Since 1973, Buster’s Place has been serving up classic American burgers and wings in Murfreesboro, earning a reputation that keeps locals coming back generation after generation. This no-frills burger joint on NW Broad Street has mastered the art of doing a few things exceptionally well, from their famous Buster Burger to their surprisingly addictive smoked wings. With over 1,450 Google reviews averaging 4.7 stars, this hometown favorite proves that when you nail the basics and treat people right, you don’t need fancy decor or a massive menu to build something that lasts.
The Buster Burger That Started It All
Walk into Buster’s Place and you’ll notice the flat-top grill right behind the bar, where cooks work their magic on burgers that have kept Murfreesboro residents loyal for half a century. The Famous Buster Burger isn’t trying to reinvent anything. Instead, it delivers exactly what a great burger should be: juicy, flavorful, and cooked to your exact specifications on that well-seasoned flat top.
What makes this burger stand out is the simplicity and quality. Fresh beef patties get grilled to order while you watch, and you can build your burger exactly how you want it. Regular customers swear by adding extras like bacon jam or pimento cheese to take things up a notch.
The beef itself is well-seasoned and cooked properly, with that perfect crust on the outside and the juiciness you ordered on the inside.
One thing you’ll notice from the reviews is consistency. People who’ve been coming here since the 1970s say the burger tastes just like they remember, while newcomers discover what all the fuss is about on their first visit. The portions are generous without being ridiculous, and the toppings are fresh.
You can order a single patty if you want a solid meal, or go for the double if you’re extra hungry. Just know that even the single is substantial. Some folks mention the meat could use more seasoning, but most find the flavor just right, especially when you add your preferred toppings and condiments.
The burger comes with your choice of sides, and while the crinkle-cut fries are popular, many regulars split their sides to get half fries and half onion rings. That way you get the best of both worlds. Whether you’re a lifelong Murfreesboro resident or just passing through Middle Tennessee, the Buster Burger delivers that classic American burger experience that never goes out of style.
Smoked Wings That Steal the Show
Here’s the thing about Buster’s Place that catches people off guard: they came for the burgers but can’t stop talking about the wings. These aren’t your typical buffalo wings dunked in fryer oil. Buster’s smokes their wings, giving them a flavor profile that has customers ordering extra dozens to take home before they even finish their meal.
The smoking process creates wings with crispy skin on the outside while keeping the meat tender and juicy inside. That smoky flavor penetrates all the way through, and you can taste the difference immediately. Customers consistently call them the best wings they’ve ever had, which is high praise in a state that takes its barbecue and smoked meats seriously.
You can order them plain to really appreciate that smoke flavor, or toss them in one of Buster’s sauces. The jalapeno ranch dipping sauce gets mentioned frequently in reviews as the perfect complement. The wings arrive hot and fresh, and the kitchen consistently nails the texture, achieving that ideal balance between crispy and succulent.
What’s interesting is how many people discover these wings by accident. A server recommends them, or they see another table’s order and decide to try some. Then they become converts, making the smoked wings their go-to order every visit.
Some customers admit they now come specifically for the wings and skip the burgers entirely.
The portion sizes are reasonable, and the wings make a great appetizer if you’re sharing, or a solid entree if you order enough for yourself. They’re not the cheapest wings in town, but the quality and unique preparation method justify the price. If you’ve only experienced traditional fried wings, Buster’s smoked version will change your perspective on what chicken wings can be.
Onion Rings Worth the Hype
With 49 mentions in customer reviews, the onion rings at Buster’s Place have developed their own cult following. These aren’t sad, limp afterthoughts or frozen circles reheated in a fryer. Buster’s onion rings come out hot, golden, and perfectly crispy, with a batter that stays crunchy even as they cool down a bit.
The onions themselves are thick-cut, giving you substantial rings with real onion flavor instead of mostly breading. When you bite into one, you get that satisfying crunch followed by the sweet, tender onion inside. The batter is well-seasoned and not too heavy, letting the onion taste come through rather than overwhelming it.
