8 Church-Run Thrift Shops Around Rochester, New York Where A Ten Still Fills Your Arms

A ten-dollar bill does not stretch very far at most stores anymore, but a few places around Rochester still let it do…

8 Church-Run Thrift Shops Around Rochester, New York Where A Ten Still Fills Your Arms
8 Church-Run Thrift Shops Around Rochester, New York Where A Ten Still Fills Your Arms

A ten-dollar bill does not stretch very far at most stores anymore, but a few places around Rochester still let it do real work. These are thrift shops run by parishes, congregations, and church ministries, where donated clothes, books, dishes, and furniture get a second life at gentle prices.

Every purchase also helps support outreach work right here in Monroe County and beyond. If you like old-school bargains with a neighborly purpose, this list is for you.

1. Matthew’s Closet, Rochester, NY

Matthew’s Closet, Rochester, NY
© Matthew’s Closet, Rochester, NY

Morning shoppers have a short window here, and that is part of the charm. Matthew’s Closet keeps parish-style hours, opening 10 AM to 1 PM on Monday and Wednesday through Saturday.

The shop sits at 316 Bay St on Rochester’s northeast side and operates as an outreach of the local Catholic parish community connected to cabriniroc.org. Inside, you will find used clothing alongside household items, the kind of practical mix that makes a quick stop pay off.

It is an old-school thrift store in the best sense. Designer labels reportedly turn up at very friendly prices, and the staff keep the place welcoming with good music playing in the background.

Plan around the closed days on Tuesday and Sunday. Call 585-232-5160 if you want to confirm before heading over.

2. UMCL Thrift Shoppe, Livonia, NY

UMCL Thrift Shoppe, Livonia, NY
© UMCL Thrift Shoppe, Livonia, NY

Bag sales are the magic words in Livonia. At the UMCL Thrift Shoppe, you can pay for items one at a time or fill a bag and pay the bag sale price, which is exactly how a ten starts filling your arms.

The shop is the thrift ministry of the United Methodist Church of Livonia, located at 6 Spring St, a short drive south of Rochester in Livingston County. Expect a good variety of clothes and household items, with prices that stay very reasonable.

Hours are limited, so timing matters. Doors open Thursday and Friday from 9 AM to 3 PM and Saturday from 9 AM to 2 PM.

I would pair this one with a Saturday country drive. It is a quick visit, but a bag sale can make it a memorable one.

3. HOPE, Webster, NY

HOPE, Webster, NY
© HOPE, Webster, NY

Four letters say a lot about the mission behind this Webster stop. HOPE is the thrift and clothing outreach of Holy Trinity Catholic Church, found at 1450 Ridge Rd.

The focus is on helping neighbors get essential second-hand goods, especially clothing, at low cost. It also accepts clothing for recycling, so it works for donors as much as shoppers.

Restrooms are available on site, a small detail that matters when you are browsing with kids in tow. Details on the program are posted on the Holy Trinity parish website.

Hours are not widely posted, so call 585-265-6694 before you go. A quick check keeps the trip easy.

4. A Second Thought, East Rochester, NY

A Second Thought, East Rochester, NY
© A Second Thought, East Rochester, NY

Book lovers and furniture hunters can share a car on this run. A Second Thought stocks books, furniture, and other household items at 349 W Commercial St in East Rochester.

Sales support Heritage Christian Services, a faith-rooted nonprofit serving people with disabilities in the region. That gives every paperback and end table a purpose beyond your living room.

The finds are good, the prices are friendly, and the people running it are known for being kind. It is a solid quick-visit stop if you are already in the village.

Hours run Tuesday through Saturday from 10 AM to 5 PM. Those longer afternoon hours make it easier to fit in after work than some parish shops.

5. St. Vincent Depaul Society, Rochester, NY

St. Vincent Depaul Society, Rochester, NY
© St. Vincent Depaul Society, Rochester, NY

Friday is the only day that counts at this North Clinton Avenue spot. The St. Vincent de Paul store at 869 N Clinton Ave opens Fridays from 11 AM to 4 PM.

The Society of St. Vincent de Paul is an international Catholic lay ministry with a long tradition of person-to-person charity. Here in Rochester, that tradition shows up as help outfitting individuals and families at minimal cost.

Clothing recycling is part of the operation too, so bring a bag of outgrown items when you visit. It keeps the cycle of giving moving.

With just one open day a week, mark the calendar. Call 585-338-2330 or check svdprochester.org for updates.

6. The Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center, Rochester, NY

The Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center, Rochester, NY
© The Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center, Rochester, NY

Space is the selling point out in Greece. The Salvation Army Family Store at 800 Elmridge Center Dr is a roomy thrift store with a large selection of clothing and furniture.

The Salvation Army is a church as well as a charity, and its stores help fund its programs. Clothing racks cover women, men, and kids, which makes this a smart stop for back-to-school shopping.

Prices here are reportedly among the best in the area. In-store pickup is offered, handy if you spot a larger piece.

Hours are generous, Monday through Saturday from 9 AM to 6 PM. That makes it one of the easiest stops on the list to fit into a busy week.

7. The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center, Rochester, NY

The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center, Rochester, NY
© The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center, Rochester, NY

Not every store has handed checkout over to a machine. At the Salvation Army on West Henrietta Road, a real person still rings you up, and the line tends to move quickly.

The store at 3501 W Henrietta Rd is known for being clean and well organized. You will find a wide spread of second-hand clothing, household items, and furniture.

Items often cost a fraction of big-box prices. For anyone shopping along the Henrietta retail strip, it makes a sensible first stop.

Open Monday through Saturday, 9 AM to 6 PM. Drop off donations while you are there.

8. Salvation Army Family Store, Batavia, NY

Salvation Army Family Store, Batavia, NY
© Salvation Army Family Store, Batavia, NY

Ninety-nine cents for Levi’s is the kind of price that justifies a drive west. The Salvation Army Family Store in Batavia has reportedly turned up name-brand jeans and like-new purses at that price.

You will find it at 96 Jackson St, about 35 miles west of Rochester in Genesee County. The shop carries an extensive selection of apparel and furniture.

Prices vary, so check tags and condition carefully. Furniture runs higher, while clothing is where the deep bargains tend to hide.

Hours are Monday through Saturday, 9 AM to 6 PM. It is an easy add-on for a Thruway trip, and a good place to end this list with your arms full.

Share this story

Leave a response

Your email address stays private. Required fields are marked with an asterisk.