they come through the door. Many first-timers mention an older gentleman welcoming them in before they even reach the back.
The rest of the family keeps the same spirit alive. One road-tripping group with small children was allowed to use the restroom, and the mom of the family handed cookies to the youngest and shared artichokes with everyone.
That warmth shows up in small, practical ways too. A young staff member once ran to the register to warn a shopper about a big accident on her route home and explained how to avoid the traffic.
Friendly staff is one of the most common themes tied to this market. It is the kind of service that feels like a neighbor looking out for you.
Owners also respond to online notes with simple hearts and a cheerful “Grazie,” which says plenty about their style. They let the work speak.
So the family sets the tone, but the back room is where some of the most charming moments happen.
4. Cookies Made by Hand in the Back
Here is the part that gives this market its bakery soul. Behind the deli counter, cookies are still made by hand.
Shoppers have caught Nonna working on batches in the back while they ordered. It is not a staged show, just the daily routine of a family that bakes the way it always has.
One mother and daughter stopping in for a park picnic got an unexpected bonus. The staff invited them into the back to watch the cookies being made and then let them try one fresh.
Moments like that are hard to find at big-box stores. They turn a quick errand into a memory worth telling at the next family dinner.
Cookies come up again and again as a favorite pick, and Lady Fingers are often named as a must-try. Some varieties can sell out, so earlier visits may offer more choice.
Bringing a box home is an easy way to share a slice of Pueblo history. It also makes a thoughtful hostess gift that costs far less than a fancy bakery order.
Of course, the baked goods are only one corner of a store packed wall to wall.
5. Shelves Stacked With Old-World Finds
Plan on getting a little lost in the aisles. The front of the shop holds a lot of food and kitchen extras, packed into a modest space.
Imported Italian ingredients line the shelves, including polenta, oils, candies and jarred sauces. Many shoppers say they find items here that they cannot track down anywhere else in Colorado.
The market also sells its own homemade spices. Those make a smart pick for home cooks who want an authentic touch without a pricey specialty order.
Gluten-free shoppers get pleasant surprises too. The store has carried gluten-free flour, pasta, sweets, bread and even frozen ravioli.
The refrigerated cases add imported deli meats and cheeses. Some customers drive to Pueblo specifically to pick up imported cuts for family members who grew up on Italian cooking.
Ready-made pasta dishes and stuffed shells round out the take-home options. They are handy for busy households that want a homemade-style dinner without a full afternoon in the kitchen.
It is easy to spend more time browsing than planned. A basket is helpful, and so is a list, though most people abandon the list within minutes.
Still, one homemade specialty deserves a section all its own.
6. House Sausage With a Pueblo Accent
Italian sausage is the single most talked-about item at Gagliano’s, and it is made right in the shop. That alone puts it in a different league from mass-produced packages.
The local twist is what makes it a true Pueblo product. The market has offered house-made sausage with Pueblo chiles, blending Italian tradition with the region’s famous crop.
Shoppers can buy it in bulk, which is a real perk for families who cook in big batches. It freezes well for later meals and can stretch a grocery budget further than restaurant takeout.
Denver residents heading home have been known to stock up before hitting the highway. A cooler in the trunk is a wise move for anyone making the drive north.
The sausage and the premade pasta are often mentioned together as top picks. Pairing them makes for an easy weeknight dinner with a century of know-how behind it.
For residents who love supporting Colorado growers, the Pueblo chile connection adds extra meaning. It is a small example of how this family market has woven itself into southern Colorado life.
Next comes the deli counter, along with an important clock to watch.
7. The 3 PM Rule at the Deli Counter
Timing matters more here than at most delis. Sandwich service stops around 3 PM, even though the store stays open later.
That detail has caught out more than one hungry traveler. A family drove from Cañon City and arrived at 3:30, only to learn the sandwich window had already closed for the day.
The fix is simple: treat it as a lunch stop. Arriving before early afternoon gives the best shot at a made-to-order meal.
The ordering routine is easy once you know it. Head to the back, grab a paper bag near the deli and place your order.
Expect around $16 for a sandwich, which can sound steep at first. Many say half is enough for one meal, so the other half becomes dinner, which helps the value add up.
Group orders work well too. One road-trip crew picked up five for the drive, and others have taken lunch to a nearby park.
For parties, the market also prepares meat trays. One family served them at a dutch lunch for a daughter’s birthday, and the trays were a hit.
Next up is what the shop itself feels like inside.
8. Tight Aisles and Neighborhood Charm
Nobody would call this market spacious. It is a little cramped, and plenty of regulars say that is part of the charm.
The layout is old-fashioned and personal. Shoppers squeeze past one another, chat at the counter and often end up swapping cooking ideas.
It feels like a true neighborhood deli rather than a polished showroom. That throwback quality is exactly what draws people who miss the corner groceries of their childhood.
Retirees tend to love it, especially those with memories of Italian markets back East. Families find it welcoming too, since the staff is patient with little ones.
There is no seating, so it is not a place to linger over lunch. Think of it as a grab-and-go stop paired with a nearby park or a picnic at home.
Couples looking for a low-cost day trip may find it a fun anchor for an afternoon in Pueblo. It offers history, shopping and a meal without resort-town prices.
The small size also keeps things friendly and unhurried most of the time. Crowds can build at lunch, but the mood rarely turns rushed.
A few practical notes can make the trip go smoothly.
9. Hours, Parking and a Fair Verdict
Good planning saves a lot of disappointment here. The market opens at 9 AM and closes at 4:30 PM Monday through Friday.
Saturday hours run from 9 AM to 4 PM, and the shop is closed on Sundays. Remember that sandwich service wraps up around 3 PM.
Typical spending lands in the $10 to $20 range per person. That makes it an affordable outing compared with many sit-down spots along the Front Range.
Parking can be tight, so give yourself a few extra minutes to find a space nearby. Patience usually pays off.
Weekday mornings may be the calmest time to browse the shelves. Late morning works well for anyone hoping to shop first and grab lunch before the cutoff.
So is it worth the drive from Denver, Colorado Springs or Cañon City? For anyone who values family history, handmade cookies and friendly faces, the answer leans strongly toward yes.
This is not a flashy destination, and it does not try to be. It is a century-old family shop doing the same honest work it has always done.
Bring a cooler, arrive early and leave room in the trunk for a few extra treasures.
10.
Share this story