Many customers specifically mention choosing half fries and half onion rings as their side option, which tells you something about how good these rings are. People don’t usually split their sides unless both options are worth eating. The rings hold up well whether you eat them plain or dip them in ketchup, ranch, or whatever sauce you prefer.
Compared to other items on the menu, the onion rings get consistently positive feedback with very few complaints. While some customers have mentioned receiving undercooked fries on occasion, the onion rings seem to come out perfectly almost every time. That consistency matters when you’re building a reputation.
They’re substantial enough to share as an appetizer if you’re dining with others, or you can keep them all to yourself as a side. Either way, you’re getting a quality product that demonstrates the kitchen’s attention to detail. For something as simple as onion rings, Buster’s manages to elevate them into something memorable that keeps people coming back specifically to order them again.
Bacon Jam That Changes Everything
Sometimes a restaurant creates something so good that it becomes its own attraction. At Buster’s Place, that something is bacon jam. With 18 mentions in reviews, this sweet and savory topping has customers requesting it on everything from burgers to who knows what else.
Bacon jam combines crispy bacon pieces with caramelized onions, brown sugar, and spices, cooked down into a thick, spreadable condiment that adds incredible depth to whatever you put it on. The sweetness balances the salty, smoky bacon, while the texture gives you little crunchy bits mixed into the smooth base. On a burger, it transforms the whole experience.
What makes Buster’s version stand out is the balance. Some bacon jams are too sweet, tasting more like candy than a savory condiment. Others go too heavy on the bacon and become overwhelmingly salty.
Buster’s hits that sweet spot where every flavor component works together, enhancing your burger without overpowering the beef.
Regular customers know to add bacon jam to their order, and servers often recommend it to first-timers looking for something special. Once you try it, you understand why people keep mentioning it in their reviews. It’s the kind of topping that makes you think about your burger days later, wondering when you can get back for another one.
You can add bacon jam to any burger for an upcharge, and it’s absolutely worth the extra cost. Some people love it so much they ask for extra on the side. The jam also works beautifully on other menu items, though most folks stick with putting it on their Buster Burger where it really shines and creates that perfect combination of flavors and textures.
The Hometown Atmosphere That Feels Like Family
Step through the door at Buster’s Place and you immediately understand why people have been coming here for over 50 years. The atmosphere isn’t polished or trendy. Instead, it’s genuine, comfortable, and welcoming in a way that makes you feel like a regular even on your first visit.
The layout is simple and functional: bar seating with stools on the left where you can watch your meal being cooked on the flat-top grill, and dining room booths and tables on the right. The ceiling is covered with signs and memorabilia, giving you something to look at while you wait. It’s not fancy, but it doesn’t try to be, and that authenticity is part of the charm.
What really sets the atmosphere apart is the people. Staff members greet you warmly, make solid recommendations, and check in without hovering. Servers like Halle and Bailey get mentioned by name in reviews because they provide that small-town Tennessee hospitality that makes dining out feel personal.
They remember regulars, welcome newcomers, and genuinely seem happy to be there.
The place gets busy, especially during lunch and dinner rushes, so it can be loud and energetic. But the staff keeps things moving efficiently, and most customers report getting their food in 20 minutes or less even when it’s packed. You pay at the bar when you’re done, which adds to that casual, neighborhood joint vibe.
Owner AJ clearly cares about the business and the customers, personally responding to reviews and addressing any concerns. That hands-on approach creates a culture where employees take pride in their work and customers feel valued. The dim lighting and sports bar atmosphere work for casual dates, family dinners, or solo meals at the bar.
It’s the kind of place where you can relax, enjoy good food, and feel at home.
Fried Green Tomatoes with Southern Soul
Fried green tomatoes are a Southern classic, and Buster’s Place delivers them with the kind of quality you’d expect from a restaurant that’s been perfecting its recipes for five decades. With 13 mentions in customer reviews, these tangy, crispy appetizers have earned their spot on the menu alongside the burgers and wings.
