The vault at 1 Mill Street no longer guards anyone’s savings. It’s part of Broad Street Books, a Branchville shop where a former bank building has found a much more entertaining use.
The high ceilings and old vault give the place its first surprise, but the shelves provide the reason to stay. Used books sit alongside new, rare, and collectible titles, with enough subjects to send a browser happily off course.
Come in looking for a novel and you might leave with a book about New Jersey history, a jazz CD, and an unfamiliar author you found while searching for something else. Broad Street Books has been buying and selling books since 2003, and its collection extends beyond what fits in the storefront.
That makes this Sussex County stop especially good for people who enjoy the hunt: there’s plenty to see, and no need to know exactly what you want when you walk through the door.
Broad Street Books Gives an Old Branchville Bank a New Story
A bank lobby makes an unusual first impression for a bookstore. The ceiling rises above shelves crowded with books, while the building’s sturdy proportions hint at the job it once had.
This was the First National Bank in Branchville; today, the same space holds Broad Street Books. The old setting gives the shop character without turning it into a museum.
You can admire the room for a moment, then get straight to pulling books off the shelves. The shop has its own history, too.
Founded in 2003, Broad Street Books describes itself as an independent, veteran-led and woman-led business. It buys and sells used books while also carrying new, rare, scholarly, and collectible titles.
That mix suits the building. A former bank feels like a fitting home for books that people have kept, passed along, and decided were worth finding again.
Branchville adds to the appeal. The store sits at 1 Mill Street in the borough’s small downtown, so a visit feels different from browsing a shop tucked into a busy shopping center.
There’s no need to rush past the architecture on the way to a particular section. Look up when you enter, take in the old bank room, and then follow whichever shelf catches your eye.
Some bookstores are best approached with a list. This one gives you a good reason to put the list in your pocket for a while.
The Former Bank Vault Holds a Different Kind of Treasure
The vault is the detail you’ll remember when you tell someone about this place. A room once meant to secure money now belongs to a bookstore, and that reversal is wonderfully suited to Broad Street Books.
It’s also worth pausing over in person. The vault connects the shop’s past to its present more clearly than any sign could: the building was designed to protect things people valued, and it still holds things people come looking for.
Of course, the real pleasure of a used bookstore isn’t knowing what’s inside before you arrive. It’s spotting a title you haven’t seen in years, finding an older edition of a favorite, or noticing a subject you didn’t expect to be interested in.
The bank setting gives those small discoveries an extra bit of fun. A vault is a place built around the idea that something behind its door deserves a closer look.
There are interesting details beyond it, too. In a description Broad Street Books shared with the New Jersey Bookstore Crawl, the shop mentioned Tolkien artwork, a hand-carved braille map, and other objects worked into an in-store “I SPY” experience.
Those touches give you something to notice between shelves, especially if you’re visiting with someone whose reading tastes differ from yours. You can spend time looking at the building, searching for a book, or doing a little of both.
At Broad Street Books, the old bank isn’t simply a backdrop. It’s part of what makes browsing memorable.
Shelves of Used Books Make Browsing an Adventure
Start in the section you came for. Then allow for the very real possibility that you’ll end up somewhere else.
Broad Street Books carries enough used books to make browsing feel like a search with pleasant detours, and its inventory reaches beyond the retail floor. The shop told the New Jersey Bookstore Crawl that its collection spans three buildings, including private libraries acquired from artists, academics, and industry leaders.
A single visit offers only a glimpse of everything it handles. That range changes the way you look at a shelf.
An art book might have come from someone who spent years building a collection. A scholarly title may be exactly the older edition a student or researcher has been trying to find.
Other books are simply waiting for a reader willing to try an unfamiliar subject. You don’t have to know a volume’s backstory to enjoy discovering it, but a shop built from so many collections has a different feel from one stocked only with this month’s releases.
The store also gives browsers a useful choice. If you have a title or author in mind, you can ask about it or check the shop’s specialty online catalog before your visit.
If you’d rather wander, the shelves can take the lead. The online inventory lists books available for in-store purchase or mail order, while the storefront offers the part no catalog can reproduce: noticing one spine while reaching for another.
That’s how a quick stop becomes an afternoon spent deciding which finds you can bear to leave behind.
Rare Finds and Leather-Bound Classics Reward a Closer Look
A handsome old book has a way of interrupting even the most focused shopping trip. Broad Street Books carries rare and collectible titles as well as used and new books, and its leather-bound classics give readers another reason to slow down.
You may arrive hunting for a paperback and find yourself examining an edition you’d happily make room for at home. The stock changes as books are bought and sold, so the interesting part is seeing what happens to be there on the day you visit.
Collectors can dig into the shop’s more specialized offerings, but you don’t need to be one to appreciate them. An older printing can be a gift for someone devoted to a particular author.
A well-kept classic might be the copy you choose to read rather than save for display. Even a book outside your budget can be worth a closer look for its cover, illustrations, or publishing history.
The point is to stay curious about the object in your hands as well as the words inside it. There’s a practical side to that curiosity.
If you’re seeking a specific title, the shop’s online catalog lets you search its specialty stock and contact the store about ordering. If you’re bringing books to sell, call ahead first.
Broad Street Books says it considers interesting collections and focuses particularly on academic and scholarly books, textbooks, and CDs. Those details make the store useful for serious book hunters, but they don’t change the pleasure of simply coming across a beautiful volume you weren’t expecting.
Books on Nearly Every Subject Share Space With Jazz and Classical Music
A chess book, a volume on architecture, children’s stories, and a jazz recording can all figure into the same visit here. Broad Street Books lists subjects ranging from art, photography, and design to science, philosophy, poetry, transportation, gardening, and mythology.
It also carries children’s and young adult books, plus a substantial selection of classical and jazz CDs. The result is a shop where people with different interests can split up to browse and still have plenty to show one another afterward.
The subject range is especially useful if you read nonfiction. You can follow a specific interest into the relevant section, whether that means books on trains, religion, nature, or cooking.
You can also let neighboring topics pull you in a new direction. Someone looking through music books might stop at the CDs; someone searching for a gardening guide might leave with a book about local wildlife.
Broad Street Books leaves room for both the purposeful shopper and the person who has no idea what they’re after yet. The music is more than a token rack beside the register.
Classical and jazz are named specialties, and the store buys CDs as well as books. For people who still enjoy choosing an album, opening its case, and giving it a proper listen, that’s one more collection to explore.
It also makes the shop a good shared stop for a family or a couple with different tastes. One person can look for a novel, another can work through the history shelves, and someone else can search the recordings.
They’ll all have a good reason to take their time.
What to Know Before Visiting Broad Street Books
You’ll find Broad Street Books at 1 Mill Street, Branchville, NJ 07826. Its posted hours are 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday through Saturday and 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. Sunday.
That earlier Sunday closing is worth remembering if you’re making the trip from elsewhere in New Jersey. The shop lists 862-268-5184 as its phone number, so you can check on a particular book or confirm the hours before setting out.
Give yourself enough time to browse. There’s a lot to take in between the old bank features, the used books, the specialty titles, and the music.
If you need a particular book, search the store’s online catalog or get in touch ahead of time; its inventory is larger than what you’ll see on the retail floor. If you’re hoping to sell a collection, the store specifically asks customers to call before bringing books in.
The historic building has steps and changes in floor level inside. In information provided to the New Jersey Bookstore Crawl, the shop said visitors who need help entering can call ahead.
That same listing notes free street and lot parking. Once inside, you can follow a plan or ignore it completely.
The address and hours are easy enough to pin down; the book you’ll remember finding probably won’t be the one you expected.
Share this story