The preparation follows traditional Southern methods: firm green tomatoes sliced thick, coated in a seasoned cornmeal batter, and fried until golden and crispy. The exterior provides that satisfying crunch while the tomato inside stays firm with just enough give, offering that characteristic tart flavor that makes fried green tomatoes so distinctive.
Unlike some restaurants that serve them soggy or over-breaded, Buster’s maintains the right ratio of coating to tomato. You taste the vegetable itself, not just a fried shell. The seasoning in the batter adds flavor without overwhelming the natural tang of the green tomato, and they arrive at your table hot and fresh from the fryer.
They work perfectly as an appetizer to share before your main course, or you can order them as a side if you want something different from the usual fries or onion rings. Many customers appreciate having this traditional Southern option on the menu, as it adds variety and shows the kitchen’s range beyond burgers and bar food.
The portion size is generous enough to share among two or three people, and they pair well with ranch dressing or remoulade if you like a dipping sauce. Some folks eat them plain to really appreciate the flavor. Either way, they represent that connection to Southern food traditions that Buster’s maintains while staying true to its burger joint roots.
They’re comfort food done right, with respect for the recipe and attention to execution.
Cheese Fries That Hit Different
Sometimes you want more than regular fries, and that’s where Buster’s cheese fries come into play. With 21 mentions in customer reviews, these loaded fries have become a favorite side option for people who want to indulge a little. They take the restaurant’s crinkle-cut fries and smother them in melted cheese, creating that perfect comfort food combination.
The base fries are cooked hot and crispy, with that classic crinkle-cut texture that holds up well under toppings. When the cheese gets added, it melts into all those ridges and crevices, giving you cheese in every bite. The fries stay relatively crispy even under the cheese if you eat them while they’re hot, though like all loaded fries, they’ll soften as they cool.
What customers appreciate is that Buster’s doesn’t skimp on the cheese. You get a generous amount that actually covers the fries rather than just a light drizzle. The cheese is melted properly, not just cold shredded cheese thrown on top, which makes a significant difference in taste and texture.
These work great as a side dish for your burger, or you can order them as an appetizer to share. They’re definitely indulgent, so they might not be an every-visit choice, but when you’re in the mood for something rich and satisfying, they deliver. Some people order them as their main meal, which tells you about the portion size.
The cheese fries represent that classic American bar food done well. Nothing fancy or complicated, just quality ingredients prepared properly and served hot. They’re the kind of side that makes you understand why people become regulars at a place like Buster’s, where even the simple menu items get the attention and care they deserve to taste exactly how they should.
Weekly Specials That Keep Things Interesting
After 50 years in business, Buster’s Place could easily coast on its classic menu items and call it a day. Instead, the restaurant keeps things fresh with weekly specials that give regular customers something new to try. The Texas Hold ‘Em Burger mentioned in reviews is just one example of how these limited-time offerings create excitement and keep people coming back.
These specials typically feature creative burger combinations that go beyond the standard menu, incorporating different toppings, sauces, or preparation methods. They’re announced weekly, giving regulars a reason to check in and see what’s new. For people who visit monthly or more often, these specials prevent the menu from feeling stale or repetitive.
What’s smart about this approach is that it lets the kitchen experiment and test new ideas without committing to expanding the permanent menu. If a special becomes wildly popular, it might earn a permanent spot. If it’s just okay, it rotates out and something else takes its place.
This keeps the core menu focused and manageable while still offering variety.
The specials maintain the same quality standards as the regular menu items. Customers report that the weekly burgers are just as well-prepared and generously portioned as the Famous Buster Burger. The kitchen doesn’t treat them as afterthoughts or use them to clear out ingredients.
They’re legitimate menu items that happen to be temporary.
For first-time visitors, the specials board gives you options beyond the classic burger, though most people recommend trying the original Buster Burger on your first visit to understand what the restaurant is all about. Once you’ve had that baseline experience, the weekly specials become a fun way to explore different flavor combinations while supporting a local business that’s been serving the community for over half a century and shows no signs of slowing down.
Share this story
